The Regressive Movement

Improved Essays
A regressive movement masked as progressive to remove historic monuments that depict a dark past.

I use to be for their removal but have recently changed my stance.

Those removed in New Orleans is over, but this movement is far from over. If this regressive movement isn't contested, I fear that a slippery slope with no end in sight. Once the Confederate memorabilia is removed across the country, these revisionists will turn their cross-hairs to objects like Mt. Rushmore as two of the four owned slaves.

Here are my thoughts on how we behave as a society moving forward.

I am not denying that these inanimate objects elicit a variety of emotional responses from an individual based on the underlying meaning of why it exists. These objects
…show more content…
To expand on the history and add more prominent men/women of history from all races, sexes, and creeds to represent many viewpoints of that era.

let us add to the history, not subtract.

I have heard citizens speak from all backgrounds who were directly affected by the atrocities that these symbols represent; who are able to transcend past feeling oppressed by these objects just as much as those who feel oppressed, upset, angry, and any other negative emotion. That being said, we have every right as citizens to experience these reactions and we do not have the right to not feel these reactions.

To remove the monuments due to individuals experiencing negative reactions does not progress society in any way other granting those who gave power to an otherwise powerless object some sort of short-term relief until the next scapegoat is acquired.

Have we reached 100% equality
…show more content…
As a culture, of course not, but these inanimate objects have not been impeding progress nor have they revoked any rights. We have been collectively progressing further with equal rights all while these monuments stood.

So, if these objects have not been impeding progress, then I suggest that removing them does nothing to progress any societal narrative. I would put forth that this movement to remove/hide/stow away painful reminders of history does nothing at best and regresses us at worse.

What do we gain by removing history that we could not gain by adding? Add more prominent figures from the history of all races, sexes, creeds.. why take away?

I am not necessarily making a direct argument for preserving history either as that implies that these actions erase history. I do not think this, but I do think to put them in museums hides them from anyone learning anything new as I would assume that most people visiting museums would already have an understanding of whichever museum that they are visiting. Let us wait until they can no longer be preserved in the public and then stow them away for safekeeping in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Famous Stone Mountain Confederate Carving The symbolic carving on the famous Stone Mountain is a sincere rendition of U.S. history. The carving displays three confederate leaders of the Civil War, and after forty-seven years of beauty, the memorials presence is now in jeopardy. This amazing carving has a dutiful home at Stone Mountain Park, because with it comes great historic value, a large financial support to Georgia state parks, and a genuine memorial embracing the struggles of our fellow men and women who have fought. The first reason why the Stone Mountain carving should remain, is due to the historic value it gives to the Confederate Army.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I do believe that they should be considered as more of an artifact, as the mayor mentioned in his speech. They are a part of history and I understand that it is something that we should not forget, but I say that it would be better to move them to a museum or so. It is not good to look up to someone whose views are something that we have worked hard to abolish. I do not see why there have a statue of someone who fought against their own country due to wanting to keep slavery in place. I see that the statues are also considered art and for that reason, keeping them in a museum is a more exceptional decision.…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Robert Kuttner's article, "Goodbye, Columbus", he constructs a clear point about why tearing down statues of our founding fathers, those who laid a foundation for this country, would make no substantial impact on the healing of our nation. Yes, they did partake in the institution of slavery as made clear through history and the Constitution itself, but what they stand for is far more prideful and celebratory then the Confederate leaders Bannon and other right-winged conservatives are praising. Change can always be made, but tearing down statues that hold a significant place in this country will do nothing more than to make Bannon and his followers right. In contrast to Kuttner's writing, Dennis Prager wrote an extremely opinionated and…

    • 237 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whilst building a monument, some people disregard major factors. These major factors consist mainly of, if the finances needed to build and maintain the structure are available as well as if the monument will be a desired as a loved piece in the society around it. However, if these main factors were to be ignored, the structure can be left incomplete as well as it can be offensive to those that are affected by it. Without the proper funds being available building a monument can be problematic.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    (pg.6) I agree with Landrieu, society evolutionists and some things are looked at from what they were year ago to 50 years ago. It is our job as upcoming adults to not let bad history repeat itself, everyday we see much more racism and racist violent acts like we saw during the civil war. Landrieu does not want to create a barrier between those who are against and for the taking down of the statues he makes a very powerful statement showing he…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should cities be allowed to take down Confederate monuments? Type your argument below. Cities should be allowed to take down Confederate monuments. Leaving up Confederate monuments can upset citizens who have to see them. In the article “PRO/CON: Should cities be allowed to take down Confederate monuments?”…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Daniel Davidson, the author of “Why We Should Keep The Confederate Monuments Right Were They Are”, provides several arguments against the removal of the statues. One of his reasons to preserve the monuments is in the interest of honoring those who fought for their statehood and passed away. Davidson’s argument revolves around the grieving process for descending family members, and the necessary remembrance for generations to come. Davidson writes that necessity for these statues arose decades later, once many of the remaining veterans died.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are monuments that have a huge sentimental meaning while others don't. There is a monument that was made that was a man holding a crustacean. Is that really that important to history that they need to actually make a moment out of it. Not really. "No one seemed to want the man and his lobster."…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Confederate Flag Controversy For a long time coming in the United States people are finally saying how they feel about the Confederate Flag. Some people believe it is part of their heritage, others think it is a sign of racism and disrespect. People tend not to pay attention to the real meaning of the flag. Everyone and each family has their own meaning for the Confederate Flag but the straight forward meaning this that is was the Confederates flag in a war that took place almost 150 years ago.…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reform movements including religion, temperance, abolition, and women's rights tried to expand democratic ideals in the years 1825 to 1850. However, certain movements such as trying to make America a utopia, failed to show the American ideals of a democratic society. The reform movements were spurred by the Second Great Awakening, which began in New England in the late 1790's, and would eventually spread throughout the country. The Second Great Awakening differed from the First in that people were now believed to be able to choose whether or not to believe in God.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To many other Detroit residents, they see the same thing, but to different degrees. For example, in 2004, two white American men painted The Fist white in protest of two white police officers killed recently while on duty. They left a sign saying, “courtesy of fighting whites”. To those men, The Fist did not represent “Joe Louis, the boxer”; it represented “Joe Louis, the proud black man”. It represented something they were against, or even scared of, and that something is more than just Joe Louis himself, with all of these different reactions to the memorial, the conclusion that we can come to is that sculpture is deeper than just representing one man-it represents and…

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Not for Admiration, but for Commemoration: Keeping the Confederate Statues Erect With less than one hundred years since it was established, the United States of America split gravely during the historical Civil War. Over the course of four long years, America witnessed the bloodiest battles fought on American soil. After the war was won by the Union and Reconstruction was in full swing, African Americans were given rights previously unavailable to them due to their status in the American social landscape. Yet inequality among colored people versus white people has still raged on for centuries since. Despite the Confederate defeat and shameful shadow left on the South for the decades to follow, Confederate statues remained and more were built to commemorate the fallen Southern generals and soldiers.…

    • 1731 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But, I would like to add something-many believe we learn something from statues and I hope that is true, but I know many just glance. Maybe in the place where the statue stood there should be a sign that says what was once here, the history of that person/event, and why it was removed. Basically, I want a plaque that says we learned something. It is now taking us far too long to realize we cannot change the…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The progressive movement aimed to restore the economic opportunity and help the lives of Americans. I think that the progressive movement was successful at accomplishing their goals of protecting social welfare, creating economic reform, and fostering efficiency. The progressive movement completed their goal of protecting social welfare in many ways. One way they accomplished their goals was reducing the hours of work for women, thanks to Florence Kelly.…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most dramatic movements of the progressive era was known as the muckraker movement. The movement was characterised by the use of sensational journalism that targeted the social issues prevalent during the time as such it encompassed the most sweeping reforms of business and government in U.S. history. The title of Muckrakers was first used by Teddy Roosevelt, who compared them to people who would literally use rakes to clear out waste (muck) the title accurately captures the nature of Muckrakers whose goal was to clean out corruption in the United States. Muckraking journalism involved in-depth research and factually documented accounts as opposed to opinion to serve as a trusted source for the people. They focused on two related…

    • 150 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays