The Pros And Cons Of Representative Democracy

Improved Essays
Many Americans believe a representative democracy is unfair. They believe the only truly fair way to voice opinion is through a direct democracy. But, the truth is, American citizens would not be able to function efficiently in a direct democracy because our political culture is far better suited for a representative democracy. Our form of government as a representative democracy works so well because the majority of Americans agree on the same views. Culture in America tends to be more suited for a representative democracy rather than a direct democracy because they are generally uneducated and unwilling to learn on most concerns and are more inclined to put themselves first instead of thinking of the group as a whole. When it comes to voting, citizens are very politically apathetic, which is not the most ideal behavior in a direct democracy, but is more suitable under representative democracy.
According to Alexis de Tocqueville, Americans tend to have the same views that go under representative democracy: liberty, equality, democracy, individualism, the rule of law, nationalism, and capitalism. Americans believe in the right to be free, as long as
…show more content…
If US citizens lived in a direct democracy, the people would have to vote on pretty much every issue. The problem with that is that political issues can be exceptionally complicated and would take voters a lot of time and consultation with experts to understand them before they can be informed enough to vote. Educating the entire electorate could be very difficult and time consuming, and if an uninformed electorate were to vote on issues, the results could be incredibly damaging. As harsh as it might sound, the American population is extremely lazy and is unwilling to vote all the time on issues that might not concern

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This inability to challenge the majority is what allows the majority to make a tyrannical approach in endangering the democracy of America. The legislators buy into this tyranny of the majority because they both agree with the majority and want to please the people that put them into office. This favoritism of the majority is not only secluded to certain people or parties, as Tocqueville claims, “all the parties are ready to recognize the rights of the majority because they all hope to be able to exercise them to their profit one day” (1.2.7.237). The majority rules the American government, as the minority is forced to live by the rules set out by others. The reason that the tyranny of the majority is so dangerous to America is that: they control popular opinion, insist legislators act on their behalf, and destroy any sense of independence that America boasts.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A decentralized Congress protects and enhances individual interest, although quick decision making is sacrificed and delays and discussion must be allowed. However, the delays in time can lead to more thoughtful decision making. The people do not favor Congress because they feel it doesn't represent the viewpoint of the people and they are slow in their decision making. 7.…

    • 272 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this day in age, politics is not prioritized by the majority of Americans. Many do not know how many senators there are per state, how many states there are in the United States of America, what is Roe V Wade, and can not recognize important figures in our government, as shown in the ABC news story on uninformed voters. The root of this issue is based on the fact that although there are many and various ways of obtaining information about the government and its functions, many do not care to seek it. As stated in the video, in the practice of democracy, citizens are “personally responsible” for their government. With lack of support and participation, people are willing to be controlled and be told what to do instead of figuring it out for themselves.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paper Assignment Democracy is, obviously, one of the most commonly used concepts in modern society; but despite the frequent use, there is no universally agreed interpretation of the notion. The validity of this claim becomes particularly noticeable when comparing the interpretations of Thomas Jefferson and Carl Schmitt. This comparison is conducted with an aim to choose the most plausible approach to democracy which could be implemented in our contemporary U.S. society. It’s argued that although both Jefferson and Schmitt criticized their contemporaries for apathy in political participation, they suggested different ways through which Americans could contribute to building a democratic society.…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Democracy relies on representative democracy in the ability of the populace to participate in and take part in general elections for the representative leaders of the country. However there are rules in systems in place in a true representative democracy more complicated than it was in the past. Voters today are also faced with a large and increasing number of hot topic issues that require more knowledge than the average voter is likely to know which in turn makes meaningful presence in the election difficult to fully achieve. Campaigns help to ease this massive influx and information and allow the voter the opportunity to know what they’re going to vote for as the political party a politician belongs to indicates their stances on all the…

    • 1800 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the assertion, Democracy In America, written by Alexis De Tocqueville, a French diplomat, political scientist, and historian, Tocqueville addresses that we, Americans, do have a political science well-formulated to modern democracy and democratic society, and thus, lacking the necessary tools to effectively understand and manage this new form of government. Tocqueville also suggests democracy and equality are not entirely ‘good things’ as they may leave long-lasting negative impacts in society, to which it may not be necessarily prepared for. In his study, Tocqueville described the movement toward a democratic society and the idea of equality in America to be a universal phenomenon that could not be ceased; in this realization, Tocqueville…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the United States we believe all citizens should share an equal voice in electing who represents them. Every election year, citizens vote for our future president but the votes of the Electoral College ultimately decide the victor of the presidential elections, not the people. Using an Electoral College rather than a direct vote means that not everyone truly holds a voice. The Electoral College should be abolished because it violates the basic principles that our nation was founded upon.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Systems like Direct Vote/Popular Vote or others like it may not work for a country like the United States because there are large states to be represented in a certain way due to the size and population of the state. The Electoral College has an exceptional manner to handle both large and smaller states; for instance, it allows the rural areas to still participate in governmental actions. And by allowing the entire nation to decide the direction the governmental candidates go it makes sure that that the candidates a peal to the majority of our nation. The system of Direct Vote has been tried out by the government of the United States before. But it failed four different times (1824,1876,1888,2000) to succeed.…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Most Americans believe that democracy is the best form of government and therefore, support policies that protect, value, and expand democracy. The overwhelming support for democracy stems from, Majority rule (the belief that government decisions should reflect the will of majority of the…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since its humble beginnings the United States has always swore to be the perfect example of democracy to all the other countries of the world. The power of democracy comes from the people who each get to have a say in government affairs. In order to protect these rights elections are held. However these elections are not always fair. History shows that there are problems in our voting process, these problems have at times made it difficult for democratic or republican candidates to win the presidency.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The 2016 presidential election will go down in history as one of the most controversial elections in American history. During the campaigning our lives revolved around news jam-packed with predictions and contentious headlines about both the Republican and Democratic candidates. Most of us were fed up and could not wait until November 8th when the incessant character assignations would finally come to an end. All the while many of us had high hopes for the future mixed with the fear that polls are not always accurate and dreams do not always come true. Finally, on November 8th, the presidential race entered its final lap and it was obvious that the Democratic candidate was trailing in the numbers.…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States of America are among the lowest amount of voter participation. Some people think the answer is compulsory voting, but is that the right idea? No, Americans should not be required to vote because it goes against our rights and is time consuming, it decreases voter satisfaction, and it increases the amount of uninformed voters. Compulsory voting may be the answer to other countries problems, but not the US. Americans should not be required to vote because it goes against our rights and it is time consuming.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The weakness of our voting System I have never convinced of the saying, “every vote counts,” when our founding fathers created this democracy they were distrustful of the masses. They designed the system to make sure citizens never had too much power, because if they did they would make mistakes. They set up the Electoral College so “wrong” votes could be corrected. Therefore, I believe that voting is not an effective form of political participation, because the voting system is flawed. I believe each vote doesn’t count as much as it should because of the Electoral College.…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should American Citizens be required to vote Throughout the years, many citizens have fought for the right to vote. Citizens of other countries view the United States as being lucky just to have the opportunity to help choose the person who will be in charge of our country or to help decide how our constitution will be amended. American citizens should be able to vote for many reasons,first being U.S. citizens are the voice of America and are our future leaders and drive the political process. The second reason mandatory voting should be require is because it can get American citizens involved in the government, and lastly mandatory voting will sustain a democratic government. I believe that American Citizens should be able to vote for many reasons, one of the reasons that American citizens should be required to vote is the simple fact that American citizens are the voice of America and without our voices this country would have no one to represent us as a whole; the American Citizens represent the American population.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Democracy in America has a paramount theme, the preservation of liberty in the midst of a growing equality of conditions. Tocqueville noted social equality as the defining characteristic…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays