The Myth Of The Vanishing Indian Essay

Good Essays
The Myth of the Vanishing Indian has served a vital function in U.S. history. The removal of the Cherokees indeed illustrates the pervasiveness of this myth. After the arrival of the Europeans to the Americas, the indigenous population dwindled significantly. This myth attempts to explain this phenomena by claiming that the disappearance of Native Americans after their contact with the European settlers was inevitable unless they assimilate because they were “culturally and genetically weaker”. Essentially, the myth was formulated by the white people to justify taking Native American land because they were interested in expanding the United States. The pervasiveness of the Myth of the Vanishing Indian can demonstrated with the Cherokee removal …show more content…
Civilization Program and assimilate the Native Americans to white culture in order to maintain peace with them. Nevertheless, their main intention was to acquire land from the indigenous people. During that era of history, the Cherokees were suffering economically due to the deterioration of the deerskin market because the deers were dying off. As a result, the tribe was experiencing a lack of food and President George Washington pitched a solution after noticing this. First and foremost, Washington encouraged the Cherokees to shift into a farming-based society as opposed to hunting, claiming that it would alleviate their hunger issues. However, this indicates that they won’t need a vast amount of land for their hunting lifestyle, thus giving the U.S the opportunity to buy it. Because of this, the government aimed to teach the Cherokees about the economic value of their property. The United States was looking to “expand with honor”, so the government resorted to more creative methods such as this to take Native land without inflicting violence. The Myth of the Vanishing Indian comes to play here because the U.S. is urging the Cherokees to leave their “savage” hunting lifestyle behind and adopt farming. Although farming played a role in Cherokee society, the fact that they are being encouraged to abandon hunting depicts that if they decide to assimilate, a part of their cultural identity will disappear. …show more content…
The Treaty Party, which was a minority political faction of Cherokees, signed the treaty. Therefore, the Cherokee territory was ceded to the United States legally since a treaty is a legal document. After this point, the United States had the right to relocate the Cherokees west of the Mississippi River. It was widely believed that Cherokee politician John Ridge was bribed by U.S officials into signing the treaty and consequently, he was brutally murdered by his fellow tribe members after they moved west. In May 1838, the U.S military had circled the Cherokee Nation in order to enforce this treaty. Thousands of indigenous people ended up perishing in the detrimental journey due to the lack of food and bitter winter. The United States government didn’t have to take responsibility for this tragic outcome because the Cherokees agreed to the treaty, even though a minority group signed it. Therefore, the brutality of the Trail of Tears was lawful and allowed to occur due to this legal document being

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    On May 28, 1830, Congress passed the Indian Removal Act. The law authorized Andrew Jackson to negotiate with Indians for their removal to federal land west of the Mississippi River in exchange for their homelands. Andrew Jackson was able to convince the American people that Indians could not coexist peacefully with them. He argued that the Indians were uncivilized and needed to be guarded from their own savage ways. As a result of his actions, thousands of Indians were forcibly ripped from their homes and onto a journey to a unknown territory, that was not as fertile as their home grounds.…

    • 2378 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In1807, Doublehead, a fearsome Cherokee chief and warrior sold Native land without approval from the council of the Cherokee nation; he was named a traitor by the Cherokees. Due to the immense loss of land, the Cherokee elders decided that any land sales with their approval would be a crime punishable by death. In past years, they had been selling land to the United States government and now the nation was so small that they simply couldn’t afford to lose any more land. So the Cherokee council made this sale of land a crime punishable by death. He was eventually killed after a long struggle but the Cherokee nation shed no tears for him.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Elected president in 1828, Jackson did everything in his power to get rid of the natives in the south. He believed that they were not supposed to be there and they were in the way of westward expansion of the government. Jackson and his cabinet members had a few different ideas on how to deal with the Natives. They were: allowing white settlers to violate Indian lands, having the federal government move in so they could enforce treaties, forcing the Indians to acclimate by taking away government protection, or removing them from the guaranteed land given to them by treaties and sending them to unsettled western lands. Andrew Jackson also said that, “The consequences of a speedy removal will be important to the United States, individual states, and to the Indians themselves.” This is to mean that he believes that removing the Indians from the south will help the United States in becoming a better…

    • 1763 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The policies the presidents passed was to take the lands of the Indians, but they had different ways of doing so. Thomas Jefferson saw the American Indians as being similar to the Europeans in mind and body since they worked hard to protect their lands and saw themselves as free people. He believed that the American Indians were good human material but the only issue he had was their culture. Most Americans, including Jefferson, saw American Indian culture as savagery but believed they could be civilized through education, Christian religion, and commercial agriculture. The Indians felt pressured for the land so some tribes decided to accept the policy to assimilate into civilization as a means of survival to avoid wars with the white Americans.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During the Nineteenth Century, western expansion was erupting in America, and federal policy decided that certain tribes had to be confined to fixed land plots to continue their traditional lifestyles. American Indians were being forced off of their lands, and they were not adjusting well. Federal policy was trying to Americanize the “savage” indians so that they could be introduced into American society. American Indians were sent to live on small areas of land within a group’s territory that was reserved exclusively for their use, or reservations. Native Americans retaliated against the American government wanting to relocate them due to it’s former policy of treating the much of the west as Indian preserved territory.…

    • 283 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Issue and Controversies in American History Dawes Act Americans believed in 1840, that they had to move westward; although the land was taken by the Native Americans. The Dawes Act, was a way to end the conflict between white settlers and the Indians; by giving the Indians and settlers their own plots of land. After the American Revolution white settlers continued to come to the New World, taking more from the natives for ranches, railroads, mining interest, as well as their own needs, causing the natives to have to move farther west. The government sought out to resolve the issue by giving the Indians large pieces of lands called reservations. Whites weren’t allowed to trespass on the land.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Native Americans

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The loss of people cleared more land for the colonists thus expanding the European dominance over the New World. Boundaries were set to let the Natives keep some of the land; however, they were not enforced (Hirschfelder 9). In the early nineteenth century, things began to change (Hirschfelder 9). Tecumseh, a Shawnee leader encouraged all native tribes to band together and refuse to give up any more land. In the early-mid 1800s, the United States Indian office began to physically remove Natives from their land and force them to assimilate them into white culture.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They were brave and listened to the government, but they still lost their tribal land. During the 1830's the East coast was burdened with new settlers and becoming vastly populated. President Andrew Jackson and the government had to find a way to move people to the West to make room. He passed the Indian Removal Policy in1830. The Indian Removal Policy, which called for the removal of Native Americans from the Tennessee, North Carolina, South Carolina, and the Georgia area.…

    • 2132 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The act was named after Henry Laurens Dawes, a senator in Massachusetts. Dawes objective was to bring the Native Americans out of poverty and to assimlate Natives into mainstream American society( an effort made by the United States to get rid of the Native American culture and turn it into European-American culture). Dawes was just another policy or act to encourage the " civillizing" process". The issue was that when new settlers moved into the nearby borders of the Natives territories they fought for resources and worked differently since different cultural beliefs. The Dawes act was to be " advatageous for agricultural and grazing purposes,"(Henry Dawes).This was another way to remove the Indian for their homes and turn that into something the U.S. could handle and control.…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Indians became deprived of hunting lands, decimated by disease, increasingly dependent on the white economy for the trade good and annuity payments in exchange for land cessions, many Indian peoples despaired. December 2, 1823 the president presented the Monroe Doctrine to Congress and the World. He ended the colonization of the Western Hemisphere by European Nations. United States considered the New World nations a danger to itself. Monroe then said that the United States would not interfere in any affairs of European countries or the New world colonies.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays