Free Tuition Argument Analysis

Improved Essays
Disagreements Over Free Tuition The recent talks surrounding tuition being free and its impact to the society of people in the United States has been a hot topic recently. Many agreements and as well disagreements have risen over if the tuition for a college student should be free. “Tennessee Is Showing How Free Tuition Community College Works” by Celeste Carruthers, “Free Tuition Is a Needless Windfall for Affluent Voters and State Institutions” by Michael J. Petrilli, and “The Problem Is That Free College Isn’t Free” by Andrew P. Kelly argue at the definition if having a free tuition could work. Meanwhile, “Obama’s “Free” Community College Scheme” by Michael A. LaFerrara, and “Free Tuition Can Boost Latinos College Access and Completion Rates” by Deborah Santiago argue if having free college tuition is good. As a result, rhetors who want to intervene in this debate should at the level of definition. Carruthers, Petrilli, Kelly, LaFerrara, and Santiago all agree of the existence of a free tuition plan. Carruthers, Petrilli, and Kelly reach the level of defining free tuition as being able to work or not, while LaFerrara and Santiago reach the level of having a free tuition is either good or bad.
The authors of the debate all have similar and well as different ways they would define if free tuition is able to work. Petrilli, Kelly, and LaFerrara argue that
…show more content…
Carruthers says that it is “effective at getting more students into college” (Carruthers). She also argues that it would allow a clearer reflection of the education system with opportunities and challenges faced by the students (Carruthers). On the level of definition, the author Santiago agrees with Carruthers that it can get more people into college. Santiago also defines it as an easier way to even the playing field among the Latinos and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Vedder argues that free collage is an illusion because the funds used to support education in collages is paid by an individual. He points out it is imperative students to pay for the educational services they access in collages because they are the end beneficiaries. In his article, he acknowledges that any student from a middle class family can afford education. “But the true dropout rate is almost certainly greater than the graduation rate”(401). Vedder is critical on why free tuition should be introduced in colleges.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    During the presidential campaign, Democratic candidate Bernie Sanders purposes a plan for college tuition free. He suggests that public colleges and universities in the United States should be charge free. The federal government has made over $110 billion dollars through student loan, so Senator Sander suggests that the government should cut the interest rate of student loan from 4.29% to just 2.37%. In current economy, the interest rate of auto-loan is 2.5% on average, so students should not pay more interest rate for their education that lasts for decades. In order to execute the plan, the federal government needs to pay $75 billion dollars a year to cover all the costs.…

    • 1508 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Tuition Reform

    • 1018 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Tuition Reform Society today faces the challenge of being able to receive higher education due to economic and financial difficulties. Students, and even parents, experience hardship when it comes to the attempt of earning a degree in any field of study. In addition to the current cost of tuition, most middle class and lower class citizens are not able to afford the "luxury" of attending college or universities in the United States. Likewise, this poses a leviathan problem for the country and especially to the communities. Tuition needs to make a drastic change in prices, which in doing so will open more opportunities to accomplish the American Dream, improve society, provide a chance for people in financial struggles, and help place our country back to one of the top ranked in the world.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Community College Should Not Be Free President Barack Obama and Bernie Sanders have been discussing making two years of community college tuition free, one hundred percent free on the student’s part. Is it actually free for the students? Doesn’t the United States already have programs that are supposed to help low-income students afford their tuition? How could it affect the taxpayers or even taxes?…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It starts by introducing the topic followed by a brief background information on free community college discussion. The paper gives a brief description on the reasons why some Americans think community college should be free. Their main reason is that it provides equality and more opportunities for students. It proceeds to issue writer’s opinion as to why community college should not be free with backup from credible references and statistics. Among the reasons explained in this paper are; dropout rates would increase, free community college would be unfair to the poor while the rich would benefit more besides being a burden to the taxpayers.…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Literature Review After the economic recession in 2008, life has only gained more and higher expenses. Studies have highly increased, while wages have increased but not an equitable value to meet a college students’ expenses. In the article, The Reality of Free Community College Tuition, by Fran Cubberley, she presents both pro and con arguments in why it would be beneficial for our current and ongoing high school graduates to receive a free two-year education. The arguments made are: As a pro, students could avoid such costs as well as reduce the likelihood of requesting a loan. As for a con, “the cost of educating and serving students, and senior management and the board of trustees will need to adopt creative financial strategies to maintain…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every little kid has fallen at some point. Riding that bike, trying to balance on a beam or just plain bad balance. A mother would lean down and kiss the boo boo and tears away. But how many times would she do the same thing, making sure her child protected in the best way, not letting anyone hurt her baby? Eventually would she say that tears aren’t necessary?…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    TITLE Rising college tuition in America is a serious issue for most students, causing the push for free college tuition to increase tremendously over the last few years. With the recent Presidential election and candidate Bernie Sanders pressing the issue of tuition free college, it has become of gargantuan focus among the American people. Because of this, many have posed their own arguments and research for, or against, free college tuition. America being the only major country without free public college tuition, makes many furious with the government.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Purpose: To persuade the audience to find ways to promote free college education. Importance to Audience: College education has become a necessity that’s hindering the future of growing generations. Thesis Statement: College Education should be free. Preview of Main Points: I will elaborate on the following three topics: the increasing rate in student debt, how other countries are benefitting from providing free college, and how we can achieve free college tuition in the U.S. (Transition:…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Importance Of Free College Education

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited

    For students to understand the investment of an education shows a maturity that they developed by taking out loans. It is required for students to undergo a seminar about loans and how it should be monitored. This helps students understand the real life aspect of adult hood and money management ("Huffington Post" ). If college were to be free, yes students would not have to take out any loans whatsoever but many would not develop the maturity needed for life after college. It is understandable for students to disagree with the argument and refute that college is something that should be free to anyone.…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As tuition and fees continue to get higher, scholarships will be more challenging to achieve, and the student will have to get multiple student loans to cover it. “Tuition and fees at public colleges soared a record 14 percent this year, continuing a quarter-century trend of higher-education prices rocketing faster than inflation,” (Price 3). It is true that the government has not always funded the children through the twelfth grade, but times have changed, (Kingsley 16). On one hand, some would argue that students can get apply for a loan or financial aid to pay for college. Education is not free now does not mean that students are prohibited from entering a college or university for a higher education.…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If we made college free for everyone we would be funding the rich. Families that have the money to pay for some or all of the cost of a college education might choose instead to take advantage of free college at a public institution. Amelia Josephson said, “In effect, the government and taxpayers would be subsidizing the rich. Critics of free college who point to this drawback often argue that a more targeted reform subsidizing college for the poor and the middle class would make more sense. They also point to the example of Brazil, a country with free college where wealthy students reap a lot of the benefits of tuition-free education at public universities.”…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sacramento City College student Markese Pierce stated that free tuition is “‘probably the smartest thing we can do because it will keep people in school [.] It makes people want to further their lives and their future’” (Devaney). Graduating from college will impact families because getting a college degree will pass on to the next generation and improve the next…

    • 1654 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    It must have been a daunting prospect at the time - paying for the education of so many children for such an extended period of time, transferring a potential workforce away from productivity for an investment like schooling.” If free education for all high schools could be achieved, even if it’s still being ironed out with it’s problems, then why not do the same for college education? College students should be given the chance to make the most of their…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    New Republic is opposed to it saying “The main problem with free college is that most students come from disproportionately well-off backgrounds and already enjoy disproportionately well-off futures, which makes them relatively uncompelling targets for public transfers.” Many disagree, saying “College should be free to all students. Just like students have a right to elementary and secondary education, students should have a right to obtain higher education. If a person has a desire to learn more, they should not be forced to stop learning after high school due to a lack of money or connections” (Academic OneFile). Students that have been raised in the middle or lower class may not have the income, work, and time to support them in top well known colleges.…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays