The Red Convertible By Louise Erdrich And The Brothers

Better Essays
A Broken Puzzle “Nothing is so painful to the human mind as a great and sudden change” (Shelley). The two stories “The Red Convertible” by Louise Erdrich and “The Brothers” by Lysley Tenorio demonstrates that a sudden change can turn a lifetime of memories into betrayals, In “The Red Convertible,” the brothers Henry and Lyman has a strong bond filled with amusement and adoration but disintegrates as a result of an unexpected event that happens to Henry. In comparison, in “The Brothers,” the brother Eric who later becomes Erica, reveals to the world on national television his change in identity. This event shocks his mother and brother Edmond, causing their familiarity to drift apart. Both stories share a similar obstacle that the brothers …show more content…
After the death of Erica, caused by an ‘asthma’ attack, Edmond, her brother flashbacks to the time when the two were together, alive and well, “... joking like the closest of brothers” (8). These flashbacks illustrate the very close bond they use to have and causes Edmond to reminisce their childhood. As a result, Edmond also carries a sense of regret for not being there for Erica when he was needed …show more content…
In the beginning, the brothers were inseparable from each other and the car, they went places together in that car throughout that one whole summer. But after at least three years, Henry comes back from the army, everything about their relationship, their brotherly bond changes dramatically. Lyman tries to recover their brotherly bond by beating up their car and “[making] it look just as beat up as [he] could” (246) and making Henry repair it. “It was spring. The sun was shining very bright” (246), Lyman says. Spring is a metaphor for a new beginning, this implies that after the repairs on the convertible is done, maybe their brotherly bond will bloom again. But it wasn’t until the brothers felt like they were together again when Henry jumps and drowns in the river. That is also when Lyman has an epiphany, he realizes that his brother is in a better place now, and decides to let the car go with his brother, into the river. The car, now in the water with Henry symbolizes closure and burial of their brotherly bond, this allows the both of them to move on without each

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Once the car was fixed they take a picture where Henry finally smiled and took a trip to the river; the first one in years. On this trip Lyman finally starts to get his brother back but it was all an illusion and in the end Henry waded into the river and was never to be seen again. As a result of this tragedy Lyman pushes the car into the water with the engine running and the headlights on. At first it appears he does this in hope of seeing Henry somewhere in the murky water and the crashing current but soon realizes that every time he would look at that car he would remember the night he both gained and lost his older brother. Although it also appears Lyman lost a part of himself among the murky waters of the river on that horrible night.…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He proceeds to beat and break the car hoping that Henry will turn his attention to it and rebuild it. The beaten car represents the exhausted relationship between the brothers and by rebuilding it, Lyman hopes to mend the broken bond they once shared. In a way it helped him psychologically when Henry began fixing the car. He was more at ease and more social with Lyman and his family. Soon after he is finished repairing the car he and Lyman set out on a trip to the Red River.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Red Convertible Essay

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Red Convertible by- Louise Erdrich, is a short story about two Indian brothers, Lyman and Henry, who buy a red convertible together. The story starts out with the brothers losing their jobs, and end up buying a convertible together. They spend the summer on a happy road trip, but the story soon turns into a tragedy. In the beginning of the story, the car symbolizes freedom. However, as the story progresses, the symbolism of the car changes.…

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Later on the same light is referenced by Nick to symbolize how the light looks to be rising out of the ocean and must have looked to settlers of the new nation. “Jay Gatsby pursues Daisy knowing that her sense of happiness and good life depends on money and property” (Callahan 149). He asks his neighbor Nick to do him the favor of asking Daisy over for tea, so they could finally met again. Because it has been a long time since Gatsby and Daisy have seen each other, things were uncomfortable at first. After Nick has left them alone for thirty minutes he returned and it had seemed as if no time had passed between them.…

    • 1292 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They travel all summer long. When Henry was stationed in Khe Sanh Lyman wrote to him just so he could be informed about the car. " I wrote him back several times. I kept him informed all about the car" ( Erdrich 4). He noticed that something was wrong with his brother Henry.…

    • 2049 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The story ends with the city of Kahani remembering its name and the people and city are happy again (Rushdie,208). A reader can draw that remembering one’s identity brings happiness. Looking further into the story there are multiple layers of the power of memory and how memory is affected. The main plot of the story is Haroun’s quest to help his father regain his talent to tell stories. Part of the reason Rashid Kalife has last the talent of telling stories is because his wife disappeared with a clerk and Rashid is depressed and he is forever stuck on 11 am just like his son, despite in the story the reason for his loss of ability to tells stories was his story water was cut off (Rushdie ,57).…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, young Nick moves to West Egg in his effort to find financial success in bond salesmanship. Soon after moving to East Egg, he visits his cousin Daisy and her Husband Tom. The visit was initially on good terms; however, Nick would only discover the devoid morals of veracity that defines the extensively wealthy. This striking enlightenment came upon Nick immediately after observing a fight between Gatsby and Tom over Daisy’s love, at the Plaza Hotel. The entire day was filled with a stressful, awkward atmosphere due to Tom’s recent discovery of his wife’s adultery, preceding the physical discord at the hotel.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In The Chosen, by Chaim Potok, one theme wove its way throughout the entire story: friendship. It shaped Danny and Reuven’s life, and even affected both of their fathers’ lives as well. Friendship played a tremendous role when Danny felt depressed because of his experimental phycology class, as Reuven’s father had a heart attack needed hospitalization, and most of all, as Danny and his father overcame their silence. The story has the idea of friendship all through it, yet friendship affects these three situations most of all. When Danny and Reuven met for the first time, they both hated each other, but through the forgiveness, the two boys became some of the strongest friends ever written.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The car gave them a since of freedom, or new life. "We owned it together until his boots filled with water on a windy night and he bought out my share. "(Erdich, 1) This quote foreshadows what is going to happen to the convertible, the brothers relationship, and Henry. After Henry leaves for the Vietnam War the convertible is put a way, like how Henry and Lyman’s relationship is ended for the time. Lyman does not feel that it is right to drive it while Henry is gone.…

    • 1771 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In 1996, he wrote a love story called The Notebook, which has also been turned into a movie watched over and over by many. It’s a story about a young man named Noah who falls in love with a girl named Allie in the heat of summer in 1946. Due to many reasons they are forced to go in different directions. He recalls that summer as the best time of his life and cannot seem to forget her even after fighting in World War II and not seeing her for nearly 14 years. Noah returns home to North Carolina from the war and tries to start settling down by restoring a house he purchased but he is constantly haunted by the memories of his love for his summer girl.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays