Essay On Public Education

Good Essays
Are taxes that fund public education just? The United Nations’ Declaration of Human Rights declares that education is a fundamental human right and everyone should have access to free, compulsory elementary education (United Nations). On one hand, taxes that fund public education seem just because they aim to provide a better educational system for the community. However, these taxes also seem unjust because taxation itself is a violation of the right to self-ownership. Emmanuel Levinas argues that in order to live ethical lives, we need to care for and take responsibility for the Other. When this idea is applied to the dilemma of public education, Levinas seems to support taxation as it could help improve the lives of other people. However, …show more content…
Levinas writes, “I am responsible for the Other without waiting for reciprocity, even if I were to die for it. Reciprocity is her affair. It is precisely insofar as the relationship between the Other and me is not reciprocal that I am subjected to the Other; and I am ‘subject’ essentially in this sense. It is I who support all” (195). By completely devoting oneself to the Other, a person will reject all selfish thoughts and emotions. Selflessness is a virtue that Levinas favors and taxation to fund public education would help to promote this virtue. Everyone is required to pay taxes, and when these taxes go to public education, the government is promoting virtues by requesting its citizens to care and aid the education of others. From a libertarian framework, one might argue that the government should not intervene in the lives of its citizens, but this framework could result in a more selfish and less educated society as people are allowed to only think for themselves and the poor are denied assistance. Levinas might argue that people should donate all of their disposable income to a charity or source they support. In order to fully care for the Other, one must reject selfish emotions, and paying taxes to fund public education is just one manner in which one can support the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Plato would argue that people could rule themselves as long as they are rational and educated and just abounds. He says, "the philosopher will have the quality of gentleness". Plato will in no way let a dictator run his government because a sovereign with absolute power can do bad things to society if he is not a lover of justice, knowledge, and is not gentle. Hobbes said, "knowledge is power" and as we all know, knowledge is indeed very powerful that governments try to suppress knowledge and keep it to themselves so people wont be able to rise up. Therefore it is crucial for a government to guarantee free education to all and for…

    • 1376 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In order for a just society to be built, it is fundamental for a strong central government to be formed to provide equality for all of its citizens, and protect them from themselves and each other. In addition, education is necessary to teach citizens how to avoid resorting to their natural tendencies, and discover skills which could be used to assist others in society. These skills can be used for a citizen’s own profit, for their…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For Nozick, it seems as if the enforcement of contracts is something that is implemented by the State through the taxation of individuals income is more important over an excellent educational structure. But this seems odd, that Nozick would refute a society that offers public education to individuals. Public education is the one of the productive areas that is to thank when talking about wealth. The right to education is an essential right that needs to be fostered by the State because not everyone has the luxury to pay for it. Education is such an important need, but Nozick is not arguing that education is unjust instead he is referring to the act of having some other individual pay for it.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Society places statistics on inner-city children and the unfair public education encourages those statistics. Public education in inner-cities is a way to weed the bad from the good. It is the way that society sees who will help the society rather than harm it. Society believe that those who make it through the harsh inequalities against all odds are the ones who will contribute to a better society and those who are held down by the inequalities will harm our society by taking more than they can give. I believe that the inequalities is intended to keep the rich, rich and the poor,…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Free Speech Advantages

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Censoring certain beliefs and ideologies would prove very counterintuitive when attempting to achieve this elevated form of community. Colleges are meant to equip their students with the abilities and tools needed to be an effective member of society. Censoring information stops students from being able to filter and interpret information on their own, which is an important part of being a functioning member of society. Furthermore, censoring information fundamentally opposes the concept of a liberal and free society. The first amendment gives the citizens of the United States the right to peacefully share ideas and criticisms.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    My Political Philosophy

    • 1012 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For example, I believe in the government 's role of improving the life but not to the point where this "improvement" conflicts individual freedom. I believe in the acceptance of social equality to a certain degree without limiting the idea of capitalism or free market. I am against both large government and large institutions because of its power leading to a lack of direct control. I am all for government giving out welfares for those who are less fortunate, but I also believe it 's the citizen 's responsibility not to rely solely on it as a source of income. Taxation, I would have to argue it is necessary because the government depends on it to fully function, however most government activities should be transparent meaning run through by the people without any barrier blocking them.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For example, what they must feed them, how many hours a day they should spend with them etcetera. This would ensure that all children come from equal social circumstances. That would negatively be influencing our right to freedom with regard to how parents choose to raise their children. There is the possibility of government looking at genetic engineering as a way to ensure that people are on equal footing with regard to natural talents. Both genetic engineering as well as the interference of government in the role of the family negatively influences our right to freedom which is ironic because freedom is one of Rawls’s core principles in his theory of…

    • 1751 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is necessary for a system to allow the widest measures of opportunities for participation, as the only way progress and development in society can take place is through ‘the political education of a free people’. Preferably, Mill would rather have government involvement at a minimum in the lives of the citizens but he understands that the government must intervene in some situations, like preventing crime and government enforcement of health and safety in workforces, for example. Therefore, it is necessary for individuals to be educated and politically mature, which is understanding the politics of the community and what politics is producing; through this is where Mill’s proposition emerges. It is paramount that individuals have liberty and the government in which they live under, positively seeks to develop one’s character. The government as understood by Mill, must encourage and…

    • 1853 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Once we get poverty in our communities under control we will be in a much better position to help other communities. Additionally, I would suggest that Madison indeed should help her brother Thomas pay for his college education as I believe that in the present time education should not be considered a luxury in the same sense as Bob’s expensive luxury car as education is almost a necessity. Differing only slightly my ideas and Singer’s ideas live up to our moral…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This highlights the idea that in order to have a just society in which everyone has equal rights the government is to oversee that all inequalities due to factors, outside of our control, are eradicated. In terms of taxation, this entails the theory of distributive justice: taking from the rich to prop up the poor. Therefore, this theory of ethics naturally sides with progressive taxation. Furthermore, Rawls’ theory would naturally oppose a flat tax system due to his larger theory of the concern of distribution of benefits and burdens. Sun states that “Flat tax rates make no logical sense, given the larger aims of the theory”.…

    • 1941 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays