Open Labour Market Pros And Cons

Improved Essays
In the global economy, the hardest thing for individuals to market is themselves. There are countries that have policies that gladly welcome foreign workers into the work force, and there are countries that do not. Individuals look for jobs in countries that would allow them to grow, but they find themselves blocked from entrance and restricted by policies. In “Let Anyone Take a Job Anywhere,” a debate on Intelligence2 Debates, the pros and cons of an open labor market crashed in a head-on-collision. In the argument in support of an open labor market, many great supporting points were brought forth. Bryan Caplan, a professor of Economics at George Mason University, argued that such an action would reduce discrimination, it would increase the …show more content…
Ron Unz, a successful publisher, presented that opening the labor market would cause a surplus of labor, it would only benefit the wealthiest in society, it would cause suffering to other social classes competing for jobs and higher wages, and would cause “severe political backlash” from the people of the U.S. Kathleen Newland, co-founder of the Migration Policy Institute, argued that an open labor market would not work because it would cause low productivity and lower wages, and that the social costs would be too great, such as establishing infrastructure for new …show more content…
Unz presented that the incomes of average Americans has stagnated and declined over the last forty years and that further competition in the labor market will only cause further decline. This is most surprising, for if we would like to increase living standards for Americans, why would we open a labor market to immigrants willing to take jobs at lower wages? Incomes would further decline for most Americans because they would be forced into working for lower wages.
Before the debate, my position on the topic was neutral, and it has remained neutral. Both sides presented valid arguments leaving me unable to decide which side would be best. Although, I would hope that the supporting side would be right in their arguments, for if their statements were true it would cause greater prosperity for the entire global population.
After evaluating the sides in the debate, I found the result of the audiences vote to be surprising. I found, upon watching the debate, that the supporting side had greater credibility. From my viewpoint, the supporting side’s arguments were clear and easily understood compared to the arguments from the opposing side. If anything, I would have anticipated that the majority of the vote would have been

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Minimum Wage for Minimum Skills The war over minimum wage in America is roaring on. On one side, people argue that raising the minimum wage will help many escape poverty and maybe even provide more jobs. On the opposing side, people argue raising the minimum wage would only reach half of those who really need it and result in a major loss of jobs; therefore, it would be unsuccessful (Gray). Of these two sides, I agree with the latter. Through my research, I have found out that there is going to be more harm than done if we increase the minimum wage.…

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Minimum Wage Madness

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The question against raising the minimum wage is simple and direct. A higher wage makes it more costly for businesses and companies to hire workers (Rugless). Depending on where America stands economically, adding five-hundred thousand people to the unemployment rolls could slow down or even stop growth and maybe pushes us toward an economic recession, causing additional layoffs and pay cuts. How big of an effect does this wage spike have on the job market? Economists argue over this, but no one argues that boosting the minimum wage expands the number of unemployed workers who find jobs.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Minimum Wage Debate

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages

    From an economic and social standpoint I do not believe it will be beneficial to raise the minimum wage. As I analyzed the data provided, it appeared that the cons outweighed the pros. For example, reduced levels of poverty appeared to be the major benefit supporters were using to justify raising the minimum wage. I am in disagreement with this claim due to the fact there has been a trend of increased poverty and inflation in the past as a result of increasing the minimum wage (Iowa). Increasing the minimum wage makes it more challenging for businesses and companies to pay their employees.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The lack of employees has produced an initial increase in monetary savings but the prolonged effects of not having adequate employees will yield a large decrease in the revenues over an extended period Fd gqert q4tq gqert notice a lack of employees manning the store. If you have a question about a product good luck trying to hunt someone down to assist you with your inqucdtrt;qwerkqwe’r233343240234l’iry. Often times you will feel as if you are the only one in the store. This is due to the fact that TheStore has trimmed the company employees down below an acceptable level for conducting normal business operations. The lack of employees has produced an initial increase in monetary savings but the prolonged effects of not having adequate employees will yield a large decrease in the revenues over an extended period Fd gqert q4tq gqert notice a lack of employees manning the store.…

    • 52230 Words
    • 209 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Andersen 208) Those rich countries can’t use their own population for their production because the labor is heavily expensive in their country and the economy will drop down. However, they use poor country who needs money because labor is cheaper. Social inequality pushed the core countries to send jobs overseas and thus those exploited countries tend to migrate in thinking that all the work is inside, which leads the economy to drop because everyone needs to be…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Effects Of Outsourcing

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Every hour of every day could be filled by the stories of a family’s breadwinner losing their job to cheap labor overseas when their greedy company decides to globalize. My perspective is driven by the effects of outsourcing will give the general public lower prices on goods, but will also destroy the U.S. economy in the long run. I do realize that globalization affects more than just Americans. When businesses move the majority of their jobs overseas, those countries experience a boom of economic growth and often bring them to the twenty-first century of technology. However, the U.S. economy doesn’t get affected as much as the loss of thousands of jobs would seem to cause.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many people may ask the question would raising the minimum wage reduce poverty? The answer is no, since there are big factors that go into play when a wage increase happens. There are a lot of low wage workers that are put under the poverty line which does effect the families that are in that area where they may not be able to make ends meet with their current wages. Whenever the minimum wage limit seems to increase, inflation seems to catch up and it ends up not making a difference. The minimum wage increase will not help people in poverty since it will cause employers adjusting their employee job hours, making entry level jobs harder to find, and is making prices rise.…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without economic rewards, most people are discouraged to invest their time in the economy, which would make a poor American economy and global economy. The one possibly beneficial thing that this would do to the economy is eliminating social classes and making it so there is a middle ground for people from all walks of life. This would create equality throughout the economy. With this financial equality, we would be losing the Capitalist ideals that Americans value. To keep the American economy strong, there must be rewards for hard…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I do agree with his perception of "offshorable jobs” (Krugman 2). These are jobs that could be done in other places for a lower price. Offshorable jobs are a problem because they take jobs out of America; however, the increase of jobs in America will come with some consequences. If America raises its standard of quality to combat offshorable employment, the price will go up. Bringing back jobs to America is so hard because no one wants to pay more when they can pay less.…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This would create millions of jobs because many would prefer others to manage their accounts due to the lack of education in economics and accounting. It’s crazy to think that we are wanting to pull our funds away from the government because of the lack of trust in government but we are willing to trust our money into a possible asset stripping organization. We need to remember that Social Security was created for our disabled, elders, and their families. Now, I believe that the current set up should be altered so the program can continue without the worry of funds running out. You also have to imagine what would happen to stock prices and the market in general if every adult was investing into the top companies.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays