Legalize Prostitution

Improved Essays
Prostitution is historically considered to be the oldest profession in America. During the colonization of the country, most early settlers were male. Fears that these men would marry and thus, reproduce with the Native Americans developed, which led European governments to send over convicted prostitutes for them instead. Such females, however, discovered that the selling of sexual services offered more independence than being in arranged marriages upon their arrival to the colonies (Grant 2). As a result of this, prostitutes are identified as some of the first women in America. Issues towards prostitution first began with the increased appearance of the settlers’ wives, sisters, and daughters as the settlements became further established. …show more content…
It is, however, not centered entirely on the concept of putting an end to prostitution as it was in previous times, but rather the idea of whether or not it should be legalized across the United States. The debate becomes highly controversial when human trafficking, sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), and the workers’ rights and safety are considered. Opponents argue that the legalization of selling sexual services will lead to an increase in the sex-based human trafficking trade and the spread of STDs. Yet, these two assertions have been proven to be incorrect. Germany is one of the few countries that have already legalized prostitution and from the year 2001 to 2011, “human trafficking shrank by 10 percent” (Reisenwitz 4). Some people claim that the reason for this is that the legalization of the commercial sex industry has lowered the price of sexual services. Thus, human traffickers can no longer gain a significant profit that would balance out the large expense of abducting a person. In addition, research studies did not find any “difference in sexually transmitted infection rates between sex workers and the general population” after Germany had legalized prostitution (Reisenwitz 3). This fact that the amount of people with STDs do not increase with the legalization of the commercial sex industry is further supported by the case of Rhode Island. Rhode …show more content…
Violence towards prostitutes was facilitated due to this invalid belief. The legalization of the commercial industry can instead help combat against sex-based human trafficking by implementing what is known as the Swedish Model. This model does not criminalize the selling of sexual service, but the buying of it. It is thought that the targeting of customers will lead to the decline in the demand for human trafficking. Former sex workers support this notion of criminalizing the clients and not the prostitutes (“Our Position” 1). Yet, the people still in the prostitution do not agree with this. They assert that it will cause hardships in earning money with police arresting their customers (Hanson 5). I think, however, that this is a small price to pay for trying to prevent more sex-based human trafficking victims. If the sex workers find it difficult to continue to support themselves with selling sexual services, then they have the option to switch to another job. They would not be able to easily make this choice if the sex industry is still considered illegal and the prostitutes had criminal records as a result of

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    While many may think it is good to have prostitution illegal, no matter the situation you are ultimately punishing the seller and if that person if a victim of sex trafficking than they will have that on their record and it will not be able to get expunged with the exceptions of a few places. In America 90% of the people arrested for prostitution is the seller while on 10% of buyers get arrested. If a person in the sex industry wanted to get out but they have prostitution of their record it will be hard for them to get a job because people will look at that negatively. Also as mentioned earlier, how will sex workers be able to get the adequate support they need while the practice is still illegal here in America? Workers don’t have access to the proper health care and they need to be able to get tested regularly.…

    • 2007 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With an approximate 2.5 million people being trafficked around the world, prostitution being legal would only make this easier for those in the trafficking business (UN News Centre). Unfortunately, prostitution is widely tolerated with people mistakenly assuming prostitution is sex rather than sexual violence in most cases. The prostitution industry is akin to slavery and so intrinsically discriminatory and abusive that it cannot be fixed. Prostitution can only be abolished for these problems to be fixed, but its root problems must be dealt with as well like poverty, racism, and even economic development that destroys traditional ways of living. It is cruel to say that legalizing prostitution will protect anyone in prostitution.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Mike Epps, prostitution should not be legalized because it serves no purpose. He is wrong. There are good benefits to legalizing prostitution. Economic gain, lowering contraction of STD’s, and lowering sexual assault against women. Mike Epps believes in his choice against the legalization of prostitution.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sex workers live in fear of law enforcement; they are concerned that they will not be able to work if they don’t hide in unsafe places do to being found by police and forced to stop working or be prosecuted. Decriminalizing sex work would allow a policy to be put in place, compelling workers to register as an employee of sex work. This has the potential to bring victims who are being coerced into sex work to the surface and allow the victims to be helped rather than law enforcement trying to help workers as…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prostitutes might be physically attracted by their client and they won’t be able to get any source of help. It is considered as impossible to protect a person whose source of income is exposes them to the likelihood of being raped. Therefore, prostitution shouldn’t be legalized as it causes physically harm to the individual’s health. Secondly, legalizing prostitution would encourage more youngsters to engage in prostitution. As according to Feminism, it supports women’s control over their sexuality and reproduction.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Make it illegal, and you give criminals a monopoly. Legalize it, and you give law-abiding enterprises a chance to compete. . .” Giving these woman and men more legal protection, makes it easier for them to seek help, so it would reduce the amount of medical issues such as STDs and the amount of crimes: murder, abuse, and human trafficking. Making it safer for the worker and the clients, and giving them the choice to what sexual act they’re willing to commit, the times they want to work, and work in conditions they’re willing to work in.…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Decriminalizing prostitution and regulating it will protect sex workers. It will prevent human trafficking and dangerous pimps from exploiting people. Most importantly, it will discourage people from buying sex and let prostitutes get out of the sex industry should they wish…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Legalizing Prostitution

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As stated in the previous paragraph, studies of places who have it legalized show improvements to trafficking. As for disease transfering, laws could be made in America that protect prostitutes from harmful diseases. According to Legalizing Prostitution Could Reduce HIV Infections Nearly In Half, it states, “Because prostitutes fear getting caught by law enforcement, they rush the process along with clients and often don’t take the time to discuss protecting against STDs. Further compounding the problem is the fact that these sex workers are often stigmatized, and don’t get the care they need from health workers.” This shows that one of the main reasons sex workers get diseases is because of prostitution being illegal. In Brazil, prostitution has been legalized.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The legalization and decriminalization of prostitution could protect the public and make law enforcement more efficient and productive. It is highly possible that legalizing prostitution can help reduce other crime rates. The Proof is available that nations that have legalized prostitution have fewer violent crimes as compared to those that have made prostitution illegal. The determination of the United States government to consistently fine and incarcerating prostitutes and their male clients, forces people to resolve to take drastic measures to obtain the services of a sex worker, this than escalate the crime level, where if prostitution was legal the crime would not exist to spiral out of…

    • 2167 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Biswas wanted people to realize that human trafficking is a slavery business, and in order to end it, awareness needs to be spread. Zach Weissmueller proposed the idea that instead of trying to end it, to just make prostitution legal everywhere. In Zach Weissmueller’s (2014) article, “The Wrong Cure for Sex Trafficking,” there is not a strong support for why he feels that prostitution should be made legal. One logos argument he makes is the idea that there is a very high demand for sex. He quotes the State Department report which said, “If there were no demand for commercial sex, sex trafficking would not exist in the form it does today” (Weissmueller, 2014, para.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays