The Power Of Dehumanization: A Human As A Human?

1073 Words 5 Pages
A human, according to TheFreeDictionary.com, is “a member of the primate genus Homo, especially a member of the species Homo sapiens, distinguished from other apes by a large brain and the capacity for speech. Because homo sapiens have larger brains and the capacity for speech, we see ourselves as superior - and in many ways we are. We, as a species, have created all that the material world has to offer and have constantly proven, to ourselves, that there is not much that we aren’t capable of doing. However, one thing that we - as a species- with our large brains and language, have not been able to do, is see each other as equals. This has been a problem since the dawn of time - our inability to accept each other’s differences as additions …show more content…
In “On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion,” by Mary Anne Warren, Warren suggests “that the traits which are most central to the concept of personhood” are consciousness, reasoning, self-motivated activity, the capacity to communicate, and the presence of self-concepts or self-awareness. This does not lend any room for computers or other inanimate objects, like Searle argues in “Minds, Brains, and Programs.” In Searle’s Chinese Room argument, he argues that computers work off of symbol manipulation, and are in fact just made up of a bunch of Chinese rooms that serve the purpose of manipulating symbols. This argument continues in his reply to robots: he argues that even if you were to put the Chinese room with him in it, inside the robot “with the Chinese symbols coming from a television camera attached to the robot”, he would still not “understand anything except the rules for symbol manipulation. (Hauser)” Because computers and all other forms of artificial intelligence work solely off of networks of Chinese rooms, and do not have qualia - an internal, subjective life - it is not possible that they could actually be human, or have any actual form of personhood. In fact, the only way that they could have “personhood” is if an organic human brain were recreated for the machine to use. So, for that reason, even though David, the protagonist of Steven Spielberg’s film A.I Artificial Intelligence, is both loving and adorable, there’s really no real moral issue with treating him differently than one might treat an actual human being; after all, David may look and act like a human, but he’s not. While David may show the five concepts of personhood, he is only replicating those concepts; because he is a man-made machine without an organic human brain, he is not able to

Related Documents