The Negative Effects Of The Winner-Take-All Method

Improved Essays
In the current US election system, citizens do not directly vote for their next President. Instead, there is a group called The Electoral College that carries out that function. Citizens Cast their votes and then those votes are tallied up by state. Once tallied, the Electors, also known as Representatives, of the states go and place their votes. Each state has a certain amount of electoral votes placed by those electors. Whoever those Electors vote for is to whom all the electoral votes of that state count towards. This is known as the Winner-Take-All method. In the end, whichever candidate has the most electoral votes wins the election, regardless of whomever had the majority of the popular vote. If neither has the majority of electoral …show more content…
The spoiler effect is caused when a candidate loses a state that he or she should have won. This is caused when supporters of a third party decide to vote for the third party candidate instead of going with one of the two main party candidates that had similar political views. This draws votes away from that candidate, allowing the other major candidate to win. One major example of this is the Gore versus Bush election of 2000. According to Gary Bugh, in the 2000 election, Nader received around 90,000 votes in Florida, which resulted in George Bush winning Florida (51). Bugh also stated, that if the citizens who voted for Nader would have voted for their second choice, which would have been Al Gore, that Gore would have won Florida (51). The same thing happened in the state of New Hampshire that year. According to Robert Dudley, who has a Ph.D. in Political Science, and Eric Shiraev, who has a Ph.D. in Political Psychology, Bush had beaten Gore by only around 7,000 votes (141). Later on Dudley and Shiraev said that according to the polls 8,000 of the 22,000 who voted for Nader would have voted Gore before Bush (141). Many times by voting a third party, these citizens end up voting in a candidate farther from their views than their second choice (Bugh, …show more content…
The first way this may happen is that although one candidate may have received a majority of the popular vote, neither may have received the majority of the electoral vote. This means that the House of Representatives would choose between the candidates and they do not have to choose the candidate with the majority of the popular votes. According to Bugh, the 1824 election of Jackson versus Adams was the first occurrence of this (48). In this election, Jackson had more popular votes but neither had the majority of electoral votes (Bugh, 48). But instead of choosing Jackson, who had the majority of the popular votes, the House of Representatives chose Adams (Bugh, 48). Another way a wrong winner could be elected is if the candidate wins the majority of electoral votes, but not win the majority of the popular vote. Thus, a majority of the people may have actually wanted one candidate, but the other candidate would win. According to Lawrence Longley, a presidential scholar and political scientist, and Neal Pierce, an American journalist on local government, a wrong winner has been elected three times as of 1999

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Voting In New Mexico

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The citizens vote, then the electoral vote based off of the popular vote, and then the electoral votes go to one side by the “winner-take-all policy”. From there, the electoral votes are added up and whichever candidate gets 270 or more electoral votes. The process also hands more power to the states, rather than just the government. As described above, the state citizens and state electrons have an opportunity to pick either party/candidate majority of the state wants to win.…

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dbq Electoral College

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In correlation with the Great Compromise, each state was permitted the number of votes equivalent to the number of members in Congress. Choosing these electors was each state’s responsibility. Although this later evolved at the time political parties emerged, each elector voted for two different candidates. The candidate with the most votes was determined to be the president while the runner up was elected to the vice president…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each state was left to decide how to choose its electors. Their options included popular election or appointment by the state legislature. There are no recorded popular vote totals for the first few presidential elections because all the state legislatures appointed their electors without the direct input of the public. They declared that the candidate with the majority of electoral votes became the president and the one who came in second would be the vice president. Everybody got something: large states got electoral votes based on their population and small states got an assurance of at least three electoral votes and a contingency procedure based on a one-state-one vote principal.…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Our founding fathers established this process between the Congress and popular vote by the people to elect a President of the United States. An Electoral College is that each state is the same number as senators ans representativies that is present in the U.S. Congress. Total number of votes including the District of Columbia is 538. In order for a Presidental Elect to when his/her seat as Presidental of the United States by the Electoral College is 270 votes. Since the radification of the Twelfth Amendment in 1804 and still the constitional foundation for presidental elections today (O’Connor, Sabato, Yanus pg. 330).…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “...The Electoral College makes sure that the states count in Presidential elections...federalism [the combination of a central government with some authority given to state and local governments] is central to our grand constitutional effort to restrain power” (Document C). Although initially intended to lend an ear to the public’s preferred candidate for the Presidency, there are no laws or amendments stating the members of the Electoral College must vote in accordance with the state they represent. Due to this error in representation of the public, the Electoral College rules according to the “minority” vote - going against the basic principles of Democracy. In all transparency, as noted in the elections of 1824, 1876, 1888, and 2000, it is possible for the popular candidacy vote to be negated by the Electoral College vote (Document G). In the election of 1842, Jackson was the popular choice, yet the Electoral College voted against the States and chose Adams for the Presidency.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A state 's number of electors are determined by the state 's total number of members in congress. This means each state 's gets one elector per representative in the House, plus two electors for the two members in the Senate. The method of election for the electors is not specified in the constitution. Many states have adopted a system where the party that wins the majority of the popular vote chooses the electors. Another way states have chosen electors is giving the choice to the state legislature.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, they came up with the Electoral College. In this system, the president is chosen indirectly. Each state gets a number of electoral votes based on how numerous the numbers of the members are in the House of Representatives are,…

    • 1009 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Electoral College Flaws

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In 2000, Al Gore won the popular vote, but George W. Bush won the electoral college. Even though, a majority of people wanted Al Gore as president, because of the electoral college the want of the majority was denied. A candidate could campaign heavily in states such as Florida, California, New York, and other states with high electoral college votes and win the votes in those states. This would give the president an extensive edge on their opponent in the election even if the other candidate had the majority of people on their side. This problem is a great one, but it is not the largest.…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The founding fathers of our nation spent over two months trying to devise a plan that would have a fair and just way of elected our nation’s principal administrator. The Electoral College is constructed of state electors that equal the number of the United States House of Representatives plus the 2 senators from each state. The District of Columbia has three electoral votes even though it is not a state and has no voting representation (“Presidential Election Process”). There are 538 electors total for the Electoral College and 270 electoral votes are needed to win the presidential election (“Presidential Election Process”). These individuals are picked by the political parties of the states that they represent and they vote in December and Congress then tally’s these votes in January.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Electoral College Dbq

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Afterwards, the American people vote on which candidate they would like to have in office. These votes then go the The Electoral College who, then in turn, vote again.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Consisting of a total of 538 electors the Electoral College of the United States of America is the organization that elects, every four years, the President and Vice President. The Founding Fathers of America, such as Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, George Washington, among many others, established the Electoral College in the Constitution, in the late 1700’s, whom the Congressional Digest claims was entrenched “as a compromise between election of the President by Congress and election by direct popular vote.” With the Electoral College, the citizens of the United States have the opportunity to elect their representative every four years. Every four years on Election Day, which takes place in the first Tuesday after a Monday in the month of November, those who meet the requirements, such as being 18 years old and an American citizen, have the right to vote for the President and Vice President that they believe will not only be their voice for the next for years but also be a great contributor to the success of their country. Both the President and the Vice President are allowed to reclaim their position for a second consecutive year in which they must go through the Electoral College process, gain the voters trust, and win the election for a second time.…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every four years, citizens of the United States of America choose their next president based off a unique system known as the electoral college. The way that this system works is interesting and is confused easily in the general public. In early November, when citizens go to the polls, they are not voting for the president directly, rather they are voting for their individual states to cast its electoral votes towards a certain presidential candidate. In the forty-eight of the fifty states where voting takes place, all the electoral votes go to the presidential candidate who wins the majority in their state. No matter how large or small the majority is, the presidential candidate gets all the votes.…

    • 1924 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Voters in battleground states listen to the argument of both parties. They do not focus as much on the states heavily supporting a certain party. The electoral college, helps balance the influence of large states, meaning states with a large population. It helps when neither candidate receives the popular vote, for example, Clinton in 1992 and Nixon in 1964 (Posner 2012) and Jefferson in 1800 (Ginsberg…

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Controversy has been raised recently over whether the deciding factor of who is to win the United States presidency should be the votes of electoral college or popular vote. The United States Constitution, population of the states, and election fraud give valid reasons as to why Electoral votes are counted in the elections instead of popular vote. Popular vote is based off of the opinions of each individual person in the United States. The Electoral College is made up of Electors from each state that are put into office by voters in each state.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The United States election process is one of great importance and significance to the American government. Yet voting can be one of most confusing topics to its citizens. How does an election work? How does your vote make a difference in our county? What is the Electoral College and what is its purpose?…

    • 1672 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays