Whistleblower Ethical Dilemmas

Great Essays
Working in the corporate or government environment, employees sometimes witness things that are unethical to society or to the corporation. Many times these things are also illegal. The employee is then inadvertently put into a difficult situation. Should they speak up about the activities they witnessed or should they keep quiet for the sake of not causing problems or not losing their job? This is a very complex question to answer and each individual justifies their decisions differently depending on their morals, values, and principles.
The employee that decides to speak up and expose the violation is called a whistleblower. In many situations, there is no threat posed to national security, especially if the offence took place in corporations
…show more content…
As a whistleblower, an individual promotes transparency as well as accountability by providing internal means to allow external checks, upholding checks and balances. They assist law enforcement’s efforts to detect and prevent crime by providing them with effective and reliable information which could lead to successful prosecution. These actors have played a major role in exposing some of the most controversial actions of the government. For example, Sergeant Joseph Darby and Sergeant Samuel, both exposed of the torture taking place in the Abu Ghraib prison. Sergeant Joseph Darby provided the pictures of the abuse that led to an investigation and resulted in dishonorable discharge and reprimands for 11 of the soldiers. Whereas, Sergeant Samuel Provance publicly revealed the role of the interrogators in the abuse and the tactics used to cover up the Abu Ghraib abuse. Similarly, Edward Snowden, exposed the NSA’s warrants domestic wiretapping program. It is important to acknowledge that if it weren’t for these whistleblowers, these activities may have never been …show more content…
Government agencies are given extraordinary powers, therefore, it becomes crucial that someone becomes the “eyes and ears” of what is happening in these agencies ensuring the government is effectively protecting the citizens and upholding the constitution. Government’s classification and clearance program seem to be acting as a shield for the agencies. These clearance programs help the agencies protect themselves and prevent information from reaching the public. In some instances, it is important to secure classified information if it possess the power to threaten the national security, but if the information is only aimed at educating the public about the wrongdoing of the agencies, it should no longer be prevented under the excuse of ‘national security’. Sergeant Samuel Provance clearly wanted to inform the public about the interrogation tactics used at the Abu Gharib. He shed the light on the matter of unethical means and methods through which soldiers were interrogating the prisoners. The military tried to cover the abuse. The public needed Sergeant Provance to reveal the necessary information to learn about the torture that was happening at the Abu Gharib prison, in order to prevent it from happening again. Even after this, few view Seargant Provance as a

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The SEC’s Dodd-Frank whistleblower program is getting a lot of attention now that the agency is announcing substantial rewards given for information. The SEC does not disclose the name of the company involved, nor the name of the whistleblower who received the reward, however, people still worry about maintaining their anonymity. While the whistleblower program has strong protections against retaliation, such as an employer firing an employee who gave the SEC a tip, there's no protection against gossip and social alienation. Once an individual reports original information about a probable securities law violation, it may take months, or even years, before there is an SEC enforcement action. If no action is taken, or the sanctions against…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Andersonville

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Detailed witness statements and the discovery of extremely graphic photographic evidence.” Photographs and videos taken by the soldiers as the abuses were happening were not included in his report, Taguba said, because of their “extremely sensitive nature” which is stated by Hersh in “Torture at Abu Ghraib.” These conditions were horrible for all involved and the U.S. received backlash because they were held responsible for these people. These pictures are horrible to look at and will physically make you sick to think about the things these people had to go through during their time here. No one deserves this type of treatment or to live in the conditions they were placed in.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Zimbardo Evaluation

    • 1774 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Abu Ghraib held one of the most notorious prisons whereby executions, torture and appalling living conditions existed. Abu Ghraib became a U.S. military prison for criminals after its original regime collapsed. To much concern, after America had taken over this prison and replaced all of its inmates, Major General Antonio M. Tuguba found that there were numerous cases of abuse at Abu Ghraib. These illegal instances of abuse were actioned by members of the American intelligence community (Hersh, 2004). This displays that the Americans level of authority over those in Abu Ghraib may have been due trying to conform to their role of power.…

    • 1774 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unfortunately, the United States’ government did not handle the situation as well as some may have expected. In 2004, the US Congress received only twelve hours of sworn testimony about Abu Ghraib and there were no final reports (Eisenman 7). The main attention was focused on the lower-ranking officers, instead of the whole chain of command. Also in 2004, the General in charge of monitoring Iraqi prisoners, Geoffrey Miller, was promoted to deputy commanding general for detainee operations in Iraq, even after the incident at Abu Ghraib. At the Pentagon’s Hall of Heroes, Geoffrey Miller also received the Distinguished Service Medal-- an award presented to any person serving in the United States’ army who has distinguished himself or herself by exceptional service to the Government in a duty of great responsibility--in 2006.…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Whistleblowing has been a topic of discussion in business for over a hundred years. While there are federally mandated regulations in place to protect whistleblowers, some still argue that whistleblowing is wrong. The main argument of these naysayers, like Norman Bowie and Sissela Bok, is that whistleblowing is an act of disloyalty to the company. In Ronald Duska’s article Whistleblowing II, he takes opposition to this stance. Throughout his article he makes three main points: employees have no obligation to remain loyal to a company, the primary function of business is profit, and the analogy between business and team is erroneous.…

    • 1165 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially curtail its domestic surveillance. Plan: The government will curtail its surveillance by only viewing collected data by means of a warrant. Intro-After the NSA reported their first transparency avowal, the publisher Omicron Technology Limited stated, “The report said 19,212 "national security letters"—administrative subpoenas that allow the FBI to collect information without a warrant—were issued last year, containing 38,832 requests for information.” These unwarranted leaks are why this problem needs to be solved. That is why we stand resolved that “The United States federal government should substantially curtain its domestic surveillance.…

    • 1880 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The creation of the Department of Homeland Security and establishment of the US Patriot Act was a result of the understanding that in order to have freedom, certain aspects of daily life would have to change. One aspect of change has been law enforcement’s move towards militarization, evolving from basic military like organizational structure to changes in uniform colors, equipment and vehicles. Citizens see this evolution as a “police vs citizens” stance rather than community oriented policing. The other and more clandestine policing problem has been the National Security Agency (NSA) and its domestic surveillance. While domestic surveillance is said to provide valuable evidence to prevent terrorism, it has resulted in whistleblowers like Edward Snowden leaking classified information exposing the extent of the surveillance and the infringement on personal privacy.…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Strained positions for long hours, sleep deprivation and waterboarding, with the occasional punch or slap, may sound worth it in order to save thousands of innocent Americans lives from the ongoing war of terror. It is a known fact that the American government used the term “enhanced interrogation” loosely in order to cover up their questionable actions to get any little piece of information about any terrorist motives with torture. Enhanced interrogation has been described as systematic torture in order to obtain potential terrorist information. Even though the CIA get their information, the process behind on how they got it always remains confidential only for the government. Because of the confidentiality this causes a problem to the public and foreign relations.…

    • 1659 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    CIA Torture Report

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the passage “Yes, the CIA torture report should have been released” written by Tom Keane for The Boston Globe it states “ Indeed, that’s the reason we have laws at both the federal and state levels that require government meetings be open and records made public. If we have a right to know why a restaurant was granted a liquor license, shouldn’t we also have a right to know how the CIA conducts its activities.” This piece of text is a perfect example as to why it should have been released. If we have the right to know what our army does, we get to decide whose president, and we live in a democratic country why can’t we know what our C.I.A. is doing? It’s an outrage that they think they can betray the people who fund and govern them.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Injustice In Antigone

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Freedom needs more expressed. We have the right in our belief. Voices from the people that should be heard to better our society. Many people feel that the established rule are not all equal for everyone.…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At first the government established a court called the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act court or FISA court for short, which is a court that monitors the extent of the government’s data collecting and decides whether they are justified in getting that information. It was hard at first for the NSA to collect data because of the tight restrictions that were put in place by the courts. But over time the restrictions loosened. The NSA was no longer required to get a warrant on someone to look through their information. All they have to have now is somewhat reasonable suspicion and they can take whatever means possible to get someone’s private info upon themselves to interpret the constitution by themselves (CNN).…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the wake of terrorist activity around the world and threats of violence at home, the interrogation of prisoners has become a controversial issue in both international and domestic politics. In interrogation procedures, interrogators have enlisted physicians to caring for prisoners and to assist extracting information. Yet, defining the role of physicians in these interrogations is controversial. In the interrogation process, physicians are confronted with competing loyalties of patriotism and ethical medical behavior. Despite this conflict, physicians’ higher duties are to the Hippocratic oath and their pledge to do no harm.…

    • 1890 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mark Felt was the former Federal Bureau of Investigation Associate Director, for many that name holds no meaning, but what about the name “Deep Throat.” If you have been through a high school American history class then you probably have. Deep Throat was a secret informant who provided information to key personnel of The Washington Post about the president’s involvement in a scandal during the 1970s. Some may say that a high ranking official should not be lurking in parking garages releasing private or even sensitive information to the press who plans to release it to the public. Fearing for his life and scrutiny, Felt kept his identity secret until his death bed and was considered to be the greatest whistle blower of the 1970s.…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whistleblower Sociology

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This week in class we focused in depth on whistleblowers. U.S. civic activist Ralph Nader coined the phrase in the early 1970s to avoid negative connotations found with other words such as “snitch”. I applaud his attempt to create a better word, yet whistleblowers are often times deemed snitches. Also, when people tend to think of whistleblowers, they probably think of WikiLeaks or individuals exposing important government information such as corruption when it comes to money or the military, however, whistleblowing does not have to be a big issue. It can simply be something wrong that is exposed.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    When employees in organizations make decisions to act unethically, they affect not only the company itself, but also its shareholders, employees and customers. Employees make a countless number of choices every day in businesses, if they act unethical, they can damage a company's productivity, profits and…

    • 1804 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 6 Works Cited
    Brilliant Essays