The Pros And Cons Of The Mental Treatment Act 1945

Improved Essays
The Mental Treatment Act 1945, as amended, forms the legislative basis for the mental health services in Ireland. The MTA 1945 was innovative and enlightened in its day. The former procedure whereby patients were committed to psychiatric hospitals on the order of two magistrates (subsequently Peace Commissioners) was repealed and the Mental Treatment Act 1945 set out the procedures for the admission of both voluntary patients and involuntary patients, other than mentally disordered persons charged with criminal offences and Wards of Court. The Mental Treatment Act 1945 specified two main classes of patients received in psychiatric care -- the voluntary and the non-voluntary patients. There are two categories of non-voluntary patients -- temporary …show more content…
The maximum period of detention of a temporary patient is six months, but if, towards the end of that six month period, the chief medical officer of the institution is of the opinion that the patient has not recovered, he may extend the original period of detention for a further six months up to a total of twenty-four months, or twelve months in the case of an addict. A person of unsound mind is broadly defined in the MTA 1945 as a person who requires detention for protection and care, and who is unlikely to recover within six months. Section 162 deals with a chargeable patient reception order and Section 163, as amended by Section 7 of the Mental Treatment Act 1961, provides for an application for recommendation for reception into a psychiatric hospital. Under Section 163(2) the recommendation must certify that the person is of unsound mind. The medical officer of the psychiatric hospital must examine the person to whom an application for admission as a person of unsound mind refers before he or she signs the reception order. A person of unsound mind may be detained for an indefinite …show more content…
I have already adverted to the right of the patient or someone acting on the patient's behalf to apply to the High Court for an Order of Habeas Corpus both under common law and under the provisions of Article 40.4.2 of the Constitution. This initiates an inquiry as to the lawfulness of the patient's detention and is undoubtedly a speedy and efficacious remedy. However, the situation of a mental patient who is illiterate, harmless and without kith or kin to initiate such an inquiry on his behalf by way of habeas corpus perhaps poses the problem in a stark form. Such a patient may not be aware of his or her rights to seek habeas corpus and may be incapable of the necessary written or verbal communication to trigger such an inquiry. There are other safeguards built into the Mental Treatment Act 1945 (as amended). A patient may apply to the Minister for Health for an Order under Section 222 of the MTA 1945 for the examination of a detained person by two medical practitioners, and the Minister on consideration of their report, if he or she thinks fit, may direct the discharge of the patient. Section 12 of the MTA 1945 provides for the appointment of an Inspector of Mental Hospitals who is a registered medical practitioner and who is normally a psychiatrist. The Inspector must visit all public mental hospitals at least once a year and private hospitals once every six months. He has a duty to give special attention to the state of

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Safeguarding Reflection

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Dimond (2011) states that mental capacity is a person 's ability to make their own decision, and this must be always kept in mind in safeguarding adult. Department of health (2009) has set up guideline for people working in health and social care following Mental Capacity Act, to protect vulnerable adult. Mental capacity act is underpinned by five key principles, every adult should be thought to have capacity, individual should be given all the required help before he or she is thought not to be able to make their own decision (Smebye, Kirkevold and Engedal, 2012). Every person has their own value and beliefs therefore, they cannot be treated as someone lacking capacity for that reason (Department for Constitutional Affairs, 2007) . Anything that is done for the person lacking capacity should be done in the individual best interest (Department of health, 2009). It is important to follow less restrictive approach with the person’s rights and freedom (Legislation.gov.uk,…

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I attended Department 95 and the patient was not there, but the reason the patient is being held involuntarily is for danger to self and danger to others. It started when he was having dreams that he had killed his family. He was convinced that the neighbors, teachers, everyone around him is trying to poison him. The patient was using illegal drugs such as hallucinogens but started using cannabis first. He was has been going on and off to a Psychiatric Facility for a few years and about 8 times. Then, he would be released after 5150 hold is over. His parents were told that they can ask for him to be extended for another 14 days, but his parents did not do that. He would go back to his parent’s house and his parents would take him back however, it got to a point that his paranoia was so severe and they fear for their own lives as well as the other…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The rising population was because of various variables including the affirmation of numerous seriously impaired patients who would never be released and the extending Middlesex populace. There were additionally an expansive number of ineffectively understood and untreatable conditions giving psychiatric side effects, for example, metabolic clutters, lead harming, syphilis and intracranial tumors. When admitted to the refuge, medicinal officers' obligations included characterizing patients as "reparable" or "serious" as per the term of their sickness and the nearness of complexities, for example, epilepsy and loss of motion . To address the steadily expanding patients population, the Mental Treatment Act of 1930 extended the intentional confirmation method to hospitals, which urged them to build up outpatient divisions ‘for the examination of applicants as to their fitness for reception as voluntary patients into asylums’ . In 1925, there were 25 psychiatric outpatient offices in the UK and by 1935; this figure had expanded to 162 . These were the starting points of group psychiatric…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Correctional officers are held legally responsible to analyze their prisoner’s mental health needs; which includes the delivery of medications, treatment, and other forms of therapy (Osher et al.). By refusing to comply with the law and neglecting to arrange mental health services to the mentally challenged during custody, the United States government has failed to protect and defend many of its citizens. Criminals with mental disorders may be as guilty as the convicted felon who committed first- degree murder, but they should be treated differently in the criminal justice system. For, they have the mental capacity of an ignorant child and their disorder should be accounted for when imprisoned. “Many individuals with behavioral health disorder under correctional control have diverse and complicated needs, but with appropriate supervision and services, they are capable of recovery and ending their criminal justice involvement” (Osher at al.). Mental health services should be provided in prison for inmates diagnosed with a mental sickness to further protect the U.S. citizens, slowly diminish the criminal behavior in America, and to improve the nation’s overall mental…

    • 2016 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Mental Health Act 1983 is an act of parliament which applies to people in England and Wales. It covers the care and treatment of people with mental disorders. The main purpose of The Mental Health Act 1983 is to allow action to be taken where necessary to ensure that people that have mental health difficulties or have learning difficulties, get the proper care and treatment they need for their own health and safety, and for the protection of other people. It provides the legislation by which people diagnosed with a mental disorder can be detained in hospital or police custody and have their disorder assessed or treated against their wishes, often referred to as being sectioned. It promotes anti-discriminatory practice by making sure that even with someone’s disability to learn that they will get the same choices and opportunities as any other person…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It modernizes mental health legislation and includes an approach to promote the care and treatment of patients in communities, where appropriate. It provides for the establishment of a Review Board to hear, in a timely manner, applications by patients, persons acting on behalf of patients, medical practitioners and other persons. (p.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is it justified to incarcerate an individual for having a uncontrollable health condition? Should people be punished for dispositions that are hereditary and uninhibited? More and more mentally ill individuals are getting arrested and being put into jail instead of getting the proper help so they can coexist in society. As soon as an mentally Ill individual is jailed they have no true hope of getting better and most likely get worse due to the harsh environment jail imposes. The individuals remain longer and They are in danger of exploitation and frequently their emotional well-being and mental conditions becomes more impaired. Even once leaving the correctional facility, numerous individuals no longer have entry to required human services…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Just within the years 2003 and 2015, the incarceration rates for the mentally ill have tremendously increased, that within a survey done on inmates it was found that “more than three times more seriously mentally ill persons in jails and prisons than in hospitals”,(Carroll). The percentage rate has enormously increased, yet the mental health treatments in prison have not changed in the last two decades, (Carroll). There is a need for change in such situations, as a result, that out of all the inmates with mental illnesses, 83% were denied access to proper treatment, (Jailing People With Mental Illnesses). With millions of people being incarcerated each year and as society becomes more exposed to mental illnesses, there…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He also enforces that Consumers subjected to community treatment schedules have the duty to accept treatment even if they are to be restrained and medicated for their treatment in the community setting. Consumers also have the duty to accept their care team to visit their home and attend outpatient appointments as per the CTO regime of the consumer. The mental health care team have the power to enter the consumers home for treatment, the power to recall the patient to hospital and if needed with police escort, the power to provide treatment without the patients consent in the hospital setting. The use of community treatment powers is a matter of the human rights concern. The rights of consumers to be left alone to the safety of their own self where they could seriously harm themselves or others and to privacy of their person and property may be implicated, even if they are not actually detained when receiving compulsory community care (Dawson,…

    • 1596 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Long Standing Law

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There is an old standing law still active in Louisiana that in an emergency situation a coroner/medical examiner or judge may file for an ‘order of protective custody’ (Hanson) allowing a police officer to pick up and bring the suspected individual for a psychiatric evaluation that can last as long as 3 days. This minor loop hole makes it easier for family members…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethical treatment was a commodity of insight in the 1800’s. In the past, those who had mental conditions were naturally taken care of in harsh conducts. In the United States and Western Europe, doctors who treated the mentally insane began to promote better conduct for mental care. During the late nineteenth century, the confidence around moral conduct for mental health started to diminish. With the beginning of development in industry along with the rise of migration to the U.S., burdens were put on mental health asylums to disclose further business in terms of treatment. Rapidly, the ideas of local services where psychologically ill patients would obtain personal behavior collapsed into much bigger services where less courtesy was accustomed to the patient. Also, the simple maintenance and growth of mental hospitals took up more time for overseers of hospitals.…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The New Asylums Essay

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After viewing “The New Asylums”, there are many systematic problems, societal shifts, and/or changes in policies that have contributed to “The New Asylums”. One of the main societal shifts that have contributed to the “The New Asylums” is the nation’s shut down of psychiatric centers. This led to the police department to handle the mentally ill that were left on the streets leading to many arrests. However, a prison’s function is not to treat mentally ill patients; their role in society is to provide safety and security to the community. Nonetheless, the prisons do provide many services and treatments to accommodate the mentally ill. Since these prisons have rules and regulations that the inmates must abide by and follow, it is very difficult for the inmates to get parole or eventually leave these prisons because of their frequent outbursts of violence or misbehaviors. They essentially cycle within the prison system and are not able to break free from it, causing “The New Asylums”.…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mental Health In Kentucky

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages

    If agreed, then the hospital where the patient was admitted to shall discharge the patient if the physician on staff determines that the patient no longer needs hospitalization. If a person is considered for outpatient treatment, then the court will assign a case manager or an employee of a community health center to propose a plan of treatment that is comprehensive in nature to the individual. The respondent must abide by the comprehensive plan and participate in all treatment sessions. The patient will be monitored by the case manager or community health employee to make sure the patient is adhering to treatment. The case manager will be on call and available twenty-four hours a day if the patient needs them. If the respondent does not comply with the rules set by the legislative bill, then involuntary hospitalization may be rendered. For a person who is on Medicaid, prior authorization needs to be determined before treatment begins. Section 2 KRS 202A.261 states that a public or private hospital can agree to provide outpatient therapy services to a mental health patient, but is not required to do so. A state-operated mental health facility will provide these services. Section 3 KRS 202A.271 says that if a public or private hospital does agree to…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As he was under sedation, he was very compliant with the hospital staff, doctors did not admit the individual using powers of detention under the Mental Health Act. When the individual’s foster carers realised that he was not going to be allowed home, they appointed a solicitor on his behalf and filed a case for unlawful detention to the High Court, which at first ruled against him. The Equality and Human Rights Commission (2015) states that in October 1997 The Appeal Court overturned the decision, and even though the individual did not meet the criteria, the hospital chose to section him. In December 1997, he was finally discharged by the hospitals managers. In the meantime, the hospital trust appealed to the House of Lords in regards of the ruling. The House of Lords overturned the ruling in 1998, stating that the individual’s detention had been illegal. After this, they decided to take the case to the European Court of Human Rights, which ruled in his favour in October 2004. Following this, the government established the new Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards, which came into practice in April 2009. (Equality and Human Rights Commission,…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Standard Operating Procedure; Consent and Treatment (2012), for example, if the patient is unable to give consent due to incapacities to make a sound decision (unconscious and/or mentally unstable, etc) and require emergency medical treatment to avoid serious harm, the health professionals can provide treatment by demonstrating professionalism to act in patient’s best interest and legislation would protect for the minors under 18 years old (Guardianship Act 1987 for New South Wales)and it will be different to other states)and mentally disable patient by appointing them a guardian to advocate their rights and make an appropriate medical decision for them (Daly, Speedy, & Jackson, 2010). However, with an exception of medically urgent situation, if patients who arrived in the operating theatre without valid consent the health professionals should not move the patient to the treatment bay and relevant supervisors, such as Clinical Nurse Manger, Medical Director and other health service administrators, should be notified. Treatment should also be cancelled or withheld until the valid consent is available.…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays