Compulsory Education In Gatto's Dumbing Us Down

Improved Essays
For those students and parents concerned with the education system in the United States, say ‘goodbye’ to compulsory schooling for the good of the younger generation. One common myth among people is that education is the most important factor in determining one’s success. It has been ingrained in our minds that without compulsory education, one will not proceed anywhere in life. Unfortunately, many people fail to realize that compulsory education is not essential to success. Education is an opportunity given to people that could possibly enhance their lifestyle, but it should not be a force being thrown upon the students. Ironically, even though the United States is a “freedom for all” country, students do not have the freedom to choose what and how they want to learn. Not only does compulsory …show more content…
Throughout the book Dumbing Us Down by Gatto, the author challenges the curriculum of compulsory schooling and offers his ideas for its transformation. Gatto, a school teacher for over twenty six years, criticizes the national curriculum of schooling in his book by stating that it prevents children from learning how to think and act and ultimately dumbs them down. He believes children should be focused primarily on making emotional connections with their community and family, and encourages them to know what is best for them rather than being in a place (school) that will make them even more disconnected from others. Similarly, Cevine Soling’s documentary, The war on Kids, paints the picture of an increasingly authoritarian school system that is failing its students. Children have no voice and they are always the ones being blamed for the failings in the education system. Therefore, Gatto’s and Soling’s opposing views of compulsory schooling should be proliferated and taken into

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In multiple places in his essay, he writes about how school is dumbing the society down, essentially “factories in which raw products are to be shaped and fashioned…” (Cubberley in Public School Administration). In another place, his anger is directed towards modern economy, where he expresses that schools don’t make the next Albert Einstein, but your average…

    • 1291 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jared Korotzer Professor Grady Writing 1 31 October 2014 For School In John Taylor Gatto’s essay, “Against School,” Gatto draws on his extensive experience as a teacher to argue that the American public education system does not exist to make students their personal best, but rather aims to create a large, manipulable work force incapable of challenging its government. This, he argues, is achieved by forcing authority on students from a young age, and then proceeding to breed each student for his or her specific role in society. While “Against School” does present an intriguing view of the modern education system, Gatto severely underestimates the value of the academic and social skills students learn by attending school.…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s society, education equals freedom. Without putting forth more effort to properly educate children, the children will be easy prey for any person trying to persuade them. While many people do talk about the educational crisis in America, there is no effort from those people to change the situation. Benjamin Barber delves deeper into the problem in his article “America Skips School.” Barber explains exactly how American children have become intellectually inferior and supplies ideas to fix the situation.…

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result of Americans’ disregard and hypocrisy, the educational system decreases in societal value. Furthermore, the citizens fail to recognize the benefits that result from a well-developed educational system; such as the power to think critically and to comprehend the true meaning of freedom. In Benjamin Barber’s article, “America Skips School,” Barber discusses how society continues to undermine the progress made in classrooms, labeling the educational system as irrelevant. The people within American society justify their actions with well-meant intentions, however, they rarely act on those intentions. As a result, American teens recognize the lack of value placed on education and therefore learn by the example of their leaders, who place…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Public Education Failure

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Tom DeWeese, in his article “Public Education is Failing,” from Opposing Viewpoints in Context, suggests our education system is failing to teach our children the basic subjects of reading, writing, and mathematics. DeWeese is the president of a public-policy organization that promotes less government involvement and more free enterprise. According to DeWeese, the “root problem” with our education system is, “. . . the federal programs and the education bureaucracy that run them.” He also suggests that the education system no longer concentrates on teaching the basics, but is training our children to perform “menial jobs.”…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most important things in life is education. While most people assume education has a direct correlation to school, people often learn more things outside of school without realizing it. Learning plays a pivotal role in our lives. Benjamin Franklin once said, “An investment in knowledge pays the best interest.” The question we should ask ourselves is whether or not our education system in America really succeeds in its purpose.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is it that states see in compulsory schooling? Is it the fact that the different governments believe they are conforming the students into good citizens who abide by the law? Truthfully, the governments have compulsory schooling set in hopes to create good citizens, decent young adults, and that these students will become adults who abide by the laws. In reality, everyone knows that not every student is going to listen to what the teachers say, much less a state law that he or she does not like. John Taylor Gatto, the author of the essay, “Against School”, argues against compulsory schooling by saying the school system is boring.…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Elements of Education Is everyone enrolled in an elementary or secondary school getting a quality education? How much of what students are learning even stays with them into adulthood? In fact, the things that do stay with us and help us in our everyday lives, no matter what we choose as our career path, are seldom taught in most schools. Classes can become monotonous bore where only those with great memories and rigorous study habits succeed.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Diane Ravitch and John Gatto both set up their arguments to have a message mirroring each other, in that the current system that schools have in order to teach kids is failing and needs to be refined. Diane Ravitch approaches this view in contrast to Gatto. She builds her argument around the solution that children should be educated in such a way that sets them up for citizenhood during and after high school. Gatto’s approach takes a different view in which children are responsible for their own education and it should be left up to the individual students on whether or not they wish to “take away an education rather than merely receive a schooling,” (Gatto, page 115). Both build up to this belief through their separate experiences within the schooling system.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, in chapter one, Brighouse (2006) argues that parental preference should not influence the child’s opportunity to learn about different ways of living. He declares, “so to guarantee that all children have the opportunity to live well, the state must ensure that all children have a real opportunity to enter good ways of life other than those into which their parents seek to induct them” (Brighouse, 2006, p.18). In other words, a sufficient education provides students with alternative perspectives, so that students may reject their parents' ways of life if they discovery a more suitable way of living (Brighouse, 2006). In my opinion, children should have the freedom to learn about multiple livelihoods; however, I also believe that parental preference should not be neglected. For instance, I would be up in arms if I found out my seven-year-old child was learning about sadomasochistic sexual relationships in second grade.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For those who work in the school system, all respect for Gatto is lost. When referring to public education, Gatto uses the word “unfortunately” to describe mandatory schooling. He continues to state that kids never grow up because they are always with other children. Responsibility and independence is also something that he believes has been stripped from children simply because they are with other children Instead, selfish emotions are what takes place. At this point in the essay, Gatto has offended a lot of people.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Issues in Education: John Holt’s “School Is Bad for Children” They say everyone’s opinions matter, but in an academic school setting, opinions are irrelevant. In John Holt’s “School Is Bad for Children”, the author addresses the problem of the public education system. Holt portrays the schools by saying that they kill children’s curiosity about life, and goes to show his personal reaction since he himself is a teacher and educational theorist.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Currently in our education system, students are being forced to…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Common Core: Standardizing Inadequacy In John Taylor Gatto’s essay “Dumbing Us Down: Weapons Of Mass Instruction,” John argues that the current liberal state of the education system is in need of public reform and recognition. John explains that our current education system is structured to discourage self-discovery by cramming mind-numbing busy work down student’s throats, stifling creativity. John expounds the current education system is creating a quiet lower and middle class that keeps busy and helps capitalism maintains its influence by feeding the low wage labor pool, making big business possible.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    education system does not have a standardization of curriculum. This variation across the system has disrupted the basis of education for a majority of its citizenry as they are not receiving a well-rounded education. The lack of standardization is a hindrance as it has resulted in unequal education across this nation. As a result, the U.S. education system initiated a No Child Left Behind Act which was intended to “close the gaps that plague education in the United States and make schools accountable for success or failure” (Eitzen, 371). Unfortunately, this has failed drastically as the act did not establish a national standard that all states should comply too (Eitzen, 371).…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays