The Pinto: The Ford Pinto Case

Superior Essays
Looking for a car to compete with foreign imports, Ford Motor Company sought a lightweight and inexpensive automobile to address the market share they were losing to their foreign competition. Therefore, Ford Motor Company developed a 1971 model named the Ford Pinto to answer gaining back market share against the foreign automakers. In order to roll it out on time, Ford Motor Company would need to cut the design and production period nearly in half of a normal schedule. Due to the fast-tracked timeline, the Pinto went through the testing phase after the production of the car. Unfortunately, Ford discovered, during the testing, there was an issue with the placement of the gas tank if the Pinto endured a hit on the rear bumper at speeds greater …show more content…
The decision on whether to move forward with the existing design directly affects Ford Motor Company. Will customers find the car desirable if Ford redesigns the trunk to fix the issue? Ford complied with the laws and regulations of that time, and they were quickly losing the market share to foreign car manufacturers. It was most likely the result of changing the length of the schedule causing the company to test the car’s safety after production. Based on the regulations of that time, Ford believed they were compliant with the law. If Ford pushes back the production schedule to fix the design flow, they most likely miss the window to gain some of the subcompact market and lose money to the bottom line. As for Lee Iacocca, he benefited from rolling out this car on schedule. It would not only benefit him professionally, but personally in monetary form. This action would also affect the customers that purchased the Ford Pinto. Despite the low price for an American made car, would a customer purchase the car knowing that it had a possibility of bursting in flames if hit on the rear bumper during a collision? Alternatively, perhaps the customer would weigh the excellent price against the risk for adequate transportation. Severe burns or death is a potential consequence for those purchasing this car. Is it worth this risk …show more content…
“Additionally, we cannot know all of the consequences of a particular act nor can we know in advance many of the specific consequences” (DeGeorge 48). After making the initial decision, it may have been a different outcome if Ford changed the design after the first year or offered customers an option to purchase the baffle. The jury may have acquitted Ford of any criminal charges, but they paid a hefty price in lawsuits, negative publicity, and loss of faith by their employees, customers, and the American public. Weighing all of these factors, the greatest pleasure did not occur in Ford’s decision to manufacture the car with the defect. It was not an ethical

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    So their influence on Mr. Iacocca’s decision to continue the pinto production would have been prevented. For starters, Ford Motor Company and its engineers failed to use the ultimate goal of Utilitarianism during the development and production of the Ford Pinto. Because Utilitarianism is based on the premise that our ethical choices, like other types of decision, should be based on their outcome......it consider both short-and long-term consequences when making ethical determination (Craig E.J., 2016). The ethical dilemma of lack of Altruism emerged from the engineers’ action once it became known that the result of the crash was a design flaws from the pinto; their interest was more on profit than saving life. They choose to disregard ethics of Moral Sensitivity whether or not they profit from doing so. Is quite obvious those involved with the Ford Pinto dilemmas experienced deontological ethics.…

    • 1821 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Within a year their shares dropped to fifty percent and continued to plummet. Henry refused to entertain the idea of a new automobile because he thought that the Model T, was the perfect car ever built. He was obsessively committed to his vision of a perfect Model T car, now the same thing making him successful was now making him vulnerable. Every man in Ford except for Henry believed that a new automobile was needed including his own son. Even though Edsel despised conflict and tension with his father, he became convinced that times had changed and Ford needed to release a new model. Time and time again, Edsel would arrive at his father’s office with a set of new car plans under his arm but he was sent back. This ongoing fight went for over a year. After one discussion Henry demanded one of his colleague to send Edsel on a holiday to California and that he would “send for him” when he wanted to see him again.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This essay is going to talk about one of the most debated arguments in the truck industry; why Ford is better than Chevy. Like the iconic and historical slogan says, Fords are built tough. Chevy’s have many problems and flaws within their products and this has caused a good amount of people to switch over from Chevy’s to Ford’s. Ford focuses on performance, comfort, and entertainment when designing their vehicles. In this essay these three factors are going to be broken down piece by piece to prove that a Ford is better than a Chevy.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The impact that Henry Ford made on transportation is one of the only reasons the United States grew and prospered so much at the time. Ford wanted to sell an automobile that anyone could afford to buy. He said “It will be constructed of the best materials, by the best men to be hired, after the simplest designs that modern engineering can devise.” On October 1, 1908, the first automobile that Ford Motor Company made was completed. This first automobile was the Model T, it was sold for $825, or about $18,000 in today’s world. This automobile was built mainly for people to drive every day. The Model T put the United States on wheels, it made mobility easier than ever, and it established the American middle class. This automobile may not have…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Built Ford Tough. When one thinks of a company that manufactures pickup trucks, one would envision a company that builds the toughest, meanest, longest lasting truck ever- huge four wheel drive off road machines, with poor gas mileage-a tool to get the job done. This is definitely what I envisioned. Similarly, one could assume the target audience for a pick-up would be brawny, blue-collared construction workers or farmers who tow huge loads on dirt roads with ruts galore. They require a machine-better yet-a tool for work, something that is tough, manly, and no-nonsense. This is a Spartan, utility first, comfort second do-it-yourself type of vehicle, not a suburbanite grocery getter with leather seats, navigation, and a built in vacuum for spilled…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The parents of the victim immediately suit Honda for the death in which they stated complaining that the seat belt was defective and had caused Karen’s dead because the design of the car made it impossible to disengage herself. However, a products liability action is one case that the plaintiff claim the products design was defect. Although, it must…

    • 432 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chevy Cobalt Case Summary

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages

    When the GM engineers collaborated to determine an ignition switch replacement, the user-based approach to quality should have been applied. Allowing the consumer to be a part of the product production would have given the company a non-biased view on the design. “The user-based definition favours the consumer but poses important challenges for the managers who must be in a position to measure customers’ subjective perceptions and then translate them into operational efficiency” (“Re-defining”, n.d.). The likely-hood that GM will use this method is uncertain, however, an educated guess would say that the user-based approach would require GM to do some extra work that they may be trying to avoid. The automotive industry as a whole has built a reputation of giving the consumer what they think the consumer wants. Seeking the opinion of the end user would cause GM to remove its selfish, internal culture and allow the customers the opportunity to enlighten the automaker on what they would like to have crafted in a vehicle…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gladwell discusses a universal issue that relates the association between the amount of deaths and automobile safety. Two main factors that impact the correlation between deaths and auto-safety are tolerance of the system and use of prioritizing certain issues. Gladwell portrays engineers as individuals with the ability to view situations differently because of their fascinating mentality. Throughout the article, Gladwell expresses an objective tone, by constructing his argument based on facts and statistics. An engineer uses an extraordinary process to resolve…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As previously stated, even though Ford produced the Pinto to provide an affordable, domestically made vehicle allowing car ownership by many more consumers, it still does not truly benefit all people. Ford designed a hazardous product and rather than fix it, they decided to ignore the facts as well as disregard human life and disregard their utilitarian responsibilities. By Sandel’s standards, Ford broke one of the main platforms of utilitarianism and is therefore at fault and responsible for all of the wrong doings that ensued. Furthermore, Ford should not be able or willing to put a price tag on an individual’s life. By Ford’s willingness to stamp a price tag on each person killed or injured as the result of their faulty cars shows a disregard for individual’s…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It rested in the driveways of only the wealthiest families. Most models were complicated machines that required a chauffeur to control them. However, in 1908 there was major shift in the public eye, when an individual named Henry Ford gave birth to the most widely used vehicle the world has known; the Model T Ford. The roads of the United States started to transform from the galloping sounds of horses pounding on the pavement, to the thundering echoes of fuel motors being revved. Ford revolutionized the concept of the automobile from one of extravagance to one of basic necessity. Henry Ford 's progressive headways in the revolutionizing of the assembly-line successfully delivered a car that was inside the financial compass of the average American. Assembly-line production permitted the cost of the Model T to be minimalized from $850 in 1908 down to under $300 in 1925. Ford reduced the cost of production per unit in order to decrease the price while still allowing his company to generate profit. This extra money in the pocket of the consumer allowed individuals to increase their standard of living without having to increase their salary. The Model T Ford was set on the highest platform not because of its performance, but as a result of its low price tag, reliability, versatility, and simplicity of maintenance. By the 1920s, Ford was producing well over half the cars in the…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Importance Of Deontology

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The pinto scandal where they used a cheap gas tank and the vehicle exploded with flames in crashes, as well as car doors that where difficult to open and resulted in an emergency hazard, is something they concealed, the buyer bought a cheap affordable vehicle, without really understanding what it meant or seeing how horrifying this would turn out to be. From the utilitarian stand point, the company failed to consider the happiness and pleasure of the society, yes, they sold them a cheaper product they could afford, but like Mill mentioned they did not consider the long run drawbacks of their decision. They were focused on the temporary satisfaction of the buyer to buy a cheap car and they disregarded the fact that the car will eventually lead to their deaths and the misery of society, they knew of these factors but the profit and temporary satisfaction of buyers outweighed their decision, which resulted in a decrease in the level of happiness in society, since those crashes not only affect those cars, but all other cars, as they easily become engulfed in flames. They chose to deceive the public and as Kant pointed out we need to make actions that we want to reflect us in society. The company did not reveal this information and in so promoted the concept of not being honest and fair with the people you are doing business…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As seen in the Pinto Case, Ford came to a decision by using cost-benefit analysis in which a monetary value was put to human life. According to Sandel, “cost benefit analysis tries to bring rationality…to complex social choices by translating all costs and benefits into monetary terms—and then comparing them”(Sandel, p. 41). He later claims this flaw in utilitarian reasoning is through moral theory; one can not put a monetary value to human life. Similar to the reasoning presented in the Pinto case, in The Benefits of Lung Cancer, Phillip Morris, a tobacco company, used a cost-benefit analysis of the monetary effects smoking has on the Czech Republic national budget. The final claim: the positive effects of smoking, such as tax revenues and premature deaths, outweigh the negative effects, such as losing human lives, with the treasury gaining a net of $147 million per year because of smoking. Once again, a dollar and cent value was tacked onto a human life, which Sandel argues is morally incorrect. In both The Benefits of Lung Cancer and The Pinto Case they abuse the views of utilitarian reasoning through cost-benefit analysis; in which utility thinking is misapplied and…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ford Ethical Dilemmas

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When it comes to the auto industry, one of the largest ethical questions is whether a company can put a dollar amount on human lives. Throughout the history of the automobile industry, there is to be case after case where automotive manufactures try to walk the fine line of using specific parts in a car to try and lower their costs, but also while making the vehicle more dangerous for the passengers. The idea of safety versus cost in the industry has many factors that must be considered to fully understand the ethical dilemmas.…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Based on Ford Pinto cases, we can ask, “How utilitarian principle take an action in a matter?” To answer this question, the following step of act utilitarian approach is useful; first, identify the options available, especially on the consequences of certain actions. Second, determine the appropriate audience for selection. Third, remember that any choice is chosen, it sets an example for others, and others in the same state will be allowed in making similar selections. Fourth, making an available options will likely bring the best benefits to the right audience, taking into account the dangers and benefits. This utilitarian approach is helpful for making ethical issues. For example in this Ford Pinto case, the economic cost is the main problem in this company. The choice between two safety devices in product design in determining which is more likely to reduce death and injury. Therefore, the utilitarian determination brings a high moral level, though, in some cases, they turn out to be…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Pinto case raises many moral issues. First, the case states that Ford knew of the faults of the Pinto and continued to sell them – even after they failed testing. Next, the company used a cost-benefit analysis that put a price on human lives in comparison to the amount they would have to pay to fix the issue. Ford was also involved in many lawsuits; however, they were never charged of crime but rather paid money to those impacted. Ultimately, Ford never admitted their mistake or told their customers, but rather, they claimed that they met government standards despite the safer foreign-made vehicles of the time.…

    • 2054 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays