Disability In The Classroom

Improved Essays
Disability has always existed throughout history; it has never changed. What has changed are the names people used to describe and label it. Dr. F. M. Powell is the superintendent for the Iowa Institution for Feeble-Minded Children. “Backward and Mentally Deficient Children” was written for educators who have “mentally deficient” children in their classroom. In this piece, he focuses primarily on what should be done for the “backward and mentally deficient children” (or what people in modern times would call autistic children) and provides some insight on how the children who were deemed mentally deficient was treated.
Historically, impairment is seen as something devastating if it happened, especially to a child. “…feel the blighting touch of accident or disease…burdening them with the life-long grief of a visitation worse than and more dreaded than even death itself” (Powell, 1896, p. 16-17). Although it is not as extreme, this viewpoint is the basis for the medical model of disability and cure culture. Because disability is seen as a “failing that tragically ‘handicaps’ those ‘afflicted’”
…show more content…
For example, the moral imbecile is seen as someone who is born with “an inverted perversion of the sense of right and wrong” (Powell, 1896, p. 21). Powell believes that some people are inherently born with impaired morals instead of these morals being taught by the child’s families and teachers. This is a change from his original opinion in which the child is born as a blank slate with their environment influencing them which means that the moral imbecile is born abnormal. Another category of children who was put into the feeble-minded category were the epileptic. Along with the moral imbecile, Powell thought that the best way to care for these children were to isolate them from society and detain them in a special institution (moral imbeciles) or in a special colony (epileptic) (Powell,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Argument Analysis of “Defining Mental Disability” Defining mental disability is not, under any circumstances, an easy task. One wants to be politically correct, but without actually going through life every day with a disability, how can one even start to define it? One cannot.…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During this era, disabled people were known as anyone who essentially did not look like an ideal normal white person. The author describes the terms of these laws as, “those labeled insane, idiotic, feebleminded, epileptic, and otherwise “defective” (Welke, 79). The author continues on to describe how labeled disabled people were to be institutionalized, and treated without the right to citizenship and…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Back in the 1930s, society grouped and showed prejudice against those who weren’t the “perfects” that society visualized. Everyone with defects, disabilities, etc. were put underneath one label that expressed society’s feelings about them. Laura Hillenbrand, the author, used several very strongly connotated words to describe a majority of the nation’s view and attitude towards these people such as “undesirable”. The disabled or “feeble-minded” were seen as keeping the nation back from achieving its full potential. This was several decades ago, and many of us say and many hear politicians say that “we have come a long way since then”.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    In The Strange Case of Anna Stubblefield, Daniel Engber describes the story of a mentally disabled man being taken advantage of by his teacher. This case went before a jury and Anna Stubblefield was convicted of sexual assault on D.J, the mentally disabled man, as he had no way of giving his consent (Engber 26). This abuse was caused by the improper care of D.J. As he was thought of someone different from the rest of society, he was ignored, which later caused him to be sexually assaulted. Society almost tries to ignore the existence of those who are disabled as they are thought to be less than them. This isolation from society causes them to receive improper treatment and care.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lanier mentions that since her daughter’s diagnosis she has heard a cultural voice saying that her daughter was flawed, imperfect, and in need of fixing. She says that she sees when people describe a child’s features as birth defects and in our language how words that were once used in the same context as “intellectually impaired”, like moron and retarded, became insults. She hears it when people say that people with disabilities shouldn’t have children and can ethically be killed as babies. She says she saw it when Donald Trump when running for the office of the President made fun of a disabled reporter. The message she hears is that the disabled body is less than.…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fairman maintains, “Invariably, negative connotations materialize around what ever new word is used.” He debates how the “r” word was originally used to take place of the insulting word idiot, yet still the word retarded has been turned into a negative insulting word. Then the phrase “intellectual disability” became the new official diagnosis. In 2010 the family of Rosa Marcellino a little girl with Downs Syndrome helped to pass “Rosas Law… mandated that “intellectual disability” replace “mental retardation” in many areas of federal government” (Hallahan 86). When Fairman remarks, “Idiot becomes an insult and gives way to retardation, which in turn suffers the same fate, leading to intellectual disability” he plummets back down the slope.…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most callous attributes of the American society over the past two centuries would be the mistreatment and judgment of “freaks” or people with disabilities. While this cruel treatment and hatred for disabled people has almost entirely vanished, it used to be a very common social norm as these freaks were treated as second-class citizens. Tod Browning’s notorious film “Freaks” accurately depicted these common ideologies of the early twentieth century, in addition to provoking new thought as to how individuals were incorrectly and heartlessly classified through class and disabilities. The discrimination that was present in the early 1900’s is contrasts greatly to the ideologies and equality that is present in today’s society. This concept was prevalent throughout American history up until this point in time, as “mental or physical abnormalities were commonly depicted as instances atavism, reversions to earlier stages of evolutionary development” (Bayton 36).…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People with disabilities have been discriminated, not only in the 1930s, but throughout the sum of time. Many people of the mentally ill community were taken advantage of and were the “test monkeys” for some inhumane treatments. From before, after and during the 1930s, they were thought of as a burden to society. In John Steinbeck’s Of Mice And Men, Lennie Small, one of the main characters, suffers from an intellectual disability. Although he is not the brightest, he is big and strong but does not realize his own strength.…

    • 1636 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is a powerful assertion that was argued using a combination of anecdotes and historical contexts. Susan Wendell describes three components to help articulate her argument. She first describes social factors that construct disability. This includes social conditions like war, availability of resources, pace of life, inaccessibility, and culture. Then she described the social deconstruction of disability where she expands how disability is socially constructed by social condition that cause, fail to prevent damage to people’s bodies.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Liberty can be defined as governmental, protected freedom of discrimination from both society and the government. Based off the support of many powerful politicians, the number of acts passed over several years, and the various programs created by the government, people with disabilities primarily gained liberty through governmental assistance beginning in the 1930’s. Throughout the 1900’s people with disabilities were viewed by society as feebleminded, useless, tragic, evil, and as defective human beings. They were discriminated in many areas such as education, employment, public transportation, voting, and availability of treatment or rehabilitation.…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With “Defining Mental Disability”, Margaret Price explores the complications with bringing order to the titles and beliefs used to define the realm of disabilities considered mental. For one, there is the issue of what terms are appropriate to label mental disorders. Price points out the trouble that comes from singularly identifying a very diverse group of conditions, as well as the differences in connotations found from region to region (298-299). Then there is the problem of how to perceive mental ailments. Are they something to cure, or are they a natural extension of a person that should not be seen as an enfreakment of sorts?…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When people see kids as disabled or below the average child they are automatically labeled and put off to the side because they do not have the same abilities as everyone else. In her essay “Cognitive Outlaws”, Joann Ellison Rodgers claims that children with dyslexia or other learning disabilities are not handicap and that is not how they should be defined by their mental disability but by how they perform in the classroom. She claims that the brightest minds in the world have all had some sort of learning disability. Einstein and Edison failed basic schooling and were diagnosed with Dyscalculia. In the essay “Autism and Visual Thought” Temple Grandin writes of her experience with Autism and how she thinks in pictures and not words and had to…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though the treatment of people with disabilities was far form ideal during the early American period, it declined even further during the “progressive” era. The community aspect of caring for each other seems to have been completely lost, and attempts to find a place for individuals incapable of performing traditional labor diminished. Rapid industrialization continued to cause more and more disabilities, and the quality of life of those affected by them became even worse than before. Disabilities during this time were viewed as undesirable defects, and those who had them were ostracized and looked down upon. This era gave birth to the notion of eugenics, which claimed that a “perfect” society could hypothetically be achieved trough breeding out undesirable traits that did not align with their notion of the ideal citizen.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disabilities are an aspect of life that has become increasingly significant throughout history. Being that it is so prevalent, it is almost definite that everyone on this planet knows at least one person with some sort of disability, whether it is himself or herself or someone they know. The book titled “Of Mice and Men,” written by John Steinbeck represents many of disabilities seen in society today. From physical disabilities to mental disabilities, this book shows how those with disabilities were treated during the 1930s. The two main characters of this short novel are George and Lennie.…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Ableism

    • 1865 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Overtime, we have seen a dramatic shift in the way our society addresses individuals with these types of impairments. Previously, people with disabilities were viewed as being inadequate or incapable or achieving certain statuses (Adams, etl. 2013, pg. 297). They were often disregarded and slighted by other…

    • 1865 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays