Alienation In Education

Superior Essays
Education has evolved into one of the most influential priorities in life and has transformed many lives. That influential necessity has however not always been beneficial in shaping one’s identity and ramifications. What could be known as traditional and morally good could be known as simply inadequate in some educational perspectives. The authors Rodriguez, Tan, and Kincaid all have experienced the pitfalls of assimilationist educational systems, as they had experienced alienation, and strain on their families communication. In each written piece, the authors had experienced the pitfalls of the assimilationist educational systems. In Rodriguez’s memoir, assimilation was a large concept of his educational, and social upbringing. Growing up in a predominantly white community, preserving his own cultural values had somewhat proved a difficult …show more content…
The author Rodriguez, was a victim of “ extreme public alienation ” ( Rodriguez ). English was not his first language and proved to be quite an intimidating language to speak in public. He was a dark skinned man in a predominantly white community with the desire to educate himself, and pursue his writing career. Rodriguez argued that denouncing public education encouraged public separateness. In “ Mother Tongue, ” Tan’s mother was an example of a victimized person alienated in american modern day society. Her mother could not speak the English language well, and was at times mocked for this. Her mother had long “ realized the limitations of her English ” ( Tan 702 ). She was treated poorly because others viewed her as estranged, and imperfect for not knowing how to accurately use the American language.Tan had long been embarrassed by her mother’s inability to accurately speak the language. Society had always described her english as broken, or unable to be

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Rodriguez "Aria" Rhetorical Analysis In Rodriguez essay Aria Memoir of a bilingual childhood describes a young boy named Rodriguez only able to speak Spanish which is referred as a private language throughout the essay and English being the public language. Rodriguez not being able to speak English made him an outcast from society. He only felt like himself only at home with his family that shared the same scenario as him. Rodriguez till this day would still be speaking Spanish if it wasn't for his teachers bringing their concerns to his parents that he will not succeed in his education unless he was taught English.…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She spoke excellent English, but her mother did not. When her mother would speak in the English language, Tan would be ashamed of her mother’s strong accent. She was ashamed of her mother’s tongue because her English language was broken as Tan described it, bringing attention to herself. She did not like speaking to customer service to interpret for her mother all the time. Tan wanted her own independence from her family, and having to speak for her mother made her feel like her mother was weighing her down.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kids Like Me Book Report

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Bierman, C., & McGaw, L. (1998). Journey to Ellis Island: How my father came to America. New York, N.Y.: Hyperion Books for Children.…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As a child with a Puerto Rican heritage, she grew up knowing Spanish as her first language. This, although not necessary a disadvantage, acted as one while she was growing up, and in her essay she expresses this feeling “…I express the sense of powerlessness I felt as a non-native speaker of English in the United States. Non-Native. Non-participant in the mainstream culture. Non, as in no, not, nothing” (Cofer 1).…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Despite the odds against her, Tan became a successful writer and proved everyone else wrong. Tan knew her mother was not as confident in herself as she was, and she knew that others faced the same obstacles her mother did, so she wrote this selection to help apprise the audience of the difficulties immigrants face everyday because they can not speak “normal”…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Meeting parental expectations and completing all of the “requirements” to be a successful son or daughter has always been part of the main goal and developing process for everyone, no matter how old the “child” is. Sandra Cisneros and Amy Tan, authors of two unique essays - "Only Daughter" and "Mother Tongue" - with the similar theme, are sharing their experiences and thought processes regarding that question. They have something in common – both women immigrated to the United States with their families and both decided to major in English to become writers. However, these are the only few similarities that authors have. Everything else is different and almost antithetical – mother that had her own “broken” English for Amy Tan and…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She says that being a Dominican-American novelist is the perfect illustration of the in-between that she has felt throughout her life. Alvarez describes one of the scariest pasts of coming to the United States as “losing [her] Spanish before getting a foothold in English” (Alvarez 1749). “I was without a language, without any way to fend for myself, without solid ground to stand on,” Alvarez tells the reader, illustrating with her own truth what she expresses through the fictional stories of the García family. Through this essay, Alvarez actively ties together her experience as an immigrant…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One thing that Mark , Richard and Malcolm had in common were their thoughts of education, but they had different backgrounds. Their past was hard and they thought that education was not worth it and a waste of time. Some of them were influenced by drug and gangs or they were driven apart from their family. Education/learning had a great effect in their lives . Richard Rodriguez was part of a Mexican family, that struggled with money.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The primary argument that Richard Rodriguez addresses in Aria: A Memoir of a Bilingual Childhood is the issue of bilingual education in America. He claims that he can’t be fully merged in American Society due to his “private” life, in other words his second language. Rodriguez also claims that because his original language is not the same as the “public” language, he is unable to create intimacy with someone who speaks a different language other than the public one. Lastly, he claims the use of a native language is impossible to have coexist with the “public” language. “It is not possible for a child, any child, ever to use his family’s language in school” (Rodriguez 448).…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Middlesex shows the assimilation process and what comes out at the end of it all, complete loss of culture shapes identity and something unidentifiable takes its place. For Lefty to keep his job at the factory he had to participate in a pageant, the "Ford English School Melting Pot", in which they must take off their 'immigrant costumes" and dress in "blue and gray suits... waving American flags" (104-105). At that point in time and even to this day there is a glorification of one's destruction of culture and ethnic identity, clear in the response of "thunderous applause" for these men's transformation (105). The whole point of an assembly line that Ford creates and encourages, is to be another faceless cog in this machine. In the end of his…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rodriguez properly targets his audience through the use of constant examples of people not being able to understand their heritage blending with their American culture. Within the essay Rodriguez explains that a boy named Michael was taught speak up and to stand straight. When that child went home and talked with his Chinese father, he was ridiculed because of his American ways. The targeted audience is towards those who do not understand how life in America is shaped by culture, as well as those who want a deeper explanation about American culture. The essay is written from the point of view of a Mexican American author, Richard Rodriguez.…

    • 1074 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Language has the power to connect people to their culture, history, and to other people, but language can also isolate a person and make them feel like an outsider to their own culture and family, or can make them feel foreign in their own tongue. Language can also empower a person in ways that will make him or her feel like they can control his or her own destiny. All of theses ideas are explored in The Language of Discretion by Amy Tan and in From Outside In by Barbara Mellix. Both Tan and Mellix feel like outsiders in the language each one uses, find a danger and excitement in knowledge and learning, and find a way to fit in with their respective languages. Barbara Mellix grew up surrounded by black english while her parents and teachers…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the story “Mother Tongue”, Amy Tan tries to distinguish the difference between two different cultures as a child. She is raised by her mother who speaks “broken” English, and the outside world where perfect English is spoken. Amy had a hard time as a child because of the different Englishes that were spoken. Tan as an adult continues to find the difference between the languages that are spoken, even though she knows that the one spoken by her mother will never improve. Tan’s attitude towards mother tongue starts as being embarrassed and ashamed, because Mother Tongue was the only type of English that her mother could speak.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Alienation is observed as an important phenomenon in all modern institutions. Despite having an old history;with prevalence, intensity and various forms ,alienation generally agree that there is a fundamental phenomenon of modern society. Alienation express their divergence from each of the individuals or from a particular environment in the broad sense. İnability,not to be connected internally, feelings of unfamiliarity, inability of integrate, disconnection of relations, indifference, the isolation, withdrawal, meaninglessness against something and such as feelings and behaviors are considered as indicators of alienation.…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Dexter provides us with excellent insight as to the effects of cultural assimilation within the public school system within her article “Communicating Care Across Culture and Language.” Dexter proposes that the American public school system is greatly underserving its diverse cultural groups. Her article deals specifically with a school who’s students are predominately Latin-American, while most of the teachers are white. Dexter expresses her concern for these students, as the school system does not seem to be properly accommodating their linguistic needs.…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays