The Pros And Cons Of A Smart Classroom

Improved Essays
While the positives of technology seem to be never ending, the downsides tend to add up just as much, maybe even more, making the integration to a “Smart Classroom” more difficult for students and staff. Technology often poses as a distraction, a way to cheat, and even tries to replace teachers-- all very dangerous when regarding a child’s education. The most important of these negatives is distraction. When working with computers or tablets it is so easy to venture off into non educational sites. Students could easily access their Facebook or Twitter accounts, watch silly cat videos on YouTube, or try and beat their high score on Flappy Bird or other mobile videogames. Instructor of Mathematics at College of Saint Mary, Kelly Murphy, …show more content…
While a majority of students in this generation have grown up using computers, tablets, and cellphones not all families were able to provide these luxuries for their children. Therefore, some students would be at a disadvantage; They would first have to be educated on how to utilize their devices before they could be educated on the actual curriculum. Instructor, Greg Garth here at College of Saint Mary finds that he runs into this issue quite frequently in class-- especially in the beginning of the year when students are still trying to adapt to new learning websites. He shared, “They [the students] have to learn the system on the fly and it might be cumbersome to them. I’ve had students email me asking about where to find something on Canvas” (Garth). Canvas is the main education site used at College of Saint Mary and is used for teachers to upload assignments, post announcements, and insert student’s grades; Students use this site to turn in homework and keep track of their academic progress. Previously mentioned Allyah Rayyan vouched for the difficulty in using an unfamiliar site, “It [Canvas] can be a little annoying because of not knowing how to use them at first… If they could be improved it would be to make all the professors and students …show more content…
The issue of professors not fully understanding technology raises another issue: teachers being unsure how to implement technology into their curriculum without replacing the curriculum all together. Often times teachers believe that because the class information is available to students online, that they no longer need to instruct the students. This is not the case, regardless of whether or not students can find the needed information they still need the instructor to help explain and apply real world scenarios so that the information is easier to process. Murphy brought up this idea and simply stated, “The most important aspect of technology it is a tool, it is not meant to be used as the whole curriculum” (Murphy). Although communication was previously mentioned as a positive it also has a negative aspect. While using technology some important human interaction is lost; The importance of communication skills such as eye contact and body language are crucial, and without everyday face to face interaction those skills cannot be practiced and used. Technology can also give some people a false sense of strength which allows them to say certain things they would not otherwise say in person-- this may sound like a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Teachers need to know how to use the technology. Many teachers use “educational strategies” (Rosen, 4) that were used in the past and simply transferred the content from a whiteboard to a PowerPoint on a smart board. Why waste time and energy on something that is more or less the same style of teaching, just on a different media? Throughout Rosen’s book, Rewired: Understanding The iGeneration And The Way They Learn, he references the fact that the current generation of students are completely different from what teachers have seen in the past. As a result of that, students learn unlike anything teachers have experienced. Technology is advancing so quickly that while teachers are being trained in the newest technology, even newer technology is being created. By the time teachers graduate their students have already become bored with the way they were trained to use technology in their classrooms.…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Integrating technology into the curriculum brings a wide array of positive impacts. According to researchers, technology plays a significant role in increasing student motivation, engagement, and achievement (Challoo, Green, & Maxwell, 2011). Providing students the opportunity to use technology on a regular basis breaks the monotony of school, gives students independence, and provides more opportunities for critical thinking. Implementing technology into the classroom encourages students to actively participate in the learning…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, Professor Bugeja’s survey does not show that students were distracted in class due to the installation of more wireless service - it simply indicates that students are distracted in class. Thus this does not corroborate with the author’s argument that wireless networks installed by schools have enabled distraction. Britland, however, does not make use of much evidence to support his argument that “the future of technology in education is the cloud” (Britland, 2013, para 6). Britland only introduced an iPad trial to demonstrate the effectiveness of iPads and hence mobile technology as an educational medium. However, the trial only takes into consideration a small sample size (11 teachers and 116 students) and is thus not indicative of the actual effectiveness of the iPad as an educational tool in schools. Additionally, it does not help to support his main argument that the Cloud will be the future of technology in education. Even though the effectiveness of the evidence provided by both authors in illustrating their claims is questionable, Freedman’s arguments stand stronger because his evidence illustrates his main argument that teachers are…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Modern day classrooms are occupied by computers. From Mac to PC, each classroom has at least one computer in them. Prior to the introduction of this technology, students were required to learn purely with reading materials and textbooks. The question that commonly arises among educators and facilitators involves the inquiring of the amount of usage of technology in the classroom.…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michelle Jaeckel says, “We need to be preparing students for what’s next, not just right now.” Planning for the future as technology advances allows students to be prepared for what lies ahead. The use of technology in classrooms is trial and error, Jaeckel also says , “I say, ‘That didn’t go well. Next time, what can we change to be successful for you and the students?’ or ‘That went really well. How can we go deeper?’” (Ed-Tech Coaches…). Having technology educated teachers helps create a successful learning environment for the…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Education has been revolutionized by the use of technology; students are no longer learning strictly out of textbooks and chalk boards. They now use the internet, computers, tablets, interactive whiteboards, document cameras, and some students attend virtual classes. With new technologies available, such as internet for example, students are able to access learning tools from virtually anywhere to obtain the help they need. These new technologies allow for a more personalized and…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First of all, I agree with Lamm that technology is a necessary tool for students. Nowadays, the internet and other technologies are required in the University, are the foundation for the education. Lamm points out a senior’ words “Because so many of my classes require online quizzes or paper submissions, it would be super hard to get through school without a personal computer”(81). Students need to use laptop to finish their homework and turn in their assignments, such as Canvas. Students can search information form the internet to help them to complete the assignment or use internet for self-learning. In Matt Richtel’s article “Growing Up Digital, Wired for Distraction,” he notes that “Vishal taught himself to use sophisticated editing software…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Technology is ever advancing and being implemented into the classroom just as quickly. Students and teachers are being told to use technology for assignments, lessons, eBooks, online grading system, and even talking to other students via school email. As technology in the classroom evolves and greatens, the problems with technology affects the classroom even more. Even though the rapidly advancing technology is being seen in majority of households there is a large percentage of households that cannot afford the technology at home or have a home. Especially schools that are found in a title 1 neighborhood, the percentage of students in poverty greatens as does the access to technology outside of school. Students not having access at home affects the lessons in class as well as what the teacher assigns for homework and there is two possible solutions.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sexting Research Paper

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Students reflect the changes in trending behavior today. It is increasingly obvious in the area of technology. Teachers and administrators must keep up with these changes in order to know what the students are using. These advances in technology creates challenges in the classroom. The teachers must incorporate the use of technology protocols into their classroom management plans. The school leaders must implement consequences for inappropriate use of technology into their discipline plans. The stakeholders, including all school leaders, staff, and parents must understand the legal responsibilities technology brings with the allowing its use.…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Some teachers resist change, including the use of technology. Many teachers rely on formative assessments using a “show of hands”. This may give the teacher an idea of how many students feel comfortable with a topic, but it does not provide insight to how much they know(Herr, et al, . Another popular method is the use of whiteboards. This is a method that I used to use myself. Again, there were many problems that I faced. First, was the distribution of markers, whiteboards and erasers. Then using more class time to replace any markers that had dried up. Next came the issue of students doodling on their whiteboard instead of paying attention. When I was finally able to ask a question and ask responses, I had to quickly process 35 whiteboards held up in the air at once. The largest drawback, however, was the inability to revisit student answers after they erased their whiteboards. Their answers were gone forever. A solution to this is to have students use notebooks to respond to questions in class. But, again, the logistics proves to be challenging. For these reasons it is not surprising that teachers were looking for better solutions to their problems. Classrooms began moving to a 1:1 classroom device model which include netbooks, iPads. Cell phones, and Chromebooks. There is not a lot of research into the effectiveness of Chromebook use in the classroom…

    • 2300 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Instead of participating in the appropriate educational tasks assigned, preoccupation ensues through the countless off topic websites that are available. According to Bonnie Thone Boylan, the author of “Technology in the Classroom: Too Much of a Good Thing”, “A quick stroll through a computer lab finds many students off topic, playing games, shopping or viewing YouTube” (Technology). Boylan’s quotation is an accurate representation of the ongoing conditions of the level of recreational distraction in classrooms across the United States. The more frightening matter on hand though, is the fact that the students are treating the situation with flippancy. For example, a recent study done by Cengage Learning on high school students, revealed what is really happening behind the monitors during educational purposed time. Sixty percent of those surveyed claim that texting is a source of much diversion, fifty percent are busy checking social-media, forty-five percent play online games, and twenty-five percent are engrossed in finding answers in order to cheat (Strang).These results are disheartening and they further prove that technology has become an interference in…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Virtue Private Technology

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages

    One of the ways technology is being used today is education. Many students learn by going online, watching videos, and playing games. Students nowadays are taking online classes and are being educated online. Instead of driving and attending class, they can enroll in an online course and complete assignments provided by the instructor and never have…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Students in this generation are known as digital natives because they have grown up with technology within their lives and are able to manipulate it well (Coviello, 2013). Technology is a great additive within every classroom because it can be manipulated to include every student in the classroom as well as the teacher. Technology can be arranged to fit any lesson plan and can also improve engagement because it something that children use on the daily basis within their homes. Being able to manipulate technology in school helps to boost motivation within students who are used to manipulating technology outside of the classroom. The classroom arrangement that best fits this method is one that a future teacher can and will be using within their own classroom. The layout starts with the Smart Board located at the front of the class in which each student is able to see. There is also a rug for students to use in which they can sit on and work on the board. The room is arranged to use the Smart Board, but not as a distraction. The students are split up into groups of four, which is good for cooperative learning. There are also centers in which the students will be able to manipulate items and keep them within that area, allowing for organization. Technology can and will be implemented in ones future classroom. Technology is use a great additive that is can be used within every subject; however,…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The problem, today, is that with the technology the students have a toy in front of them which is taking their concentration away from the teacher and to the device that they have. The teacher should be the main focus in the room, not the computer or whatever they have. They are even losing focus on what the assignment is. The students are too focused on what their assignment looks like rather than the content in it. “With the temptation of social media and texting in their hands, students may focus solely on their social life instead of the lesson plan” (pros and cons). The moment you put anything that has internet access on it, students will take advantage of it and go onto their social media sites and check in with everyone. With that comes not paying attention to the teacher in front of them and focusing on the website. Which then backfires on them and causes them to get behind in school work, fail assignments, and not learning what they are supposed to. Having technology in front of the students is causing them to not do well in school because of the distraction of social media and the…

    • 1312 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laptops, tablets, and cell phones are essentials that many students own that are very common, however, these devices have the ability to make anything possible to the user. Sophia Harris states that “the society of today has become quite reliant on technology,” (Harris 2) in her famous article Pros and Cons of Using Technology in Your Classroom. In a way Harris is right, technology, especially cellular devices, are being used so much that students have grew so accustomed to them everywhere they go. Not every student learns and takes in information the same way, in correspondingly, one key impact technology has brought to the classroom is the wide range of independent learning for every student and their different learning…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics