Lloyd George And Collins Case Study

Improved Essays
Prior to treaty negotiations, Lloyd George and Collins effected one another’s actions because they were on opposing sides during the Anglo-Irish War where the IRB challenged the British presence in Ireland. After Sinn Fein candidates, Collins included, won seats in Parliament across Ireland, they refused to take their seats and instead formed their own parliament called Dail Earnnian. Lloyd George’s response to Sinn Fein’s establishment of an illegal parliament was not to try and forcefully coerce them back into the empire because he had gone into the Paris Peace Conference as a champion of oppressed minorities and as an advocate of small countries, and any act of forceful coercion would actively contradict this. Lloyd George’s hoped that …show more content…
As leader of the IRB, Collins developed this system because he knew that the Irish could not fight the British conventionally like the leaders of the Easter Rising had tried to do, and that guerilla warfare was the only chance they had at ever winning. As the attacks continued, Lloyd George changed his opinion about using force saying, “that the disorder must be put down at whatever cost”. Lloyd George and his government decided to create a police force of ex-servicemen, the Black and Tans and Auxiliaries, to combat the IRA, which only created more violence as the new police force used any means necessary to try and defeat the IRA, including killing innocent civilians. The conflict between Collin’s IRA and Lloyd George’s ex-soldier divisions of the RIC came to a head on the morning of 19 November 1920 when fourteen British officers were shot in their beds by agents of the IRA . In retaliation, the Auxiliary division of the RIC opened fire on a Gaelic football match which killed twelve …show more content…
Lloyd George’s initial opinion was that debate should center on Ireland remaining in the Empire and it’s loyalty to the Crown, but his cabinet approved of having unconditional debates with the Irish. This meant that the Irish were not limited to debating loyalty to the crown and status in the Empire, but that they could discuss anything that they felt need to be addressed. Therefore, the British delegation gave the Irish delegation more leeway than Lloyd George wanted and on 8 October 1921 when the Irish delegation arrived in London, noticeably without De Valera, they had a great chance to finally get some separation from Britain. Collins’ initial thoughts going into negotiations was that both delegations were equal and that the Irish could get something close to what they wanted. He also had a rough idea about Lloyd George from an informant who he had sent to do reports on the British delegates, who described Lloyd George as having “a charm that wins people” and as being “skilled in political strategy”. As the debates progressed, Collins realized that the British were far superior to the Irish delegation, and that the best that the Irish delegation could hope to get was dominion status . The reason for this change was that Lloyd George had assembled one of the greatest negotiating teams with men like

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    (Laura Leddy Turner, Demand Media) With England governing over Ireland, legislation was passed to limit the rights of the Irish. The Irish were limited from holding government office, purchasing real estate, getting an education, and…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chapter 1: Introduction 1.1 General Background (Framework): The Irish Republican Army, or IRA, fought the English rule over Northern Ireland in the twentieth century and aimed to unite Northern Ireland with Southern Ireland to form the Republic Ireland. It stemmed from the times of William of Orange in 1690, where William’s Protestant Army defeated Catholic King James II in the Battle of the Boyne[1]. In the years leading up to 1703, thousands of Catholics were deported and relocated to live in new areas. English Protestants seized land and owned 90% of the land in Ireland in 1703, which the Catholic peasants had to pay rent for.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The United States had won independence from Great Britain in the Revolutionary War with the U.S. government being the Articles of Confederation. The Articles of Confederation failed in not being able to stabilize the Federal Government after the war and a new government was drawn up by the United States’ best and brightest. This new governing document is the Constitution of the United States, the Constitution created a new form of government in which to stabilize the government, economy, culture, and social aspects of the United States. The Presidents of this new Republic were the driving force in which stabilization or instability were to be created. George Washington strongly helped to stabilize the United States government with few instabilities…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Postbellum United States required great attention to both its creation, rejuvenation, and restoration as a stable nation. In the book, Founding Brothers, Joseph Ellis presented readers with an insight into some of the more problematic portions of the creation of this nation. Some issues within the border of the Union, namely those surrounding the national debt and establishment of the capitol of the United States were addressed with urgency while slavery, another great problem that inevitably had to be assessed, was turned a blind eye to. A great divide between Northern and Southern states concerning deep rooted, political, economic, and social beliefs was ever present. Top officials who once came together to see this nation rise from the ashes began to adopt a state influenced point of view.…

    • 1321 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The initial British strategy was the “annihilation by strategic offensive” to break the power of the minority with military operations, divide the political unity, blockade economic trade with ships and ultimately force the loyalists to reinforce their allegiance to the crown. (Crapenter, lecture) The thought process behind this strategy was to treat it as a typical rebellion and end it by brutal force and force allegiance. The British did not understand the true nature of the war which revolved around constitutional independence, religious concepts and economic theory. It was not as simple as an unruly rebellion that they were used to.…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In addition to famishment, the Irish were also under the thumb of the British,…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Swift clearly states that he sympathizes with the Catholics in calling Ireland one of the “Roman Catholic countries” and by saying that one of the advantages of his plan would be “lessening the number of Papists”(633). Swift sympathising with the Catholics is significant because if he had not sympathised with them, he would not have written “A Modest Proposal” in opposition to the cruel laws imposed by the English. Swift did not write this because he particularly liked the Irish, but because he despised the inhumanity of the English. Swift’s unique view of the situation explains why he uses his satire not only to criticize the English but also the Irish.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ultimately, Washington chose the path of negotiation. Convinced that America would not be ready to confront Britain militarily for at least “twenty years,” Washington believed the wisest path was to buy time through peaceful mediation. Signed in 1794, Jay’s Treaty took its name from America’s chief negotiator in London, John Jay.…

    • 51 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To the Irish this period in the island’s history is seen as the iconic moment of English rule on the island. Cromwell ravaged the country in search of power. It did not matter who got killed or what they had done. In the strict sense Cromwell can therefore not be accused of ethnic cleansing.…

    • 1908 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I will talk about terrorism in the United Kingdom from 1969–1998. We will focus on an Irish republican paramilitary organization that called themselves the Irish Republican Army. The IRA sought to liberate Northern Ireland from the UK and to join with the Irish republic. They carried out many bombings during a period colloquially known as the Troubles. Their prime target was members of the British Army and officers of the Irish national police force.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Real Irish Republican Army, or Real IRA, is a terrorist organization in Northern Ireland conducting an armed campaign to reunite the island of Ireland under an Irish Republic. The Real IRA has conducted some of the most sensational attacks of the conflict in Northern Ireland, including the Omagh bombing in 1998 and a rocket propelled grenade attack on the MI-5 headquarters in England. The Real IRA has also been at the forefront of improvised explosive device technology; utilizing bombs with infrared triggers, explosives with mercury tilt switches, and explosively formed projectiles influencing the use of these devices around the world. Through the prolonged conflict and the experience of recruited former members of the Provisional Irish Republican Army, the Real IRA still poses numerous challenges for security forces today and has shown itself to be a resilient organization able to bounce back from constant security force operations against it.…

    • 9418 Words
    • 38 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The problem in my eyes is that since the British were ‘in charge’ they were the Judges. The Irish were not allowed to be Judges or anything that required public office. If the Irish were sent to court, they would not have a say because, the British would not understand their struggles. In my opinion, a mixed Irish and British Jury of their piers would solve a lot of their problems. Some sentences were also very unfair, and mostly made by the British.…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A phrase frequently tossed around in the United States is “Hindsight is twenty-twenty”. We can’t be sure of how this phrase materialized, especially with the war of British and Americans being an explicit contradiction. There are a plethora of factors that justify the extensive clashing dialogues concerning the motivations of British defeat. Great British minds alike presented equally convincing arguments that condemned and combated that of their peers.…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lars Banks: Society’s Putrescence Banks household, night after arson on the gym. Lars sits on the balcony, watching over the streets of Belfast. How many times must it be that I have witnessed this futile recklessness of today’s juveniles? These acts of blatant attention seeking behaviour have become too many, the increased security imposed by the IRA does not do anything to benefit this current situation. The complete demolition that Liam had dragged me along to was not in the least bit beneficial to our fellow comrades of Belfast.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Amid the late seventeenth century, political flyers were dispersed all through Ireland to advance the thoughts of different savvy people and laymen. Nonetheless, numerous tossed them and did not pay consideration on them. Jonathan Swift, creator of “ A Modest Proposal,” exploits the disregarded flyers, and builds a ludicrous proposal. He does this to show how reverse and terrible the condition of Ireland is and the social classes. Swift suggests that the infants of all poor people and destroy will "add to the bolstering, and halfway to the dress, of numerous thousands" to enhance Ireland 's economy and way of life.…

    • 1519 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays