The Pros And Cons Of Standardized Testing

Improved Essays
Does a standardized test measure a student’s intelligence or ability to think critically? How does the ACT and SAT play a big role in placing students in categories without any real concept of that student’s capabilities? There are many reasons a standardized test is used; these reasons are to get an idea of where a student is academically in the school year, to see how much a grade has improved, as well as, what schools a student can attend throughout their schooling careers. Standardized tests have a variety of different uses, but unfortunately do not define any particular student’s intellect.
On standardized exams, all test takers answer the same questions under the same conditions. They have the same time limit, the same test setting,
…show more content…
In some way the test scores do differentiate students, yet, it does not specifically provide a synopsis of every student’s mind-set and intellect. The goal of most standardized tests is to sort out students and rank them according to their test scores. In order to do this, test makers must make small differences in grades appear larger than others would originally see. For example, questions that most students get right or wrong are removed because they do not help with ranking that student. This is solely because of measurement error. Measurement error is the idea in which two people with very different scores on one exam get similar scores on a retest, or vice versa. On tests like the ACT or SAT, two students' scores must differ by at least 3 points on the ACT, or 144 points on the SAT before the test’s sponsors are willing to say the students' measured abilities really …show more content…
While our understanding of the brain and how people learn and think has progressed enormously, standardized tests have remained the same. Test makers still assume that knowledge can be broken into separate bits and that people learn by absorbing these individual parts. Today, psychologists understand that knowledge is not separable bits and that students who take these particular tests learn by connecting what they already know with what they are trying to learn. If they cannot actively make meaning out of what they are doing, they do not learn or remember what they learned. For example, if a student happens to learn about the Cold War in an AP U.S History class, they may not necessarily remember everything they learned in that class the following months ahead. Along with these teaching methods come distinct test making methods. One of the biggest test making methods questions is whether or not multiple-choice measure important student achievement versus a short answer test? These kinds of tests are very poor in quality of helping a student learn. They very weakly measure a student’s ability to comprehend complex material. Nor do they accurately measure thinking skills for what people can implement in their daily

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Like many who would agree with standardized testing remaining part of the admissions criteria, Garcia argues that these exams measure more than an a student’s general knowledge. Based on the excerpt, “They test a student’s reading ability and how well they manage time, think critically and organize” (Garcia 6). He implies that they are factors that are needed and students will face in college. Elsewhere,…

    • 1644 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People giving and making Standardized test need to take into consideration that the scores they are getting may not be as accurate as they think. Weather you believe it is a good thing or a bad thing though…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized “... tests have tended to lean heavily on easily scorable multiple-choice questions that stress memory rather than understanding” (Jehlen, 1). So, when a child or teen takes these tests it does not matter if they understand what they’re doing, just as long as they got the right answer. This is completely unacceptable, they need to be tested over their understanding of a…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Schools in the United States use standardized tests to evaluate the students' in elementary, middle and high school. These tests are also used for entrance into college or even to find out if a student needs to take a particular class over in college. To enter into college, a student usually will take the SAT or the ACT Exams and usually there is a fee for taking these exams. In Indiana, the students' take the ISTEP + Exam.…

    • 1780 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized test in general are limited to math and English sections, ignoring other subjects such as Science, Art, History and Languages. Because of this, a student who is exceptionally intelligent in Science but subpar in English will be deemed unintelligent by a standardized test. Additionally, standardized tests only test a students ability to obtain the right answer to a question in a certain amount of time, rather than the process that a student used. Thus, it is clear that standardized tests are not a very trustworthy way to judge a student’s intelligence, because it can be influenced by many…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These standardized tests are don't measure the whole person's ability, only math and reading. Since standardized tests only test you in math and reading some students will score low. They will score low because if they are getting tested over something they aren't good at or can't show their creativity they struggle for not being tested over something other than math and reading. I believe that standardized tests don't know your abilities they only focus on what you know in math and reading, but some students may be better in science or social studies. Standardized tests don't test our abilities and they don't show a student's true knowledge.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Standardized tests are particularly equal to all in order to view where each particular student falls within their grade level.. This test is taken to measure a student’s education to decide whether they should keep progressing or must be taught once again. The idea is to assist a child before it’s too late and their education is even farther behind. There are many who believe that standardized test are necessary in life not only in schools but also in certain professions. Donald R. McAdams brings up that the use of tests when professions are involved has led individuals to consider “if standardized tests were an unreliable source of data, their use would not be so widespread.”…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Standardized Testing Does Not Accurately Represent Educational Quality Standardized tests are tests that are administered by the state and are graded in a consistent or “standard” manner. They are administered in hopes to measure a student's aptitude by assessing how well a student understands a collection of curriculum that the government deems is necessary for all high school students to understand. These tests are administered all across America. Tests such as the ACT and SAT are highly considered by colleges and universities in hopes to increase competition and ensure that only people who are “qualified” are allowed admittance to the school. Standardized tests are, in theory, necessary and beneficial to teachers and students…

    • 1513 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When students take standardized tests, a much clearer view of academic success can be seen. So while standardized tests are not intended to and should not replace the grades teachers give them in the…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “When next some standardized test scores are found to be incorrect or fraudulent (because they will), or some standardized testing company commits or tries to cover up another egregious error (because they will), perhaps then we can admit large-scale assessment isn't the panacea it's often been touted to be (Farley).” There are many alternatives to standardized testing that not only truly show the student’s intelligence and abilities but also the school’s effectiveness. “Other measures can show how well schools are performing. These indicators include high school graduation rates and the number of dropouts, enrollments in advanced placement and other college prep courses, college acceptance rates, including scholarships, and college remediation rates for recent high school graduates (education.cu-portland.edu).” These indicators, as well as local and classroom evidence of learning, GPA, and AP/Concurrent Enrollment courses, can also better demonstrate the student’s abilities and intelligence.…

    • 1399 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Older students do not take standardized tests seriously because the tests do not affect their grades in most cases. Instead, they are more concerned with their overall work in the class throughout the semester as it actually affects their educational status--and furthermore their acceptance at the university level upon exiting high school. In recent years, a “teaching to the test” mentality has been making its way into schools across the country, replacing good teaching practices with “drill n’ kill” type learning. A study conducted in 2007 from the University of Maryland found that the pressures teachers were feeling to ‘teach to the test’ for standardized testing were leading to “declines in teaching higher-order thinking, in the amount of time spent on complex assignments, and in the actual amount of high cognitive content in the curriculum” (Jacobs).…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The student may have simply memorized the fact or formula or trick necessary to do well on the test.” This is a huge issue nowadays because it doesn’t show the abilities and uniqueness of how each student could perform. Standardized tests create systems that compare students with one another by mere numbers and scores on a…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some people say that tests like the ACT and the SAT provide an objective, “summative” assessment of student achievement. But no two students are the same, you can’t summarize the knowledge of a mass amount of students. No two students know exactly the same thing. Another reason why some people want to keep standardized testing is because they show comparability. They say that these tests can show how different schools compare to each other, but each school won’t follow the exact same curriculum and they each have different students.…

    • 1625 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized test also don’t measure the important skills you actually need in the “real world”. They also aren’t reliable in terms of measuring how smart a student is. While some might say that these tests give a good look of where the school is at in relativity to the country, the score of the tests are most of the time not truly saying what the student…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    "The SAT is not perfect. We all know smart, knowledgeable people who do badly on standardized tests” (Postrel 1). Even some of the wisest people have agreed that the SAT and other standardized tests are not valid indicators of a student's potential for success in college. In fact, they have said that standardized exams can be counterproductive for students trying to study to become better students in high school and improve their appeal to colleges. Colleges should not be allowed to use standardized exams as a main indicator of college readiness.…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays