Compare And Contrast Indian Camp And Hemingway

Improved Essays
People walk through life as if everything is complete, even though the person may not be complete themselves. When reading “Indian Camp” by Ernest Hemingway, readers come across a character named Nick. He is a seemingly young boy with a very innocent mind and demeanor. In “Clouds” by Aristophanes there is a character named Pheidippides.When reading the story readers see that Nick has a lot of curiosities and unfinished questions which make him an unfinished person.

In both texts there is an aspect of inquisitive behavior with both characters. Nick had more of a questioning behavior because he was more innocent. He would ask questions when certain things were happening because he was genuinely curious about what was going on. In the story Nick
…show more content…
The characters are similar in this aspect, but are different when it comes to what they need to learn. Nick is a young boy who is very innocent and know basic knowledge. In order for him to grow up he has to learn and experience new things that may be surprising or unsettling for him. At the end of “Indian Camp” Nick is asking a lot of questions about the scene that had taken place just before his uncle left.(pg.70) His father had answers for him but he was very blunt and passive when it came to answering them. Even with the short answers from his father Nick had experienced something new and unsettling for him. This in turn had made him older in a sense. Pheidippides has more learning to do, not because he is as innocent as Nick, but he needs to realize that their is always more to learn. Pheidippides has an almost cocky attitude toward more knowledge. He isn 't even sure about what he is supposed to learn and so he feels the need to ask his father (p.4). Pheidippides may be older than Nick, but he has more learning to do because he is skeptical about who he is going to be learning from yet they can offer him so much knowledge that would very beneficial to …show more content…
People all around walk through life learning new things everyday. They meet new people and encounter new experiences. This is depicted in both stories. Nick hasn’t experienced much in his life because he is fairly young. As he went through the whole situation with his father and his uncle he started to find out more things and had experienced seeing death for the first time (p.69). At the end of the story you could see a change in his attitude and his demeanor. He was now quiet and not asking anymore questions. It was almost as if he grew up a little bit after finding out new information. He will then go on the have more experiences which will change who he is at that exact moment. Pheidippides feels like he knows the things that he needs to know and that he’s all set. His father feels that he needs more learning instead of caring about unimportant things, like his race horses (p.2). By the end of the story, Pheidippides starts questioning his father’s belief in Zeus and questioning whether or not he exists, which leads to his father wanting to burn down the thinkery (p.35). Pheidippides has gained more knowledge, but there is more that he needs learn even though his father is now against it.

In conclusion, no one is ever a finished person. There is always something new to learn and new to experience in our everyday lives. A person’s character and action change depending on what they have learned and experienced in

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Nick described himself as to be young and more vulnerable. It states in the story "I'm my younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some advice that I have been turning over in my mind ever since. " This is what he described himself at the beginning of the novel. 3.) Nick described Tom Buchanan as someone who had been hovering restlessly.…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nick is already seeing the modes of conduct of his parents. His father often dismisses Nick’s mother and goes to her when he wants to feel better about a situation. In “The Doctor and the Doctor’s Wife”, Dr. Adam goes to his wife and gets into a fight after being in conflict with Dick Boulton. After Nick’s mom tries to understand what happened between Dick Boulton and Dr. Adams, Nick’s father gets defensive and leaves the house. To feel better about himself, Dr. Adams goes to the woods where Nick guides him towards the squirrels.…

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    At the beginning of the story Nick describes himself as not being judgmental toward people. Nick was taught this as a young child and tried to live this in his everyday life. Nick also describes himself as being a modest person. He shows this in the home he chooses to live in. Instead of living in the city he chooses and old home out away from the city that was not in the best of shape.…

    • 3381 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prometheus’ individuality emerges as a direct result of his increasing intelligence. While in the Home of the Students, he acknowledged the studies were too easy for him. He states that it is a great sin to be more intelligent than his brothers around…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ceecret Cummings Mrs. Trapp English III May 2016 Lessons Learned In the two stories, The Great Gatsby and A Lesson Before Dying, there are many things and concepts that could be taken from both of them. Even thought these are two different books with two different plots and topics, when looked deeper into, it can be seen that they have some of the same concepts. One thing is that they both have life lessons that should be learned from the situations that they were both put into.…

    • 2386 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critical Analysis Review for The Great Gatsby and Macbeth Macbeth: 1.Summary: The three witches tell Banquo and Macbeth about the prophecies, Macbeth will become King and Banquo will be a father of a line of kings. Banquo is sceptical of what is being said to him and Macbeth is hesitant to believe them at first. Ross told Macbeth that the king gave him the title of thane of cawdor and now he believed the witches. How: Macbeth was behaving timidly, when he got told the news by Ross he automatically thought about killing the king to make the last prophecy become a reality.…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the story, The Great Gatsby, Nick admires Gatsby for everything he is and has become in life he looks at Gatsby as himself and what he could become while learning from Gatsby. Nick truly feels that Jay is The Great Gatsby. Nick's reasons for admiring Gatsby are, he is fascinated to imperfection, Gatsby is Nick's role model, and he admires the knowledge he gains during his journey with Gatsby. The first reason Nick admires Gatsby is that he is attracted imperfection.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The conclusion of Nick’s development is shown in both parts of the short story, "The Big Two-Hearted River". These stories show the end result of Nick’s growth, but also show that he is still growing and trying to change into a better person. Nick chose to go camping and fishing to get his mind off the war and his life, but to also reflect on all the opportunities he’s given, the people he met, and the things he learned. Some of these include, Bugs, who had shown him to how to clean up his plate with bread, and Hopkins, who had told him how to make good coffee during the war. However, Nick made this coffee wrong, which shows that he still has learning to do (Hemingway 140-142).…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Carelessness is the behavior of a neglection that one many portray in their decision. In the 1920s, people were reckless and did not care what the turnout would be. They would go to a party and have one too much drinks; go behind the wheel and get into a car when they know they were unable to drive is one of many examples of carelessness. The Great Gatsby, a novel written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, is not only based on romance and love, but it foreshadows the lack of responsibility and self control these characters have in the novel. Carelessness is pivotal in the character’s lives because they are blinded from reality; they are only living through their wealth which causes them to do wreckage to their lives.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nick and Gatsby’s characters don’t change throughout the book, however Daisy does based on the events that happen in her life. Nick is a curious man, always trying to learn more about Gatsby. He is also Daisy’s cousin. All he wanted to do was figure out how Gatsby got up in life and made his money, He also wanted to figure out about what he wanted with his cousin, Daisy. People feel like they can confide in Nick, he says, “I am…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His love of Jordan Baker also characterizes his wonderment of the different people that live around him and their untraditional personalities. His fondness of Gatsby near the end also shows that he has a good heart and that even though he wasn’t experiencing it himself, he understood what Gatsby went through and Gatsby’s ambitions. The character of Nick is quite realistic because he has the actions and thoughts of an above average man in the 1920’s influenced by the…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mamesarr Seck Mr.Martin 20th century Tormented vs Healing Understanding modernity is complex and they’re are so many sides of which you could think if it. SOme praise modernity and some don't. Hemingway and Kawabata for example, are perfect examples of contradicting outlooks on modernisms. The six short stories of these authors are intricate in the way they think and how they accept life.…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The choices made by today’s media, such as “news reports” and television shows flaunting celebrities famous for being celebrities, might show that the world is solely populated by materialists. But, pondering the situation, one must come to see that at least a portion of those watching these “news reports” of fashion and celebrity icons must be romanticists. They pine for a better life for themselves or their family, but do not have the good fortune to be one of the rich or famous. Another completely separate faction are realists when it comes to such “news” programs and the misplaced attention on the rich and famous. This group may take a short moment to assess the situation and then do what is called for: change the channel.…

    • 1432 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He claims to be honest and holds himself to a moral standard that, in turn, causes him to pass critical judgement onto the actions of others. Nick’s reactions and descriptions of his experiences reveal…

    • 1488 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Nick seems to be a flat character through most of the novel. as he is mostly a observant of his surroundings and does not show much change in his character. For the trait of Nick, I see him as very judgmental as he just observes on other characters and honest as he tells secrets about Jay Gatsby and truth to his fellow company. 6. Significant Character and Description #2: (6-12…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays