The Pros And Cons Of Tenure

Improved Essays
Tenure has become a very controversial debate throughout the United States with two separate opinions concerning the expansion of tenure into high schools. Before the establishment of tenure, teachers could be fired for non-work related and illegitimate reasons. In order to confront this problem, the National Education Association advocated for teachers to receive tenure. Tenure provides teachers with years of unmonitored service along with a minimal chance to lose their jobs. In colleges tenure was able to significantly improve the teachers’ working conditions by providing them with job security from illegitimate reasons to be fired. Not all consequences from the introduction of tenure are positive; some people believe that tenure only serves …show more content…
Tenure works to give teachers more freedom by “strengthening legal protections embodied in civil service, civil rights, and labor laws by shifting to the employer the burden to prove the termination is justified” (Kahlenberg, 2015). Tenure allows teachers to feel safer and more comfortable with their jobs, knowing that they cannot be fired for unjustified and illegitimate reasons. Tenure also gives “teachers’ freedom to experiment or support controversial causes,” which is very much needed, because if teachers do not feel as if they can try new things, there is no way for them to improve as teachers (Chen, 2009). If new teachers can go to a school knowing they have time to learn their teaching style and cannot be punished if what they do is controversial, teaching will be more appealing to them. In many cases teaching is improved by letting the teacher do their job their own way. By providing a stable job, which in turn serves to “attract many teachers to the teaching profession,” the quality of teachers in schools begins to improve (Akhavan, 2016). The teaching industry is in dire need of new teachers to join and some aspects of tenure actually work to improve this. However, giving teachers increased job security can also lead to many other consequences that are not only …show more content…
This would not be done to punish the high school teachers; it would be done in the best interest of the school’s teacher quality. Tenure serves “create teacher complacency” since teachers know that they are not in major danger of losing their jobs (Akhavan, 2016). Tenure leads teachers to slowly grow more and more lackadaisical in their work since they will be protected either way. Whether they perform highly for their students or become lazy, tenure entitles them to do as they wish and will continue to protect their jobs. Teachers should not be given a reason to become complacent and, in turn, lack in their performance. When complacency occurs, not only does it worsen the teacher’s performance, but it also worsens the student’s grades because of the teacher’s poor performance. This alone proves that tenure is “not in the best interest of children” because tenure protects teachers from losing their jobs even if there were to be a legitimate reason why they should be fired, such as complacency (Chen, 2008). If high school teachers receive tenure, there are more bad consequences in ratio to good consequences that can occur. If teachers at a school are considered bad it would worsen the school’s quality of faculty. High schools are already “having a hard time recruiting talented individuals” due to

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Teachers who have been accused for low performance of wrongdoing do get fire! It is just a matter of time to prove the accusations. Moreover, the education manifest to the website believes that, “Tenure creates complacency because teachers know they are unlikely to lose their jobs”. This is not true because it does not create complacency; it just gives to teachers the stability they deserve in their jobs to innovate their ways of teaching. Teachers shouldn’t be judged on the way students perform because it is always the student decision to learn something in class or not.…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tenure In Public Schools

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It guarantees their job and protects teachers from being fired for personal, political or other non-work related reasons. Teachers feel secure by having tenure which allows them to advocate on the behalf of students and openly disagree with district administrators. It…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He explains that the penalty is stopping students from becoming education majors which leaves school systems with less teachers available. Walker wants to get this message to people to raise awareness so that teachers receive the pay they deserve. He also wants more students to consider teaching instead of assuming they would hate it because of the pay. But, Walker talks about how teaching is a rewarding job. He claims that the best teachers out there do not care as much about the pay, but care more about the quality of education their students are receiving.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I do not want to spend my days as an educator babysitting my students and giving them grades they do not deserve. It is unfair to give better grades to students because they feel sad. These students should not be receiving the same grade as a student who put a lot of time and effort into the assignments. Self-esteem should be something students experience after they have worked hard. I agree that the job of teaching self-esteem should not be held to the teachers.…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Judging a teacher is what student’s specify in, but they judge them in the wrong way. Students don’t have the maturity to judge a teacher on a true scale, but in a sense of their personality and the amount of work they give, rather than their true ability to teach. Teachers should be evaluated by the schools administration. Teachers shouldn’t get their pay scale from the students’ grades and test scores; for if a student doesn’t want to put in any effort toward his work at all, it wouldn’t be…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Panda Express Case Study

    • 1320 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This can reduce costs of hiring new employees, help former employees to be retrained on areas that they need improvement on, and thus eventually helping the establishment in the long run. This will create a strong workforce that has a great deal of experience and is committed to the company as the company helps better themselves. Another solution is to have managers get retrained to focus on certain areas for improvement. If this is implemented, they will know how to properly train their own employees. This will provide a reassurance that new employees will be well trained and improves the leadership skills of managers.…

    • 1320 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They don’t want to be teased at for not understanding a subject or they are too shy to asked about with a huge class. It causes students to not pay attention and start getting low grades which is something the school educational system needs to improve on. It is also stressful for learning facilitators to manage so many kids in one day when in reality it should be a right amount of students instead of so much which effects the child…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When the teacher’s reputation is damaged, he or she may not enjoy some benefits such as promotions. If the students have reached the age of sexual accord, the teacher will be fired from the job due to his or her sexual misconduct (Fasting et al., 2014). The teachers have their codes of ethics. In the professional standards, the sexual misconduct between the teacher and the students is highly prohibited. Therefore, when a teacher breaches the professional conduct and trust, he or she is a high chance of losing his or her job.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Teacher Burnout In Schools

    • 1315 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Introduction The topic of teacher burnout is very important to me. There are many topics that are important and should be expressed more to the public, but teacher burnout is a problem that many face in the world today. The term burnout simply means that a persons interest in this career has faded dramatically, which can mean that they are not teaching students with the compassion and determination that they should be. There are many reasons that a teacher may feel burned out at some point, including problems with students learning, being overwhelmed with stress, or even a lack of technology to teach with. It is a concerning issue, considering the amount of schooling teachers might go through, the money spent to propel themselves forward in…

    • 1315 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On the flip side this could expose a lot of the terrible teachers and show schools what type of people they should and should not hire. Just because you have a degree in education does not necessarily mean you are cut out to be a good teacher. Another reason teachers should get evaluated is because even though they teach well, they can not control their students in the class. Some students may have behavior problems but their education is important. I feel as though that it is up to the teacher to find a teaching style that grasps some of the ill mannered children’s attention so they will not be as prone to act up.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays