Mexican American War Dbq Analysis

Superior Essays
Wars are what define the success of a country; if you win, then the country is considered strong; if you lose, the country is considered weak. This, however, does not determine how justified the country was in deciding to go to war. The Mexican American War marked the first time the U.S. fought on foreign soil. This war began over a border dispute between America and Mexico. It started with Texas gaining independence from Mexico in 1836. At first the U.S. did not want Texas to join the Union due to the issue of whether it would be admitted as a slave state or a free state, either would upset the balance between the two. While this was going on, Mexico threatened that any attempt at the annexation of Texas would lead to a war. Texas was annexed shortly after the 1844 election of James …show more content…
President Polk was a strong believer in that Manifest Destiny was the most important focus of America. This is why when Texas was annexed in 1846, Polk would do just about anything to gain even more land for America. Polk added Texas to the Union along with the land the U.S. received from the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo which completed his dream. Polk decided to enter a war which was avoidable due to that very dream. Before the war was officially declared, “Polk began to prepare a war message to Congress, justifying hostilities on the grounds of Mexican refusal to pay U.S claims and refusal to negotiate with Slidell. Polk claimed that Mexico had “invaded our territory and shed American blood on American soil” (“Mexican). It had later turned out that the bloodshed took place on Mexican territory making it America who had invaded foreign territory which also made America responsible for starting the war. Polk’s actions were therefore completely unjustified since it is historically proven that the war messages Polk sent to Congress to convince them to declare war consisted of lies and exaggeration neither of which are

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Was America justified in going to war with Mexico? Before April 25, 1846, American you know today wasn't the same If America didn’t go to war with Mexico, American would only be half of the size it was today. This all started because Texas declared its independence from Mexico. Mexico wasn’t so thrilled about Texas actions. Which, leads to the question, was America justified to war with Mexico?…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Polk’s “War Message to Congress”, given in May of 1846. In his message Polk justified his need for a declaration of war against Mexico based on the alleged “…wrongs perpetrated by Mexico upon our citizens throughout a long period of years…” (p. 75). Specifically though, Polk thoroughly emphasized the event of Mexican’s shedding the blood of American citizens on American soil as the main reason for going to war. Polk was playing on Americans’ pride and nationalism as there have been very few times, if any, that the United States have allowed any attack on its citizens or the country in general to go unanswered, so why let a situation as severe as this go? Lastly, as Polk insisted, it is the country’s and its citizens’ duty to “…vindicate with decision [to go to war for] the honor, the rights, and the interests of [the] country.” (p. 75).…

    • 1006 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cause Of Manifest Destiny

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Mexican-American War was result of this belief and this caused a lot of suffering for many Mexicans, as well as many Native Americans. The second cause of the Mexican-American war was the Texas War of Independence from Mexico. In 1836, after Mexico won independence from Spain, Texas rebelled against the Mexican government to become free and with the help of US, Texas won its independence. Texas, in return, wanted to join the Union in the US; however the United States did not want a conflict with Mexico, and turned down the request. When US decided to purchase Texas and add onto its territory, Mexico refused and this caused tension.…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Justified Americans As the army knows, war is not always easy. The Americans went to war with Mexico to fight over Texas in 1846. At the time, James K. Polk was in office as president. He was a strong supporter of the Manifest Destiny. The Manifest Destiny was believed as God’s plan to extend American territory.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Polk took presidency in 1845, he made the acquisition of California known as a proposition he intended to complete while in office. He was known as a model of manifest destiny, an impulsive expansionist who desired the western pacific ports and territory for the states, despite the Mexican Republic owning the land. The Mexican government denied Polk 's request to purchase the land, and as a result Polk appointed troops to the disputed lands between the Nueces River and the Rio Grande. An African American Newspaper, "The National Era", saw this idea of manifest destiny as an act of war, stating that the slaves could "lift [their] exulting eyes...your white masters have new victims found." The slaves felt that the American people would do nothing to stop at acquiring the new land, even if it led to war.…

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He would go to extreme measures for a large territory such as Texas. Texas, a large territory, had the choice to be annexed to either the United States or Mexico. Both countries were fighting over it. The American slaveholding families triggered fighting against the Mexicans, who favored freedom. Polk figured that if a war started between both countries, the spoils could come out much more rewarding than simply Texas.…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So, American blood was not shed on American soil. Furthermore, President Polk’s claim does not account for the battles circumstance. The background essay explains that the United States’ government was aware that the annexation of Texas would anger the Mexican Officials. Therefore, the United States must have “provoked the war” as Howard Zinn suggested. The idea of provoking the war implies that the war’s happening is the fault of the American people.…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Mexican War

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages

    was justified in going to war with Mexico, there were reasons they weren’t justified. President Polk believed in manifest destiny and was, in fact, looking to start a fight if that's what was needed to fulfill that dream. “Polk was a strong supporter of Manifest Destiny… President Polk had a reason for going to war” (Roden, 317). Texas, however, didn’t belong to Mexico and the war had started because Texas was annexed into the United States. Manifest Destiny may have been a selfish and childish dream but Mexico wasn’t the best qualified in taking care of the land in the first place and would have eventually lost it anyways.…

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Other conflicts that President Van Burren viewed if he was to accept Texas into the country was the situation of free and slave states. The United States citizens were going to be against the idea of accepting a state that was economically composed of slavery as it would weaken the country’s economic flow. Yet in 1844, President John Tyler renegotiated the annexation with the Republic of Texas ending with a Treaty of Annexation. The Treaty of Annexation was passed on April 12, 1844, this treaty made Mexico and the United States lose the relation between them and accept the Texas Annexation. After all the conflicts with Mexico, Texas was annexed into the United…

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mexico believed that America got hold of Texas from them and completely the disregarded basic law. President José Joaquin De Herrera called the people of Mexico to protect their independence because they were, “threatened by the usurpation of Texas” (Document 1). All of Mexico was led to believe that Texas was stolen from them. In a political cartoon from 1846 America was portrayed Uncle Sam and he was kicking a Mexican across the Rio Grande, and it is apparent that America was meant to appear much larger than Mexico implying that they were no match for America (Document 14). This political cartoon was created to send the message that America would continue to expand their power and would stop whoever tried to rebell.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays