The Lying Detective And The Dying Detective

Compare and Contrast Essay Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s “The Dying Detective”, as well as Josh Pachter’s “Invitation to a Murder” both feature the tales of two riveting mysteries. Although they were two different stories, several ideas existed in each that ran parallel in relation to one another. These consistencies include the presence of premeditated actions from the characters, evidence of situational irony, and the indication of a foul play mystery. Conversely, a collection of concepts support the notion that the two stories were unlike each other in major ways. “The Dying Detective” had an unswervingly loyal character and a cunning one too. Furthermore, it possessed a mood that was primarily mournful. “Invitation to a Murder”, on the other …show more content…
Firstly, “Invitation to a Murder” occurred inside a room with limited entrances, supporting the statement it was a locked room mystery. Its counterpart, “The Dying Detective” was not the same, due to its ability for characters to enter and leave the room freely. Moreover, Pachter’s story included a murder that was committed out of love, for Mrs. Abbott wished to murder her husband solely to relieve him from the misery that he had been engulfed with for an entire year. Doyle’s mystery, on the other hand, involved a murder, as well as an attempted murder, that was committed out of Culverton Smith’s hate for his cousin, Victor Savage, and Sherlock Holmes. Finally, “Invitation to a Murder” differed from “The Dying Detective” since Mrs. Abbott physically used no weapon to kill Mr. Abbott, whereas Smith had utilized a poisoned spring within a box in his schemes. However, “The Dying Detective” had its own exclusive concepts that did not exist in “Invitation to a Murder.” The initial mood of this story was sorrowful, as Dr. Watson and Mrs. Hudson believed Holmes was on the brink of death. In opposition, Mrs. Abbott’s glee as to killing her husband created a rather happy mood for that tale. Furthermore, to please his dear friend, the loyal Dr. Watson obeyed each of Holmes’ instructions, despite their eccentric qualities. The twelve law enforcers did not act quite the same, as they attempted to prevent Mrs. Abbott’s murder, regardless of her desires. Lastly, the murderer in “The Dying Detective”, Culverton Smith, was extremely sly as to how he went about his killing. Cunningly, Smith placed an infected spring within a box to send to his enemies; astonishingly, he would have escaped without punishment had Sherlock Holmes not captured him. Mrs. Abbott, though, invited twelve police officers and detectives to view her own murder in plain sight! Therefore, “The Dying Detective” and