The Pros And Cons Of Human Space Exploration

Improved Essays
The Moon landings of the Apollo programme redefined humanity’s existence on 20 July 1969. This marked the first time humans had set foot on a celestial body other than Earth, irrevocably transforming the scope of human existence and the latent considerations of space colonisation. One must consider a plethora of important decisions regarding space exploration. The ethical framework provides guidelines for what is fundamentally right and wrong regarding human resolves in space. Geoengineering, the large scale application of technology on a climate system raises many ethical issues to be addressed. Humans are the first organisms to deliberately modify Earth albeit negatively with evidence of present-day global warming, resulting in scientific …show more content…
The observation of extremophiles proves the remarkable persistence of life in harsh and forbidding environments, existing under extremely high pressures and temperatures near hydrothermal vents. Such discoveries provide hope in finding life in the severe Martian environment, whether present or past. Many ethicists debate the moral status of microbial communities in consideration of space exploration because such activities could affect organisms on other planetary systems. The ambiguity of where humanity stands in the spectrum of life still calls upon ethical decisions, imperative to the preservation and valuation of nature. Jacob Haqq-Misra developed a system for comparing environmental ethical frameworks, providing a visual method of “analysing how different ethical frameworks value organisms, environments, planetary systems, and space.” This biospheric spectrum views the diversity of life on Earth according to qualities like intelligence, with the opposite being empty space. In the same scope, the quintessence of life we are aware of would be regarded as humans, followed by macroscopic life, microscopic life, and abiotic systems such as stars, planets and molecules. Further presupposed by Bostrom, it would be arrogant to assume humanity is the pinnacle of intelligence, whereby it is certainly possible that life outside of …show more content…
Terraforming is the use of planetary engineering techniques to alter the environment of a planet in order to improve the chances of survival of an indigenous biology or to allow the habitation of most, if not all, terrestrial life forms (McKay 1990). The mechanics of terraforming involves warming the Martian climate by releasing carbon dioxide or other gases into the environment. This is the same process that warms Earth – the greenhouse effect, which in itself raises complex technological issues. Possibly the most complex ethical dilemma seen by biologists is the prospect of potential biochemical and ecological clashes between Earth and indigenous organisms on Mars. The introduction of alien species could lead inadvertently to significant adverse effects on the stability of the ecosystem. A preceding question raised by ethicists is whether life should belong on the terrestrial planet at all. Is there value in nature absent the presence of life? Should we preserve the natural state of the red planet, or might we have an ethical obligation to populate the universe? David Grinspoon likens the issue to a vacant lot that we have a moral obligation to bring life into: "Mars belongs to us (life) because this universe belongs to life" (Grinspoon 2004). The concept of terraforming does not receive

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Eaarth; Making A Life On A Tough New Planet has been given outstanding reviews from authors, commenting that it is a monumental book that may potentially restore faith in the future and a practical approach to solving crisis facing humanity. As an environmentalist himself McKibben has done a wonderful job of executing his knowledge about Earth and Eaarth to the general public. In the end it is up to the general public to take matters into their own…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical critique of the article “Can life exist on other planets?” Danny Faulkner, the author of the article “Can life exist in other planets?”, attempts to answer this controversial question by arguing that the answer can only be derived from the ultimate validation of one of the two major theories of origin, creationist and evolutionist. He being his essay by making a distinction between the evolution of life and the origin of life, which he argues are completely different. The evolution of life refers to the gradual development of various organisms to adapt and better adjust to their current environment, originating from a common ancestor, while the origin of life is a more complex question. The author the initiates to explain the evolutionary perspective on the subject, which is mostly unbiased and informative.…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gaia Theory

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Published in 1965 by James Lovelock, the Gaia Hypothesis proposes that organism’s interact with their inorganic surrounding on Earth to form a complex, self-regulating system that maintains the conditions of life on the planet. The theory has sparked religious, philosophical reflection, and challenged assumptions about the evolution, and the importance of humans in determining environmental change, and the relationship between life and the environment. In this essay I will be exploring and comparing the Gaia hypothesis in relation to Algic indigenous tribes beliefs and ideology. Land destruction and global warming are ecological problems that can be approached with the ideology of the Gaia theory. insights from the Gaia theory to similar…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Around three thousand years ago, a story about the creation of the universe came into existence. This story, overtime became the agreed-upon functioning story for Western society. A shared and fixed understanding of creation unified people, despite turbulent times. However in response to the destruction of the Black Death, people began to think of the world in one of two different ways. The first was “towards a religious redemption out of a tragic world,” and the other was, “towards a greater control of the physical world” (Berry 125).…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The blue planet…Third rock from the Sun…Spaceship Earth… Big Bang… Creation… There are many ways to describe our home environment, or beliefs about how it came into existence. Whatever description you use, no one can deny that our human interaction with the planet and its dizzying array of inhabitants and ecosystems is unique. Throughout history, humans have asked questions about the earth and our relationship with it. As societies and cultures grow and change, so do the questions, but current global concerns such as environment and population growth have sparked heated debate, hinging on the ideas and issues of perpetual economic growth. In light of earth’s limited resources and the way that humans are choosing to use them, and earth’s…

    • 1738 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Richard Dawkins Argument

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The earth as an organism has been a popular topic over the last hundreds of years throughout science. However, James Lovelock’s approach of the earth was, and still is, an extremely controversial concept among scholars. He describes his theory as, “A complex entity involving the Earth’s biosphere, atmosphere, oceans, and soil; the totality constituting a feedback or cybernetic system which seeks an optimal physical and chemical environment for life on this planet” (148). In other words, the surface organisms of earth, or biosphere regulate the atmosphere at an optimal level to maintain life. James Lovelock was criticized by many well-respected scientists, and at no point (until early 2000s) did any of Lovelock’s arguments get corrected; they were blatantly rejected.…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humanity’s relationship with nature periodically shifts between symbiotic and parasitic. We feed off nature in order to survive, and in exchange, we carefully monitor how our behavior affects the environment and the organisms within it. Responsibility is the price we pay for dominance and sentience. To help fulfill this duty, the United States government established the Wilderness Act in 1954 with the intention of becoming passive “guardians” of nature instead of encroaching “gardeners.” Countless acres of wild lands, henceforth referred to as the “wilderness,” were declared off-limits to American industry and placed under federal oversight; the United States hoped that at least some small portion of nature could be free from the influence…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    NASA Pros And Cons

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages

    NASA gets $19.1 billion per year while the Military gets $700 billion. Due to this lack of funding, many NASA projects are in jeopardy. Research shows major benefits to giving NASA the funding they need. Although these projects are in jeopardy, many people think NASA gets enough, if not too much. Raising NASA’s funding would directly correlate to the safety and knowledge of American citizens.…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The Creation: An appeal to Save Life on Earth, by Edward O. Wilson” is a book about preserving Earth’s vanishing biodiversity. The book is written in first person, with E. O. Wilson writing to a pastor arguing on the preservation of biodiversity. The pastor, or religious believers in general, think that god has generated this world, the creation, for humans, and humans can use/do whatever they want; biologists, believe that the Earth isn’t sustainable for current human activities, and humans must help conserve the world. The first section, titled “the creation”, describes what is nature and why should people care.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Oil Pipe Line Essay

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Our planet and they whole system was created for a specific purpose, and each serves God, and our responsibility of, protecting, and maintaining it, has failed. Many current events remind me of, the situations from this module, for example the protest by the Native American tribes against the building of the oil pipe line. While it seem logical to invest in economy sustaining measures for our country, but the problem lies above national patriotism, because our pollution affects future generations of life, to include our offspring. Building a oil pipe line across the country underneath water sources used by a large majority of the middle United States, should involve more investigation of the possible safety hazards to include busted oil lines.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    3 Ethical Frameworks

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout this semester we reviewed three ethical frameworks that not only have an effect on scientific decision making but also on individual decision making in our everyday lives. These frameworks serve as a base or guidelines for the decisions that are made by an individual. During the course we discussed how scientific advancements have numerous ethical consequences that could have an impact on society as a whole. There are so many ethical challenges within the scientific community because the decisions that scientist make could potentially have worldwide impact. Typically groundbreaking discoveries are avoided due to the simple fact that experimentation wouldn’t be ethically appropriate.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When I visualize the line between science and magic, all I see is a blur. The blur, by nature, isn't clearly defined just as humanity isn't clearly defined. I question whether my attraction to this line is then magnetic even though it should be opposites that attract. I ask if this line is simply between the things we understand and the inventions we can't yet fathom, or if that line is the distinction between the pursuit of truth and deception. Either way the line contains a mystery worthy of investigation.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evening Thoughts by Thomas Berry Thomas Berry argues that a confluence of developments and ideologies of mankind has led to an end of the Cenozoic era, and that the “expansion of the life systems of earth is being terminated,” necessitating a commitment by mankind to embark upon a “transformation from an anthropomorphic norm of reality and value to a biocentric or geocentric norm,” which he describes as the Ecozoic era (43). He proposes that the underlying impetus to mankind’s troubled relationship with the natural world can be found in a spiritual outlook that has neglected the fact that “the natural world itself is the “primary economic reality, the primary educator, the primary governance, the primary healer, the primary presence of the sacred, the primary moral value,” while man is derivative (30). To this end, Berry believes that “the story of the universe expresses a functional cosmology that needs to be taught at every level of education,” making it necessary to “renew our sense of the sacred character of the universe and the planet Earth,” in an attempt to “establish a mutually enhancing mode of human-Earth relations” (21-2). Berry begins by discussing the prevalent mindset of mankind with regards…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The human race has made huge steps forward in all directions and aspects of life, whether it 's moral, technological, scientific, and even ethical. The human race today and how we behave is very different than it used to be a few centuries ago. We behave differently now than six decades ago when women couldn’t vote or people of color were not considered equal by the majority race. Now that we are in the 21st century, some parts of our world still face some of these problems but in the first world countries, most countries have moved on from such problems where a person has all of his/her human rights. While some parts of the world face different problems, the West where most of the scientific and technological advancements are growing at the…

    • 1448 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Should Money be spent on Space Exploration? It would be advisable that more money should be invested into NASA for space exploration purposes. The reason why this would be a good idea is because with NASA focusing on Space exploration they would have to find ways to make stronger and faster rockets and more filling meals for long space flights. In this essay, I will examine what NASA has done for humanity as well as what their primary goal is, additionally I will examine why NASA should get more funding as well as the risks involved, risks that can be fix with more study and funding.…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays