The Welfarist-Reformist Argument Analysis

Improved Essays
Now, to the con side of the argument. The “welfarist-reformist” idea mentioned above, while supported by groups like the Humane Society, have been denounced by stricter animal rights proponents, such as Tom Regan and Gary Francione, who consider reformist attitudes to justify and and feed animal exploitation. (Franco, 2013)
As mentioned, animal ethics and the advocation for their rights was on the rise, and this wave of thinking was so powerful and influential that “humane science” became a widely accepted idea that both scientists and governments advocated for and adopted for scientific conduct. In Russell and Burch’s The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique (famous for the development of the “3Rs”), they argued “humane science” as the “best science”, saying “If we are to use a criterion for choosing experiments to perform, the criterion of humanity is the best we could possibly invent.” Their principles of the
…show more content…
Like the pro side, I believe there are invaluable lessons to be learned thanks to information gained from animal testing in research. However, like the con side, I believe there is a need to improve the efficiency, efficacy, and translation between animal testing and clinical trials. There is far too much evidence of insufficient methods and practices of publishing and experimental practice. According to Ioannidis (2005), “if the true effect sizes are very small in a scientific field, this field is likely to be plagued by almost ubiquitous false positive claims.” According to Bart van der Worp et al (2010), “neutral or negative animal studies may be more likely to remain unpublished than neutral clinical trials, giving the impression that the first are more often positive than the second.” They also said that, “most animal studies have failed to acknowledge the inevitable delay between the onset of symptoms and the possibility to start treatment in

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Herzog Human Morality

    • 1432 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Humans, today, conflict with the problem of how humane it is to test and murder animals such as mice and worms. Despite having a viewpoint in “the troubled middle”, Harold Herzog discusses the moral line drawn from the killing of different species in his article, “Human Morality and Animal Research.” He looks over the moral obligations and historical context resulted from the murder of worms to mice to kittens to humans. Herzog discusses patterns between the human morality and situational error when faced with a problem of animal cruelty and research.…

    • 1432 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Animal Testing Satire

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Imagine having the choice of life or death left in your hands alone. On one end, there is a rat, who is energetically running to find a hiding spot from the broom sweeping across the floor. On the other end, there is a stay-at-home mom, jumped up on the table, violently stabbing at the rat in attempts to scare it away from her. One of them will die. Most people would choose to save the stay-at-home mother with three children and not have a guilty thought cross their mind.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This suffering has been deemed ethically permissible, provided that researchers express confidence in their ability to achieve predictable benefits to humans (Doke & Dhawale, 2015; Ferdowsian & Beck, 2011, p.2). Modern scientific knowledge paired with tragic historical instances of human drug toxicity has raised questions and concerns regarding the ethics of preclinical animal testing for both humans and animals. If humans are not benefitting from the suffering of animal testing models, then the permissibility parameters for their suffering are not being fulfilled. If preclinical animal data cannot be accurately translated to real-life human scenarios, then human trials are being conducted unethically, as risks may no longer be outweighed by benefits, and study participants do not consent to the possibility of unknown risks or the fact that the trial in which they are deciding to participate, has been designed based on inaccurate assumptions (Greek, Hansen & Pippus, 2012; Green,…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Despite the fact that there has been several medical advances in new drugs and treatments thanks to the help of animal testing, one cannot…

    • 1259 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The authors support their assertion by providing examples of needing animal experimentation for testing drugs and because some animal species are very similar to humans— genetical — so animals should continue to be tested, concluding “public opinion must be made aware that hypotheses in the biomedical field is just as likely to fail as in any other field of research. Only continuing trial- and -error to understand errors will show the best way to reach a goal” (34). The authors statement is necessary because in order to judge animal experimentation you must understand it from both sides— in order for researchers to progress even further they must continue trials and errors during animal experimentations. Their purpose is to make readers aware of the benefits of researching animals by animal experimentation from a researcher’s perspective, rather than just what is on the media. The authors establish a relationship of enlightenment with their audience of animal enthusiasts to show how essential animal experimentation is and that research thrives on “trial and error”…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    When animals are used in medical research, it is great way to uncover the mysteries and find treatments or even cures for various diseases. For example, in Shany Sun’s Young Scientists Journal article, “The Truth Behind Animal Testing,” the author says, “…medical advancements that have been discovered through animal testing include penicillin, blood transfusions, insulin (that controls blood sugar levels of diabetics), kidney transplants, and vaccines for polio and meningitis” (Sun 1). This example shows just how beneficial animal testing in medical research can be. These medical advancements would not have been available for years if animal testing had not…

    • 1614 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cassidy Walton Professor Marek English 1101 Sec. 54AZ 6 June 2018 Annotated Bibliography: Animal Testing Animal testing is one of the most frowned upon scientific experiments around, but the whole world needs this testing to save the human race. There are causes and effects just like any other scientific experiments. The testing of animals helps the human race better understand the way animals react to the cures, and to help find cures for the diseases.…

    • 1323 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Inaccurate Animal Testing

    • 1217 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Heart attacks, organ failure, and lethal dysrhythmias are only a few of the dreadful reactions humans have suffered through on medication as a result of the inaccuracy of animal testing (Greek). Using animals for experiments is incredibly inaccurate due to the vast differences between animal and human biological makeup (Animal Aid). As a result, during past experiments, medications have had “totally the opposite effect” on animals than they did on humans (Animal Aid). Consequently, after already turning innocent animals into unhealthy victims while producing these products, humans themselves have also become oblivious victims to this research technique as they consume these unreliable items. Scientists spend many stressful hours conducting research through this unstable technique, while their outcomes are rarely advancements in health care.…

    • 1217 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Despite the argument that animal testing is necessary when developing new medicine and data, it is undeniable that the number of tests carried out annually can, and should, be reduced dramatically. Alternatives in…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to source Q, animal testing on the arthritis drug Vioxx showed that it had a protective effect on the hearts of mice, yet the drug went on to cause more than 27,000 heart attacks and sudden cardiac death before being pulled from the market. Animal tests do not reliably predict results in human beings. According to Aysha Akhtar, over 100 stroke drugs that were effective when tested on animals have failed in humans, after working well in non-human primates and a study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America found that nearly 150 clinical trials of treatments to reduce inflammation in critically ill patients have been undertaken, and all of them failed, despite being successful in animal tests. (Source S) Animal testing may also mislead researchers into ignoring potential cures and treatments.…

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Animals have been used repeatedly in the past for biomedical research, in recent years animal testing has been under severe criticism by animal rights groups. Laws have been passed in many countries in order to make animal testing more ‘humane’ but many argue that the benefit to humans is not worth the torture to these defenseless animals. Scientists William Russel and Rex Burch publish a book titled “The principles of Humane Experimental Technique” in 1959 where they expressed their concerns with animal testing. Due to their concern along with other factors it led to the Animal Welfare Act by the U.S. federal government in 1966. Although the act did not stop animal testing it did ensure that the animals received proper care.…

    • 2007 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animal testing is inhumane and violates animal rights for many different reasons. First of all, testing on animals can lead to broken bones and chewed up body parts. “However, in the meantime, the monkeys were in terrible shape. Some had dislocated bones. One monkey had chewed off parts of every finger on one hand” (Geraldine woods).…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Animal Experimentation : Is It Wrong To Experiment On Animals? Currently, there is an ongoing battle between animal rights activists and scientific researchers on the topic of animal experimentation. While scientists believe that animal testing is needed for the betterment of life and is fundamental for research advancement, animal rights activists believe that testing on animals is unnecessary and should be replaced by alternatives. A scientific researcher, Gina Solomon, perfectly summed it up in this quote, “While we would prefer not to sacrifice a single laboratory rat, we believe that the sacrifice is warranted to protect our children and future generations.”…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “Should Animals Be Used for Scientific or Commercial Testing?” by procon.org, it states that by testing animals with new medications and drugs it has contributed life-saving cures and treatments; in the controversy, people against animal testing believe it is a cruel and ignominious procedure. Furthermore, animals are put through an agonizing amount of pain for the scientific procedures of testing new products and drugs. They are being starved and deprived of water for multiple days to test the reaction of the products.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Arguments for and against animal experimentation Animals have been used time and again at some stage in the records of biomedical studies. Early Greek physician-scientists, inclusive of Aristotle, (384-322 BC) and Erasistratus, (304-258 BC), accomplished experiments on dwelling animals (Franco, 2013). Likewise, Galen (129-199/217), a Greek physician who practiced in Rome and became a giant within the history of medication, performed animal experiments to increase the expertise of anatomy, body structure, pathology, and pharmacology (Franco, 2013). Indeed, animal experimentation has become a major aid to scientific research and development.…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays