In this essay “The Singer Solution to World Poverty” Peter Singer is trying to persuade the society that the world hunger and poverty will be solved if people from wealthy society donate the money that spend on their luxuries to the aid organization. He gives two controversies examples of Dora’s situation and Bob’s situation which help to strengthen his argument. From that examples it is also supports his arguments in favor of his altruistic position. On the other hand he also address the objections to his arguments which is “fair share” and “the limit of the donation.…
Devoted to Betrayal For centuries, literalist, such as Flannery O’Connor, have debated and shared their views on deception and betrayal. In the short story, “The Life You Save May Be Your Own,” O’Connor introduces two characters located in the south that form an unlikely alliance to gain an advantage over the other. The mother wants to gain a son- in- law to marry and care for her daughter, and make repairs on her farm. The shiftless drifter wants a car, which he believes represent success and freedom.…
The title of The Life You Save May Be Your Own is very important because it essentially explains the theme and overall meaning of the story. Shiftlet is given the perfect opportunity for absolution when he comes into Mrs. Crater and Lucynell’s lives. Unfortunately, Shiftlet does not see this as a chance for redemption and ends up being the same person he was before he ever met Mrs. Crater and Lucynell. He could have saved his own life, but he missed the chance and is still lost and…
Chenelle Seck Gina Santiago PHIL 101, Section 01 14 November 2014 Choice # 2 Peter Singer is a consequentialist and he states that people from Bengali are dying from circumstances that can be prevented by the decisions and actions of humans as a whole, but “unfortunately, human beings have not made the necessary decisions” (pg.229). According to Singer, if we can prevent something bad from happening, “without sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, morally we should do it” (pg.231). The same goes for things we can prevent “without sacrificing anything morally significant” (pg.231). In comparison with those who suffer from lack of food, shelter, and medical care worldwide, Singer uses an example that involves you seeing a child…
It would be wrong to not help the other child in need no matter the distance.…
Mr. Shiftlet, the protagonist of, “The Life You Save”, exemplifies self-deception seeing his role in life is to be other’s savior. Yet, is invalid due to the religious symbolism O’Connor uses. Much of the symbolism used is God telling Shiftlet that he needs to find redemption. Shiftlet as a repairman illustrates how he views himself as someone who needs to fix others. As O’Connor narrates “He felt too that a man with a car had a responsibility to others and he kept his eye out for a hitch-hiker”.…
Isaac Slade, Joe King, Ben Wysocki, and Dave Welsh make up the popular rock/ pop band The Fray. With their first album, How to Save a Life, this band appeared on everyone’s radar. The Fray’s song “You Found Me” appeared on the band’s second album, The Fray. Eight months after the release of The Fray’s second album, the band released a music video for “You Found Me.” This song could have several meanings depending on different points of views.…
What Makes the World Go Round Professor of Bioethics, Peter Singer, explains in the article “The Singer Solution to World Poverty” that all prosperous people should give all money that is not needed for basic necessities to places that are in need of food and medicine. As an American, I have knowledge this argument would shake up America as a whole. This could create a world of giving up the Capitalistic ways of America and the economic food chain. On the other hand, it could create a world of kindness and less violence. Can you imagine giving up your freedom to help others?…
In life we are faced with a series of “big questions”. These questions answer whether we are decently moral people. The ‘big question” we are going to tackle is ‘are we under an obligation to save lives?’ If so, what is required of us to be a morally decent person? In “The Gift” by Parker we learn that Zell Kravinsky would take a utilitarian approach to this question.…
The era of hostile racial prejudice, the periods of slavery and racial segregation is an era that has extensively found itself in reluctant conversations across cultures, the effects continuing to radiate from the 19th century, the epicentre of racism. An uncomfortable truth to confront, race as a socio-political concept is a topic we refuse to divulge in or if done so, is a conversation peppered with scientific evidence that is nothing but discriminatory. Significant public figures have dismissed the presence of racial discrimination in the 21st century, the famous misnomer “America doesn’t have a race problem” equalised to Malcom X’s powerful legend, “You get your freedom by letting your enemy know that you'll do anything to get it.” Yet,…
As my Mathematics professor always says, “Helping one person might not change the whole world, but it could change the world for one person.” For some people who live in the third world countries such as Ethiopia and Sudan, even a few dollars or a cup of water is a great help. However, in today’s society, most people only care about themselves and forget to think of others in need. Less and less people are willing to help others. Moreover, some people once accepted help, but they forget that many are like them that need help.…
Many would agree that murder is the most morally atrocious and impermissible thing that an autonomous being can commit. As well, many would agree that there is a certain moral obligation that everyone should have to their fellow man, and hence feel some obligation to help prevent the suffering of a fellow man if the opportunity presents itself. However, how far does that obligation stretch? Does it go beyond the bounds of only being morally responsible for the circumstances that you can see in front of you? Or are people in a way just as much responsible for all the suffering throughout the world that we have the capability to help prevent; such as the suffering of the global poor.…
Do the Poor Deserve Life Support In today's world, we are often presented with situations or “economic considerations” that reflect the compassion people have. In the article, “Do the Poor Deserve Life Support?” written by Steven Landsburg, we are presented with the story where a poor woman was left unplugged from her ventilator due to insufficient funds. There is debate whether this incident was wrong which many would agree to.…
Peter Singer ultimately believes that we are morally obligated to help those who need help and are suffering. He provides various arguments that support his belief that everyone should help the dying people of East Bengal. He starts off by assuming one thing, “suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, and medical care are bad.” This assumption serves as a foundation for his many claims since it provides a definition for what he considers bad. Furthermore, his first claim is that we are morally obligated to stop bad things from happening only if we do not have to sacrifice something of equal value.…
Fair is defined as free from bias, dishonesty, and injustice. It may seem like such a simple concept, but to this day, we have trouble determining what is fair. Fairness is rewarding those who try and work hard towards their goals, while encouraging those who don’t to give more effort. This has proved to be a large conflict in our modern-day world, as balancing accolades and incentives is a hard judgment. Nevertheless, it remains that being fair is not giving everyone equal treatment, but rather holding them responsible for their own actions.…