The Pros And Cons Of Alienation

Improved Essays
This leads to alienation from the work process; this is intimately connected to alienation from the product but rather focuses on how the process is inherently alienating in itself (Marx, 1844). Consequently the focus is not on the disconnect to the final product (Pappenheim, 1959). This is perhaps the most straightforward way in which our species being is being violated. As has been outlined, capitalism creates specialisation, the mechanisation of the human. What defines prosperity under Marxism is the opposite. Free creativity and control of production is what we need for fulfilment (Marx, 1844). This is not possible when one’s job is entirely specific and requires no decision making by the person (Hegel, 1820). The process of making a table …show more content…
However many of his arguments do not stand up to critique. I believe there are some ways to better argue for mark’s conclusions, although I will not be addressing them. The first major flaw is perhaps the most fundamental to Marx’s alienation critique. Marx does not adequately account for why he believes our species being is what it is (Kymlicka, 2002: 193). The argument he employs is the taxonomical differentia argument (Kymlicka, 2002: 193). This argument fails because both its conclusion does not follow from its premises and that it is simply a non sequitur (Kymlicka, 2002: 193). The differentia argument is that which makes an organism unique, the feature it does not share with other organisms, is the feature that is necessary for that animal to flourish (Kymlicka, 2002: 193). From this principle Marx believes that it is creative cooperative production that is unique to people and is thus the thing we need to flourish. However, complex mathematics is also unique to people and yet Marx does not claim that is our species being. Moreover, simply because a feature of an organism is unique does not make that the most important thing to that animal’s flourishing. This is neatly proven by the fact that if aliens came to earth with the same species being as humans, that would not somehow nullify our species being. Far more work is required in proving that our species being is in fact …show more content…
Firstly, there really do seem like there are legitimate cases where one would choose alienating labour for other ends (Kymlicka, 2002: 192). The home cook who wants to cook gourmet food yet cannot be employed commercially can surely find contentment with an alienating career that allows her to do this. Thus, hobbies may require alienating labour. Additionally there is a strong feminist critique. Womxn have been oppressed precisely because their labour has not conformed to Marx’s ideas. Womxn raising children and maintaining a household have surely chosen a legitimate path that Marxism would undermine as mere animal flourishings. This is wrong. Simply put there are legitimate alternate preferences, which depending on the person will be more fulfilling than Marxian production. I think this has become starkly obvious in modern capitalism where home life has become significantly better. Marx’s response would likely be that under Marxism abundance would allow for all of this as well as fulfilling production. I will not elaborate on this but the assumption of abundance under Marxism is a very

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    When Karl Marx (2003) talks about labour in a political economy, he argues that the workers are “degraded to the most miserable sort of commodity” (p. 6)—in other words, the workers are being exploited by owners of private property. He introduces the concept of alienation, describing how workers become externalized not only from their labour and the product of their labour, but also from their species’ being and other workers. This, as a result reduces the workers’ capabilities of seeking their greatest potential, leaving them powerless. While Marx is able to explain how alienated labour is developed, are the ideas around alienation only confined to labour? This paper will discuss the ways in which alienation is conceptualized and applied…

    • 298 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    The second way a laborer is alienated is through the job itself. The laborer feels as if the job itself is often repetitive and does not provide any satisfaction because, in the end, the production has no inherent meaning to him. The third type that a laborer goes through is the alienation of himself. Capitalism takes away the essence of being human. The workers are treated like objects and must work in order to maintain a living in a job they have no interest or passion in.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first idea, the alienation of the worker from the product of his labor is discussed, and with this idea the conclusion is made that the worker is unable to identify himself with the object he produces. The worker invests his labor and in a way his labor becomes an object that doesn’t belong to him. The worker isn’t able to use his creative abilities in order to produce products for himself, and as a result the worker produces products that he may not be able to initially get his hands on outside of work. Next, Marx focuses on the alienation of the worker from the activity of production.…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The worker has private property when he “is the free proprietor of the conditions of his labour,” and this private property is the foundation of small-scale industry, which is necessary for “the development of social production and of the free individuality of the worker himself” (Marx, 298). The labor of workers does not include co-operation, or the division of labor. The private property of capitalists is based on the expropriation of the producers…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This excerpt is very dense in its use of Marxist vocabulary – or, the phrases and key words used by Marx as place-holders for larger and more complex ideas. Therefore, it requires a bit of un-packing. First, what does Marx mean by species being? It’s intended function is to serve as a description of the nature of human kind.…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many of the works and theories of the social theorists during the 19th and early 20th century are still relevant today even with all the changes that we have gone through as a society. The issues discussed in Weber’s and Marx’s class theories; DuBois’ theories about race and Durkheim 's theories on society and labor are the basis on which many of today’s ideologies are derived. Karl Marx was a class theorist and theorized about class struggles and the ideal class society. He also had theories about the construction of society and the interaction between the wealthy and working classes which he called the bourgeoisie and the proletariats. One of his major ideas was that of alienation of the working class.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Man is meant to work to satisfy his own needs, however now this work has been distorted and used for external gains outside the worker. This taints the process of labor which is a part of man’s nature, therefore estranging man from nature. In addition, Marx argues that man’s physical and spiritual life is intrinsically linked to nature, as man is a part of nature. Therefore, the estrangement of the worker to nature is in essence the estrangement of man to himself. This is because the worker is estranged from the functions that make him man, as they are distorted for capitalist gains.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Lastly, Marx states that workers are alienated from each other. This is due to the workplace of the factories during Marx’s time where…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although Adam Smith and Karl Marx have radically different economic theories, both their ideologies have the same goal in mind: greater freedom. Their divergent views therefore arise from their different ideas of what freedom is. Smith ties freedom to financial gain whereas Marx ties freedom to financial ownership. These differing views on freedom can be seen in their different attitudes towards machinery. While Smith sees machinery as furthering the efficiency of society which he connects to the freedom of workers, Marx sees it as furthering the estrangement and exploitation of workers.…

    • 2003 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The final element in Marx’s second alienation of labor is that the worker loses himself in the labor. The worker therefore only feels himself outside his work. This phenomenon is mirrored throughout Primo Levi’s story of his time in the Buna and his time in the chemical lab, especially during his chemical…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Book Review First Draft – Why read Marx today? – Jonathan Wolff Prior to studying this module around the topic of historical economic thought, I myself thought, ‘what is the point in looking at economic ideas that were written so long ago?’. Therefore, I chose this book by Jonathan Wolff to try and convince me that ideas written and created by some of the most influential economists such as Marx could be relevant when compared with the ideas of today. The book itself consists of 4 main sections, which pose as the chapters of the book.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Karl Marx criticizes capitalism in a multitude of his essays, including the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844. His critique of capitalism varies from the exploitation of workers to the instability of the capitalist system, but fundamentally his issue with capitalism is the dehumanization of laborers. Marx argues that under capitalism, laborers are dehumanized because they are alienated, or disconnected from fundamental human properties, in four aspects – products of labor, labor, species-being, and human-human relations. The basis of Marx’s theory of alienation is the laborer’s estrangement from his labor, which arises from alienation from the laborer’s object of production. According to Marx in the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, “the object which labour produces – labour’s product – confronts it as something alien, as a power independent of the producer” (71).…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Foucault Alienation Theory

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The theory of alienation While Foucault in his theorization of the docile body referred to “the technology of power intended to produce a calculated manipulation of the body” (Foucault, 1979, p.202), another important 19th century philosopher gave a different interpretation of the term docile. The theory of alienation was developed and expressed by philosopher Karl Marx in response to the workers of a newly (at the time) formed capitalist society. He believed that the workers were becoming mere cogwheels in the bourgeois machine of production, and that they had become increasingly “deprived of the right to think of themselves as the directors of their own actions”. While the theory of alienation in its whole can be interpreted as a politically…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The theory of alienation is ‘the intellectual construct in which Marx displays the devastating effect of capitalist production on human beings, on their physical and mental states and on the social processes of which they are a part’ (Ollman, 1996). Marx’s theory is based on the observation that within the capitalist mode of production, workers invariably lose determination of their lives by being deprived of the right to regard themselves as the director of their actions. Alienation refers to the social alienation of people from aspects of their human nature and can be defined as a condition whereby individuals are governed by institutes of their own creation in capitalist society such as; religion, the state and economy, all of which are…

    • 1914 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marxism in The Hunger Games If there is any perfect representation of Marxism in film it is in The Hunger Games. For this case study, I will be focusing on the first movie of the trilogy. This paper will overview the way Marxism is shown in The Hunger Games using a few examples from the movie. In this paper, I argue that The Hunger Games’ plot line has Marxism theories extremely exposed and almost blatantly exposed. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels developed Marxism in the early 1900s.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays