Macdonald And Elbow's Reading And Thought By Dwight Macdonald

Improved Essays
Essay 1

Writing essays to some is a simple assignment of writing down ideas, to others it could be a long process of analyzing, organizing, and writing which could be overwhelming. Readers who spend more time reading and analyzing an article will have an easier framing their thoughts and drawing better conclusions of the text. In his article “ Reading and Thought” Dwight Macdonald, He sends the message that most people now don 't spend enough time analyzing their reading. People aren 't taking the time to stop and think about what they 're reading before expressing their opinions. Most people miss out on the opportunity to be well informed and make compact decisions based on the little information they could retrieve . Macdonald contradicts
…show more content…
Thought is an idea or proposition conducted by thinking or occurring quickly in the mind. Macdonald reminds the reader that one 's thoughts aren 't gained by a simple skim of a text you have scavenge your way through the text to find the main ideas and detail so you could get the right ideas. Then you can write down all your thought that way you avoid confusion and have an organized essay. The way Elbow uses thought is by explaining it as a process of gathering information you don 't need structure all you need is the ideas of what you want to write about. Thought is the important thing or else you wouldn 't get ideas running in your …show more content…
As you are purposely avoiding all the minor but, instructive detail that you didn’t notice in your first reading attempt. Going back and analyzing doesn 't just make the writing process more organized,but it also keeps you on track with what the main idea is. If you go back and look at the article you would find key information that could help you build ideas. The thoughts I get after reading are direct thoughts usually are my opinion pinion on the subject. If I decide to write down everything I was thinking off I wouldn’t realize they don 't match the ideas of the essay which is something Elbow emphasizes and not a very cleaver idea. Taking the time to analyse the readings is very helpful when writing because it helps you not only stick to the prompt, but gain fluent ideas as you write so everything is well organized throughout the description of the essay. As Elbows method requires lots of problem solving within your brain, which to me is too much to ask for as it makes the writing process much more difficult. I would say most people just like me tend to avoid that ,and rather stay on a clear and more simple path that allows them to more sufficiently, write an

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Throughout these sections, Hacker and Sommers explain how to construct a successful piece of writing and help demonstrate the writing process. In this book, Hacker and Sommers first focus on the planning aspect needed before writing an essay in order…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being a first-year college student, you are introduced to the idea of critical thinking early in order to gain intellectual knowledge for creating your own structure of writing. Not only is critical thinking an essential learning process, a student’s ability to understand a comparison of sources is especially imperative for a college education due to a variety of reasons. A rhetorical analysis not only explores the content of a given source, but it also refers to what the author is trying to portray to his or her audience. Learning about the skills of rhetorical analysis teaches you how to apply these comparisons and differentiate between types of writing such as a popular or scientific article. For instance, breaking down the context of a…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How Wolves Change Rivers

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When assigned to read a source and write a follow up paper, often times a student will only do the bare minimum that is required of them and just skim the text. However, this is a practice that is ultimately harmful for the learner, as when one does not dig beneath the surface level of a piece of work, they can not accurately analyze or garner the author’s true purpose and intent for writing. Instead, author Mike Bunn challenges college students to “read like a writer” (Bunn 2011), and focus more on how effective the work is and whether or not the author achieved their purpose. By following this practice, a student is able to produce greater works of their own, as they will learn from the style and structure of others. Therefore, when dealing…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When comparing two different pieces of writing, it is important to assess the differences between the pieces’ tones and purposes. Essays that have similar themes can be misinterpreted as similar even though the purpose and tone of the two papers are quite different. The essays “Learning to Read” by Malcolm X and “Learning to Read and Write” by Frederick Douglass appear to be very similar. However, the two pieces have very distinct tones that are generated by each author’s purpose. The tone of Malcolm X’s piece is very serious and stern due to the fact that his purpose is to inform and persuade his audience to act for their civil rights.…

    • 1668 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Writing essays to some it 's a simple assignment of writing down ideas to others it could be A long process of analyzing, organizing, and writing which could be overwhelming. Readers who spend more time reading and analyzing an article will make it easier to reframe their thoughts and draw better ideas of the text. In the article “ Reading and Thought” by Dwight Macdonald sends the message that most people now don 't spend enough time reading. People aren 't taking the time to stop and think about what they 're reading before expressing their opinions. As most people miss out on the opportunity to be well informed and make tight decisions based on the information they could retrieve.…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Entering a Conversation While writing there is a lot of pressure to be able to create a perfect piece of writing. This tends to create an unreasonable type of pressure on the writer. Writers tend to overthink their work which leads to a block being created. When approaching writing many of use take different routes, but more often than not we stress ourselves out trying to create perfect drafts. In “The Inspired Writer Vs.…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The argument employed in Reading and Thought by Dwight MacDonald is an attack on the new culture of writing embedded into Time magazine. MacDonald goes on to describe the writing to be largely “massed” with many topics, however, these topics simply serve as an outlet to fulfill your curiosity with no other true function. He also goes on to state that the majority of the writing is useless because it does not cause action to be stirred up in a reader to cause them to “make more money, take some political or other action to advance his interests, or become a better person.” MacDonald in return goes on to even proclaim that this new form of writing has developed our thought and minds to be “rapid, purely rational, classifying habit of mind, something…

    • 1319 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During this summer session of ENGL101A, I have learned multiple ways to express myself through my writing. In fact, before signing up for this class, I did not know the proper way to compose an academic essay for a particular audience, and how to properly cite my sources. Nevertheless, after the short summer session, I am able to define my purpose and audience, analyze critically any piece of information, and write with proper citations and fewer grammatical errors with confidence. Through the short time of 5 weeks, I learned how to focus on my audience as well as how to define the purpose of my papers as academically as possible.…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    After doing that draft, I would rewrite it, so it can have all the correct format and grammars. In all the essay that I have written like Words Are Powerful and American Society’s Version of Beauty, I have been able to use that tactic in order to get my thoughts on the readings. It provided me with enough information to write my ideas into proper…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    you analyze, organize and then fix it later on. This method has helped me with my second. i felt like the essay was easy due to the fact that i’ve used that…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    EOF Student Reflection

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages

    I was able to overcome my fear of essays with the techniques like close reading and asking myself critical thinking questions. Beginning with the first essay assigned in college…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Since our first attempt at writing an essay in elementary to middle school, we are told the main components to writing an essay is the ‘beginning’, ‘middle’, and ‘end.’ All of which holds true today, but as we move from one grade to the next, the standards for a ‘good’ essay changes for the better. Rhetorical strategies, devices, and appeals also known as rhetoric, is what we learn in high school (Stotsky 10). The continuation of the expanding knowledge is what makes us alter our writing strategies, from the material taught to us in our adolescent years of elementary school and every year thereafter. It is in high school that we are taught to analyze and dissect the author, as well as the author’s work ceaselessly.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Shivam 1 Shivam Gupta Professor Keith MacDonald Composition 1 20 October 2017 Read Like a Writer In Mike Bunn’s “How to Read Like a Writer” he explains how one can become a better reader simply by trying to understand the article from the point of view of the writer, by analyzing every word, sentence or paragraph with one question in mind, "what effect did the writer intend to have with these words?". I believe it is important for us to have this skill because it gives us a better insight into what we are reading, it helps us understand on a deeper level exactly what the article is trying to tell us and in response, this teaches us better techniques and skills to become better writers. Using guidelines set by Bunn in his article, I will illustrate…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his essay “Thought,” Louis H. Sullivan greatly stresses the importance of thinking critically and creatively, and presents the argument that one must think not in words but rather in images, rhythm, and other wordless forms of communication. Sullivan resorts heavily on comparisons and analogies and metaphors to convey the impractical usage of words. “But in passing I may say that real thinking is better done without words than with them, and creative thinking must be done without words,” Sullivan argues, and he goes on to explain the intellectual heft and rigor of thinking creatively and highlights its rewards. Sullivan also asserts that one must think in the present and the present alone, for his reasoning is that “you cannot in the past,…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many writings which can be taken two different ways. Either it can persuade the reader to his or her opinion or turn them away. The strategies used in an essay can have an effect on the reader. In the essay “School Is Bad For Children”, written by John Holt, a valid argument is made that school takes away almost every child’s individuality. The children apparently do not get the chance to express themselves or show their skills.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays