The Pros And Cons Of Utopian Socialism

Superior Essays
The economical, political and sociological movement known as Utopian Socialism appeared during the first years of the nineteenth century. It was fuelled by the Industrial Revolution’s decrease in living standards. The poor were mostly affected by the consequences of specialisation. Industrialisation destroyed labourers’ traditional way of life. For most, life became monotonous and working conditions hard. The working class engaged in riots and rebellions throughout the first half of the nineteenth century. Following these social protests, labour organisations were created, making the upper class worried.

The movement rose in England as a protest against capitalism and private property. Emerging contemporary currents differ in some aspects
…show more content…
However, people always tend to desire more. Karl Marx was very critic of these theories, giving them the name of Utopian. Marx’s approach to socialism is in a more scientific way. The difference between both tendencies is that Utopian socialism tend to think of the perfect world without taking too much into consideration how it would work.

Today, we live in a mostly neoliberal world. “Neoliberalism sees competition as the defining characteristic of human relations. It redefines citizens as consumers”, as described in The Guardian’s article by George Monbiot (2016). With a few exceptions, the dominant ideology is that of the free market. According to Giddens and Sutton (2017), the capitalist component of the economy promotes the constant revision of technology in order to expand production. Consumerism dominates our daily lives. As it happened during the Industrial Revolution, society is screaming for a change. The periods where new ideologies were born are characterised by a sense of tumult and of a cultural and financial dislocation, much like today, as Kapur explains (2016). We are reminded of the failure of utopias in the past centuries. These unsuccessful attempts are due to the hypocrisy in most socialists. Egoism, acquisitiveness, competition and all other human nature’s faults
…show more content…
For example, as in the Third Reich or ISIS. Weather we like it or not there is a “tyranny in the womb of every utopia”, as Kapur quoted from Bertrand de Jouvenel. One thing is true, utopias are not considered as naive as they used to before. On the contrary, critics of this ideology, nowadays, are perceived as cynics, leaving the door opened for supporters of utopian socialism and similar ideologies that encourage social equity.

According to the “Economics: An Introduction to Traditional and Progressive View”, Gracchus Babeuf was the precursor of Revolutionary Communism. He believed that in order to achieve an egalitarian socialist state a revolt would be necessary to topple the existing government by force. Also, if the revolt were to be successful, a period of dictatorship would be necessary to establish the new

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    This very short essay, from the much longer “Critique of the Gotha Program,” highlights some of the key concepts of Marx’ ideas about the situation society would be in directly following the dissolution of capitalism. This is where the concepts of each according to his ability, to each according to his work, and “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs” are formulated. These two concepts lay the foundation for the Marxist transition from capitalism, to a socialist society, and then culminate in the Marxist utopia of Communism. From a…

    • 1317 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The effects of Socialism can be clearly shown in Australia through the above sources. It can be seen that the sources show that socialism ideas of equality for the working class has penetrated Australian society. In the first source, a political cartoon representing the fight of workers against capitalists on 23 May 1903. The tired, thin man labelled “Labour” wields a sword represents the working class of Australia striking out against the larger, more powerful capitalism which was a movement that occurred during this time period.…

    • 105 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Occupy Wall Street movement can be analyzed through the lens of Karl Marx and David Harvey. Harvey critiques the idea of self-regulating markets, or neoliberalism, because not everyone has an equal opportunity in the market and without any state intervention it becomes unfair to those stuck at the bottom. Marx writes about the class struggles between the proletariat and the bourgeois. The bourgeois have purchased the labor of the proletariat at a minimal price and therefore have alienated the proletariat from their own work, but they have also given the proletariat the knowledge of how to work the means of production, so Marx predicted a social revolution would happen where the proletariat will gain power. Well, that did not happen, but…

    • 2077 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marx believed that a violent overthrow of capitalism would lead to international socialism based on common ownership of land and capital. This would transform into an ideal state of communism, which is a worker-governed society based on the guiding concept “from each according to ability, and to each according to need” (Bolotta, Hawkes, Mahoney, Piper, 2002, pg. 58). This theory influenced many revolutions that would take place in the world. For example, the Russian Revolution in 1917, led by Lenin who said he has the philosophical heir to Marx (Schaff, 2009). Both Marx and Lenin are considered to be the two most important figures in the development of communism in the Soviet Union.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The author wake up in 2000 and discover the new world and how socialism turned to be a great system for everyone. Bellamy presented his system in a different which attract all type of people. “Bellamy avoided the s word by euphemistically calling his system nationalism instead, since socialism suggested to him "the odor of petroleum and strange sexual practices. " Nationalism benignly mixes Christianity's golden rule and capitalism's economies-of-scale.” ( golb).…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Robert Owen Inequality

    • 2560 Words
    • 11 Pages

    During the nineteenth century the gap of inequality was one that resulted in a wealth gap of rich and poor with very little in between. The lack of equality and expansion of cities filled with the new working class resulted in the desire of people for more. Following the French Revolution came the first signs of modern socialism and a growing demand for equality. In its purest form socialism calls for a even distribution of wealth and equal rights of all men. From 1815-1848 Britain and France experience strong developing socialist movements that would demand in policy changes and help in getting the newly industrialized workers the rights and conditions the people desired and most importantly deserved.…

    • 2560 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    “There can be little doubt that the age we are living through is one of tremendous economic and social transformation” (Florida, 2005, p.3). Looking back on history, the ways in which our society has developed and transformed is clear and evident. Through the actions of industrialization and globalization our society gained the ability to achieve goals that it could not in the past. Although it is crucial to obtain knowledge about society’s history, it’s also important to understand the ways in which our society functions today. Our society today thrives off of a capitalistic system.…

    • 1903 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to Thomas More, Utopia follows both democracy and communism and it works for them because they have enough resources. In Utopia, it states, “There is no reason for giving a denial…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Class Contradictions in the Communist Manifesto Marxist socialism was designed with the intention of creating a utopia; unfortunately, it turned into one of the greatest political dividing forces the world has seen, but it also encapsulated all the frustration and discrimination the working class suffered through. Marx desired a society with no class or property, and since the working class was the lowest class on the social ladder, this classless society appealed greatly to them. They would be the only class to gain from it, while the other classes would only lose status. Marx viewed class as a natural part of human society, and it was necessary for the level of human development achieved in the Industrial Revolution. The bourgeois had served…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Over 150 years have passed since the publication of the pamphlet known as the Communist Manifesto. And, ever since its introduction to the general public this very pamphlet has perplexed, intrigued and insulted millions after having been acquainted with the very ideas of note in this title. Causing a major disruption in the Twentieth century, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels provided the roots for the February and October Revolutions in Russia, the War of Liberation in China, as well as the Cold War. Their words have influenced the world in a way that most politicians and evil villains only dream of accomplishing. The affiliation of politics and philosophy through the words of Marx and Engels very much references the ideas of charity and oneness, of socialism and capitalism, and the correct course of action when encountering these ideas in people and government through the eyes of the authors.…

    • 1607 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also, it is erroneous to say that there was no "revolutionary” opposition to industrial capitalism in England, as there were many worker strikes occurring throughout the 1830s and 1840s in England. Boyer (1998) is attempting to isolate Manchester and Lancashire as unique examples of economic inequality in England, which are simply not true. Of course, Boyer (1998) utilizes the extreme form of proletariat revolution in which a communist state is realized to acknowledge the failure of Marx and Engels’ prediction for revolution, but it was also obvious that England 's parliament learned to embrace socialism as a mediating state authority between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat under the People 's Charter of 1838. I found Boyer’s (1998) not very persuasive, and he ignores labor strike movements, child labor exploitation, the exploitation of young women in textile mills, and other factors that were part of industrial policies throughout England, not simply in the extreme examples defined in Manchester and Lancashire. In some cases, it is true that Engels and Marx rely on personal experiences and political thought to argue for a communist revolution, but Boyer’s (1998) economic data is highly selective, narrow, and subjectively used to argue minutiae, instead of larger…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A key social theory existing in modern day history is that of Marxism. Marxism refers to the political and social theory developed by Karl Marx in the 19th Century, which explores class relations in history. This theory was influenced heavily by industrialisation, as Marx was living in Britain during a time where the industry was booming and the economy was becoming dependent on it. As the industrial development had a major impact on improving life for most of the lower class, Marxists developed as a result of a want to discover more about their past. The core concern of Marxism is to look at those in society dubbed ‘the working class’ and to gain a better understanding of their role in history, and the struggle between them and the richer class.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Pros And Cons Of Marxism

    • 155 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Marxism is a lengthy topic complete with ideas and principles, but does Marxism establish the perfect society for all? In judgement, Communism, in a way can flourish in the hand of the right leaders. See Marxism was developed by German philosopher Karl Marx (1818-1883) who provided the basis for communism. It concentrated on equality of the people instead of providing the businesses and corporations although some may argue otherwise. To Marx, such a utopia was not only had potential, but it was highly expected.…

    • 155 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    He regarded the modern state executive as, ‘“the committee for managing the common affairs of the bourgeoisie” (Marx 15) Hence, Marx envisioned a stateless society organized in such a way that every member of it can develop and use all his capabilities and powers in complete freedom and without thereby infringing the basic conditions of this society (Marx 37). Marx, however, approves of an intermediary stage between capitalism and communism i.e. Socialism. Marx says, “The development of the masses cannot he ordered by decree. It is determined by the development of the conditions in which these masses live, and therefore proceeds gradually (Marx…

    • 2903 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1848, Karl Marx and Fredrick Engels published ‘The Communist Manifesto’ that was aimed at presenting the arguments, goals, and platform of Communism. The publication was a commissioned work that was intended to articulate the objective and platform of the Communist League, an international political party founded in 1847 in London, England. The authors point out the benefits of communism and the need for its application in the future. Besides, the manifesto was a proposal reading stabilization of the class structure in the society without conflict. The authors argue that historical developments have been impacted by the class struggles, with the rich battling with the poor and the exploitation of one class by another.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays