Advantages And Disadvantages Of The South In The Civil War

Superior Essays
Though the American Civil War is said to have commenced purely stemming from the issue of slavery, this particular issue involved more than just the slaves and their owners. Politically, the South was deeply involved in its agricultural issues and plantations, while the North was focused on technological and industrial advances. Simply because of the different lifestyles, the South seemed fit for slaves, and due to their everyday jobs, needed more hands to produce all the products that the South was responsible for. The mere issue of slavery tipped the scales on a peaceful nation, throwing the whole country into war. “Although there were serious differences between the sections, all of them except slavery could have been settled through the democratic process” (McPherson, 7). Throughout the American Civil War, the South’s determined will and strong purpose to fight led them to overcome significant disadvantages, and evade Northern Victory for four years. During the Civil War, though the North was heavily favored, the South was able to hold them off for four years through overcoming great disadvantages. …show more content…
In fighting the North, Rebels were forced to fight with the Union’s significantly favored army and navy, as well as their stronger, newer technology and industrial equipment. The South, consisting of fewer states, and less territory, naturally had a smaller population to work with. Additionally, seeing that a large majority of that population consisted of slaves, who were not permitted to fight in the Confederate forces, this population of those fit to fight shrunk even smaller. The CSA, or Confederate States of America, led by Jefferson Davis, brought more disadvantages upon themselves by not only banning these slaves from joining the military, but also forcing them to continue the production of cotton. In doing so, the slaves could not assist in military and wartime matters such as building forts or making ammunition. Having a weaker military and almost non-existent navy caused the Rebels to have obviously less impressive transportation systems. Lastly, the Rebels were at a disadvantage to the Yankees because of their choice in a leader. By establishing Jefferson Davis to the position, they put a mediocre wartime president in office, in contrast to the Union who was led by an outstanding one with Abraham Lincoln. Although the Rebels were obviously disadvantaged to the Yankees in several ways, they balanced the equation with their unique fighting style. While the Union took a more passive stance and tended to wait for an attack, the Confederacy took a more aggressive stance, leading their army into a charge. Usually this active, attacking position won them many battles giving hope to a confederate, slave nation with each volley. Not deduced until later in the war, the Union finally realized this defensive stance was leading to their downfall. Regarding both sides’ commanding generals, the North was comprised of fewer trained war generals, while the south was led by skilled, West Point graduated officers. “About a third of the West Pointers in the regular army had resigned to serve with the South; one of the Confederacy’s assets lay in the fact that these included some of the most capable men on the army roster” (McPherson, 56). The Southern troops, led by Generals Robert E. Lee, “Stonewall” Jackson, and Jeb Stuart, were in competent hands, seeing as all three of these men proved to be wartime legends. “Militarily, the South from the opening volleys of the war had the most talented officers” (Kennedy, 438). In contrast, Northern troops were seen to be expendable in their generals’ eyes because their commanders would rather sacrifice them than lose popularity with the people. They were led by the popular yet careless McClellan, abysmal Burnside, and the incompetent Hooker. Excluded from list of dreadful leaders is Ulysses S. Grant because, though he was responsible for an appalling number troops’ deaths, he finally fit the mold of a general Lincoln was looking for—an aggressive risk taker. Because the Rebels rarely chased down the Yankees and sealed the victory, they allowed the Union to stick around and instead execute their own plan. The Union Army “[implemented] the Anaconda Plan down the Mississippi, then, depended on wresting those important outposts from the rebels” (Schweikart, 320). The Yankees planned to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    At the the start of the war, 90% percent of factories were in the North, and the Northern forces had 20,000,000 eligible to volunteer compared to the 5,000,000 free volunteers in the South. The industrial revolution, amongst other things, brought heavy military advantage. One on which is the invention and use of the the railroad and train. The North used these railroads as an advantage, creating supply lines from the heart of the union to the battlefront. While the South was busy in the pre-war era maintaining agricultural and slave lifestyles, the North was building up it's industry to the point where by 1861, 71% of railroad mileage was in the North, and 91% of factory production was in the North.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One example that Donald gives is the unwillingness of the soldiers to carry anything heavy and they would throw away equipment. The South did not have the luxury to leave behind any weapons and that played into the hands of having limited resources. Other…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both the Union and the Confederacy had many different strategies and advantages in hopes that they could use them and win the Civil War. Abraham Lincoln would lead the Union and Jefferson Davis would act as the leader of the Confederacy. At the begging of the war, the Union was the favorite to win it all. The Union had many more weapons, soldiers, and resources than the Confederacy. The Union was also able to win the first battle of the war, the battle of Bull Run, which was another advantage for the fleet.…

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Map Questions

    • 1563 Words
    • 6 Pages

    a. The Union had the greatest advantage in factory production as this gave the Union more ammo and the production helped them win the war. The South, in contrast, had almost no factory production, making them run low on supplies. b. For population, more men means more troops to fight in the war. More factory production means more uniforms, more armory, etc.…

    • 1563 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Again, with the Unions advantages in manpower it could afford to put some men to the task prison guards. The Confederacy, on the other hand, could not afford the guards like the North could. The war was not fair because the South had several advantages. Many of the best officers in the Confederate Army were in the South.…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Confederates fought on their own territory, so they knew all of the area. Their soldiers were all trained very well, better hunting skill and they attended military school. They also believed in the cause because it was for them, and their independence. A disadvantage of theirs was that they did not have many railroads to transport troops and give their troops supplies. They had a very small population, so not many people volunteered to join the army or help make the supplies for the war.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A lot of America’s best military leaders and commanders supported the South, which held as a major advantage for them. Another advantage the South had was that they would be fighting on their own land with their local people as well, while the north had to leave their land and move down to invade in the southern land. The third advantage the south had was that they were very skilled in battle…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The North could supply more soldiers than it otherwise would as it could produce rations and tents for them. This was important as the North’s population was over double that of the South. The North also owned over 97 percent of the country’s guns. This allowed them to arm their troops more than the South. The North also had the majority of railroads with over 22,000 miles of track compared to the South’s with under 9,000.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They looked at Caesar, Hannibal, Alexander, Turenne and Frederick the Great as examples of forces that were able to win despite the odds being stacked against them. (Military Leadership of North and South) However, they did not make the necessary sacrifices that it would have taken to win the war and did not have the brilliant leaders that had allowed Caesar and the others to win. The North did not have incredible military leaders either, but they were still more competent and experienced. One of the generals, Sherman, was positive that they had an advantage over the South with regard to who had the better leaders.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Slavery and sectionalism were two causes of the Civil War. The South allowed slavery but the northern states were against slavery. In 1860, in the South there were approximately 4,000,000 slaves. In the North, slaves were not allowed. Southerners relied on slaves to work on their plantations.…

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The war was destined to take place unless one side decided to back down from the other, which was not going to happen due to the presence of hardliners in both the North and the South. The only way to avoid Civil War was to abolish slavery, the South was not going to let that happen without a fight. They needed slaves in their society and were more than established in their ways. Needless to say, the South did not give up their position on the institution of slavery and they had good reason not to. The Southern economy was basically one of agriculture and the slave population was a very important component to their development.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although, there were a variety of reasons as to why the civil war occurred slavery was the main tipping point and was the origin for many of the issues between the north and south. Economics of slavery, political control, and moral issues were the central issues that dived the north and south. The war between the two was clearly…

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the course of American history, the Civil War stands as one of the most divisive and costly wars. “The Civil War had cost the most money on American soil.” (http://www.history.com) The following report will examine the causes and costs of this war, both economically and in terms of human life. There was many things that had started the Civil War, but the most important thing was slavery. The South had formed a slavery group called The Confederate States of America, which included South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Civil War Social Changes

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The fight between the North and the South began with social, economic, and political differences, but eventually evolved into what is known to be the Civil War. The war made significant political and social changes in American history and shaped the place we live in today. America was undergoing political, economic, and social changes during 1840s and 1850s that fueled sectionalism which contributed in starting the war. Writers and artists manifested these changes into their writings and arts, and politicians used these changes as a motivation to fight for their beliefs. Even with the countless differences between the North and the South, the concept of slavery is the underlying factor that contributed to the start of the war.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Slaves played a huge role in helping develop America as a major power. Slaves greatly increased production throughout America, encouraged trade, as well as influenced society and culture. They were used to dramatically bolster production of goods, in addition to freeing up time for their white owners, who were considered more important at the time. Slaves were also a very controversial topic however, seeing as they were still people, but had no say in their lives. Using slaves split the Union apart, it was one of the main causes of the Civil War, in which many slaves also participated in.…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays