The Moral Argument Of Michael Huemer

Improved Essays
Huemer’s Moral Argument

Michael Huemer argues in favor of legalizing recreational drug use by addressing three major concerns that are commonly used to argue in favor of drug criminalization:

(1) Drug users may harm themselves
(2) Drug users may harm others
(3) Drug use may make people less productive and less altruistic

In order to address the first two concerns, Huemer posits that there exist countless legal behaviors that result in self-harm and harm to others. These behaviors include “smoking tobacco, drinking alcohol [....] [and being] an inattentive and inconsiderate spouse and parent” (PPE 584-6). If it is not the role of the government to restrict these activities, then it should not be the responsibility of the government to prohibit
…show more content…
Recall Huemer’s earlier argument: while drugs only possibly result in harm to others, there are several legal ways in which one can actually harm others; therefore, drugs should not be prohibited.

This argument conflicts with another claim of Huemer’s. He concedes that it is the business of the state to prohibit driving under the influence of drugs. But, like drug use, driving under the influence only introduces the possibility of harm to others. At least in some cases, Huemer evidently believes that the government should regulate risky behavior, even if there may not be negative consequences.

Additionally, Huemer largely overlooks the issue of addiction. He briefly addresses the argument that drug users may not have full autonomy over their decisions. If this is true, according to Huemer, then drugs should legal: “It is unjust to punish a person for something he is not responsible for” (PPE 588).

While this reasoning is valid, Huemer does not address the claim that the government should protect the autonomy of its citizens. Making the empirical assumption that drugs inhibit users’ ability to control themselves, prohibitionists might argue that the government is obligated to restrict the use of drugs—or at least addictive ones—in the interest of preserving

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    One of the hottest topics that has been widely discussed lately is the “drug war”. A regular columnist and professor of economics at Samford University, Art Carden argues in his article Forbes, “Let’s Be Blunt: It’s Time to End the Drug War” for the end of the drug prohibition. The purpose of the article is to persuade the readers that the war on drugs has been a costly failure, causing unintended negative economic consequences. Overall, Carden’s argument is convincing because he offers a strong, clear thesis with persuasive logical evidences as supports.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wilson And Husak Essay

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Drugs are widely used around the world and continues to be a huge issue. Many philosophers debate on the effects of making drugs legal. Some say that the forbidden fruit effect helps reduce the urge of doing drugs; however, Wilson believes that an increase of supply at a lower price will increase the amount of people taking these drugs. In addition, many argue that if drugs are not allowed then alcohol should be prohibited as well. This brings up many questions and the philosophers seem to have a few answers.…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The issue should not be looked at was whether or not to decriminalize the users of drugs, but rather the default question should be whether to criminalize the users of drugs. Husak argues that there is not a single argument that is good enough to justify criminalization. He explains that most drugs have a genuine use, for the majority this use is to experience a state of intoxication or high. Husak believes no one should be punished for wanting that state of intoxication or high.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gore Vidal Drugs Analysis

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The issue of legalizing drugs has been debated even longer. Gore Vidal wrote his article “Drugs: Case for Legalizing Marijuana” in The New York Times in 1970, a full 17 years before the aforementioned commercial hit the television airwaves. Vidal’s piece was ahead of its time, but still relevant today. Gore makes the case for dealing with America’s drug addiction problems by simply legalizing the drugs. In the article we are made aware of Vidal’s views that legal drugs could stop addiction, why he thinks it would work, and the prospects…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Huemer's Argument Analysis

    • 2010 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In his paper “America’s Unjust Drug War” Michael Huemer presents an argument for the drug war called the Harm to Users argument that is laid out as such: (P1) Drug use is very harmful to users. (P2) The government should prohibit people from doing things that harm themselves. ( C )…

    • 2010 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Drugs In The 1970's

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In exchange of the shaming and oppressive nature of our current drug policies, I advocate for a system which encourages the user to receive appropriate rehabilitation. Approaching the use of drugs through both a temperance and disease view, I believe reallocating funds into programs which approaches drug abuse as a curable disease, not simply a moral wrong. The temperance view of drugs recognizes drugs as addictive substances which are hazards to the public and thus focuses on targeting the root of addiction, such as drug dealers and smugglers (Fraser, Moore, & Keane, 2014). The disease concept understands drug abuse as a treatable disease which neither the user nor the supplier is responsible for; thus, supporters of the disease concept’s understanding of drug abuse, such as President Clinton, advocates for drug treatment and rehabilitation (Fraser et al., 2014). Thus, on these principles, I believe we can combat drug use in a more just and impactful way.…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Power Of 420 Analysis

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The United States government has been campaigning on the prohibition of drugs for nearly a century. President Richard Nixon declared the “War on Drugs” in the 1970s. It was evident his administration wanted to shift the public perception of drugs by demonizing all drugs and campaigning on the dangers of drug use, which later lead to major anti-drug bills during the 19080s and 1990s. For years, our society has been taught that drugs have negative consequences that causes drug users to commit crimes. As a result of the stigmatization of drugs, we are faced with the challenges of changing the mindset that drug addicts are not criminals, but instead their addiction is a disease that requires medical attention, not criminalization.…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Satire On Drugs

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Drug laws play a vital role in American society because drug use is an unfortunate part of the culture. Regardless of one’s views on whether some currently illegal drugs should be treated differently than others, the fact is that at this point all non-prescription drugs are illegal, and the government is responsible for responding to public outcry on this issue whether it be the legalization of recreational drugs like marijuana or the perceived injustices handed down to non-violent drug offenders. The serious nature of our country’s drug epidemic makes the topic of drug laws one that must be addressed by all branches of the US Government; the President is calling for legalization of recreational marijuana, congress is passing groundbreaking…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What should be allowed in America? Drugs have become very big items these days, either being used for medical reasons or just for fun, they are extremely common. As known, most drugs are illegal; however, people have connections to others to be able to get these illegal drugs to play around with and get high off of. Although, individuals with diseases or illnesses may benefit from illegal drugs to counteract the effects of their sickness, so the questions then comes up- should drug sales and usage be legalized? In the article “Drug Policy and the Intellectuals” by William J. Bennett, he plays off both sides whether or not drugs should be legalized.…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In ‘Licensing Parents’, Hugh LaFollette argues for parents to be licensed before being granted children. LaFollette’s argument can be outlined in the form of modus ponens that is: P1. Some activities need to be regulated as they cause harm. P2. Parenting can cause harm.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    All drugs are classified as a chemical solution that affects the process of mind and/or body. Barkman describes the clear headedness principle as, “Clouding our mind with crazy hallucinations,... [and] actually doing harm to us psychologically since the mind naturally functions best without such diversions” (Barkman 2-3). Barkman’s argument reflects that our mind needs its own time to think and make a decision. Decisions made by a person whose mind is influenced by other substances should be considered unfair, and impaired.…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Closely regulating the use of some drugs would likely prevent many lives from being destroyed due to using…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    V. For years drugs have been categorized as a poor personal decision, if the addiction persists then it is only because the person the person chooses to. But it’s just the brain defect - An addict should be able to make the decision to quit just as they made the decision to start taking the drugs. - Since a person chooses not to quit then the consequence of jail is deserved. Jail, Drug Court, or Rehab is the three most likely options. VI.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The argument on whether drugs should be legalized has been going on for so long now. Some people say as an Americans we have the right to choose whether we want to do drugs or not. It is really hard to control the consumption of drugs, because people are going to do them whether they are legal or illegal. Other people say that the laws that are being enforced now are good to control drugs. “There will also be more unpublicized fatal and maiming crashes, more job accidents, more child neglect, more of everything associated with substance abuse”(M. Kendrecke).…

    • 1002 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The drug market is stronger than ever, yet the drug war has been in full force for several decades. The effects here in the United States, are quite similar to the effects internationally, but there are many solutions other than a drug war, to stop the use of drugs. Nobel laureate and economist Milton Friedman remarked on the issue, “However much harm drugs do to those who use them…seeking to prohibit their use does even more harm both to users of drugs and to the rest of us…Legalizing drugs would simultaneously reduce the amount of crime and improve law enforcement. It is hard to conceive of any other single measure that would accomplish so much to promote law and order” (Donohue 146). Friedman is right.…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays