The Pros And Cons Of Racial Classification

Improved Essays
After I completed the “Sorting People” activity on the PBS: Race as an Illusion website, I was told that I had correctly paired 6 out of 20 people’s faces with their corresponding U.S. racial classification. These results were not entirely surprising. I often find myself categorizing others, whether it be by gender, ethnicity, race or age, but I recognize that I am usually wrong in these assumptions. I’m horrible at guessing someone’s age and, more often than not, I’m wrong when it comes to guessing someone’s race or ethnicity, as well.
When you try to categorize others, especially by way of race, you’re forced to rely on a set of stereotypical features assumed to belong to certain members of certain groups. We all have specific images that
…show more content…
There are no clear-cut set of features for any single race, simply due to the fact that race is nothing more than a social construct—an illusion. No one facial feature or characteristic is shared unanimously across one group. Humans, as a species, have not been around long enough to have any evolutionary differences between groups in this way.
Overall, I’m not surprised by my results to this activity. It is hard to judge which racial classification someone falls under, simply because it is an unnecessary, over-generalizing label we stick to ourselves. We each have a specific ethnicity or ethnic background from our families, and while I don’t believe this label should define us, either, it is at least a more accurate description of ourselves than race ever will
…show more content…
The fact is, misperceiving someone’s race can have damaging consequences. For example, an air of controversy still hangs over Middle Eastern individuals in our society, especially in relation to airports. Ever since 9/11, our society has been on edge—leading to superficial judgements of those who may bare any semblance at all to the group who caused America so much grief. Even 14 years later, Middle Easterners are still fighting an uphill battle in our country when it comes to being pigeon-holed by stereotypes. This is an even larger problem in airports. Misperceiving Middle Easterners or someone similar, can lead to being wrongfully and harshly judged, and often times they are treated very differently not only by their peers, but by administration and staff at the airport, as well. They might get pulled aside to have their baggage checked or have an additional search. These judgements are unfair and cause unnecessary stress to innocent

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Folk Taxonomy Of Tipos

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Essay Question: What is the difference between the way race is defined in the United States and in Brazil? List the Brazilian folk taxonomy of "tipos" and how to translate "tipos" into U.S. racial categories. Race is a myth. In another word, what looks like a difference in biological variability, is in fact, merely a difference in cultural classification. Similarly, anthropologist have stressed that U.S. racial groups are American cultural structures that depict the way Americans categorize people, rather than it be “a genetically determined reality (Spradley and McCurdy 200).”…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For centuries, it was believed that the darker your skin the less intelligent you are. People with darker skin were compared to monkeys because it was believed that they evolved from apes. They were separated and treated completely different from white people, one could say they were treated like animals. It took years for mankind to learn that the color of your skin does not make you different from the next person. In fact, we learned that every human being is almost the same.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Birthed into our society as a marginalized individual encompasses sociohistorical obstructions that hinder one’s life chances in attaining equality amongst the hegemonic group. These obstructions are historically formed both latent, and manifest through legitimacies such as law and through social consensus of norms, beliefs, and values. Such obstructions are called gender and racial projects consisting of ideals, stereotypes, and laws that help shape boundaries of groups. Racial formations are defined by Michael Omi and Howard Winant, as the “sociohistorical process by which racial categories are created, inhabited, transformed, and destroyed” (69). Collectively, racial projects form racial formations, a process of racial interactions we conform…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The idea of race is as old as recorded history. Race can be defined as “Human constructed categories that assume great social importance. Those categories are typically based on observable traits and geographic origins believed to distinguish one race from another (Ferrante 214).” Along with physical characteristics, skin color being the most common, social characteristics and stereotypes are associated with a race which often go unquestioned or are considered to be obvious, Ferrante refers to this idea as racial common sense (215).…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Categorizing and identifying threat is part human defense mechanism which allowed humans to survive nature and evolve into the modern man. Identifying threat in nature allowed for better survival and by categorizing animals into dangerous or safe further improves the chances of survival. Unfortunately, this defense mechanism of categorizing and identifying threat in the modern world has shifted from animals to other humans. Describing someone based on their appearance is normal and it facilitates the recognition of that individual, but racism also developed due to natural tendency of humans categorizing subjects. In America, the land in which everyone is created equal, there is a clear evidence that equality between races may just be an ideology…

    • 1727 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We must stop categorizing biracial and multiracial demographics as one group in order to better understand and, in turn, accept people for who they are seen through the history of biracial and the judgement of physical perception. Multiracial identity has a deep and painful past in American history. During the Antebellum Era in the South, countless slave children were mixed race, half black and half white. Their black companions rejected them for being less black and white fathers did not claim them as their own due to their own selfish reasons and matriarchal genealogy. Matriarchal genealogy expressed that the mother determined the child's status of slave or free, used as a way to keep the child a slave at birth.…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whether people acknowledge it or not, everyone makes assumptions based on race. For example, when someone sees an Asian student, he or she will often assume the student is studious and smart. The brain automatically categorizes people based on their appearance. However, race is not always apparent from the outside.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Our class has learned through the videos shown in class that there is no gene for someone’s race. Humans, however, have created categories to try to find differences among us, when there is little to no variation (Ferris, Stein, 2014: 217). A sociologist would still categorize this as a factor for diversity because humans have incorporated them into our society. It would be near impossible for people to ignore race. It is engraved into humans.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “Culture, Not Race Explains Human Diversity” by Mark Nathan Cohen, Cohen elucidates the concept of races not existing and that there is an additional in-depth understanding needed to teach students the correct perspective to a non-racist view when classifying humans. He goes on to explain that us humans differ in a multitude of ways and cannot be simply classified or interpreted by the general standards that are usually set. Looking into the science behind it, he continues to clarify that even genetics can’t merely classify a human based on certain characteristics for being intelligent or how closely related you are to someone. There are so many combinations and factors that contribute to each individual that it’s not as simple as separating people into black and white categories. Cohen further believed that in order for this idea to be communicated effectively, a stress should be put on the understanding of culture.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Effects Of Cliques

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Do not judge a book by the cover”: children have been told this for centuries, so why is it that adults do not abide by their own advice? Judging, or classifying, others based off of outward characteristics has been a problem throughout the world for centuries. Over time, things have begun to equal out socially for all races in the world, but out of habit humans still stereotype one another based off of looks, skin color, or social standing. These stereotypes have been shaped over time and have become intertwined into society. Classification tends to be a general indication of a certain type of person based off of other people’s opinions; however, this does not represent the entirety of those people with similar characteristics.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While many merge ethnicity and race side by side, they have contrasting meanings. The notion of race relates to physical differences, while ethnicity refers to a shared culture between a group. Throughout history, race has been primarily used to classify individuals in a particular category; either through traits, behaviors, ancestries, and so forth. As a result, these categories for racial groups have created designated regional skin tones - including black, white, yellow, red, or brown. Although race has been scientifically understood to be socially constructed, many agree that race has taken a clear toll in relation to: discrimination, policies, and other prospective parts in…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It was shown that when scientists and anthropologists of the time were studying this topic it was shown that they were rejecting three fundamental premises of a very old racial ideology: “1) The archaic sub species concept, two parentheses the divisibility of contemporary humans into scientifically valid biological groupings and 3) The link between racial traits and social, cultural, and political status.” Mukhopadhyay & Henze also discussed the United States racial categories that are used on the Census. They believed that race as biology was being inconsistently used and that the terms used on the census are partially valid because “the biological attributes used to define races and create racial classifications rely on only a few visible, superficial, genetic traits – such as skin color and hair texture – and ignore the remaining pre-ponderings of human variation.”…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Documentary Race: The Power of an Illusion: The Story we Tell, provide a different perspective on the issue of race. Thomas Jefferson was the first to articulate a theory of race. His concept “all men are created equal but not all are considered men”, was referring to African Americans. Having an ancestry of European culture you are considered white, however, although some Europeans were poor they considered themselves white. A race is simply an “assign meaning to how you look” society need to put a classification of some sort on a person to feel secure that they know how…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reading one Question: 1) Why was the social classification of race invented? Race being the social classification in which we distinguish one another by our ethnic and or regional background, enables us to not only create, but uphold systematic social status throughout the world. As proven through scientific research, race is not a substantive concept, but rather an unfounded concept that has been used to separate the human race overtime. This being the case, race was invented to create social class ranks; which sanctioned the appalling treatment of non-whites throughout the past couple of centuries. Is Afrocentrism a response to racism?…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stuart Hall (1997) wrote about the impact of classifying and stereotyping various forms of difference in society. According to Hall (1997), race, like many other forms of difference, is socially constructed (p. 225). As such, individuals’ racial identity varies over place and time (p. 239). Hall (1997) suggests that stereotypes are used to maintain the boundaries between different groups of people because racial boundaries have proven to be fallible (p. 258). In his text, The Spectacle of the ‘Other’, Hall (1997) offers three different cultural strategies that can be used to combat stereotyping (p. 270).…

    • 1036 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays