The Pros And Cons Of Pro Slavery

Improved Essays
The argument about slavery was looked upon through two common sides, those who favored it and those who opposed it. It can be said that the South was in favor of slavery and some of the most prominent influencers who favored it found their own reasons to justify it such as, minister Richard Furman and writer George Fitzhugh. However, their justifiable reasons could not compare to the harsh reality that the slaves experienced firsthand. Through the shared experiences from Sally Thomas and other African American slaves it can be concluded that pro-slavery writers and supporters only looked to benefit themselves and had little consideration for the well-being of slaves.
In 1822, the leading Baptist minister, Richard Furman, from South Carolina,
…show more content…
He believed in the concept, “A southern farm is the beau ideal of Communism…” , in which the slave benefits more than the master. He relates an average farm in the South to the governmental control of Communism by saying that the slaves take pride in working for the master and elaborates all the benefits that slaves are able to experience while being enslaved such as they are able to marry when they want, they are always given protection and support from their masters, and when they die their family will be taken care of. He explains how easy of a life slaves are able to have and believes that slaves are “as happy as a human being can be.” He believed that slavery was highly beneficial for the economy and that it proved to be more dominant and stable than the economic development in the North. He believed that slaveholders were the least selfish of men because they spend their whole life providing for the minutest wants of others and took care of their slaves from sickness and in health. Due to the devotion of slaveholders to their slaves, Fitzhugh believed that slaves took a sense of pride towards their slaveholders and devoted their whole life working for them,

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Economic Motivations Georgia Georgia originally did not permit slavery. The colony was made to help poor white men and ex-cons. Eventually, Georgia was divided between preserving the original charter for the colony or keep up with other British colonies’ economies. Georgia then demanded slavery to be able to produce cotton, rice, and indigo on large plantations. Some colonists opposed slavery since slaves would replace poor workers and would have their land bought by plantation owners.…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    3. Taking a modern and moral stand, it could be implied that there were better ways of how to handle slavery but during that early stage of the country, it could have endangered the birth of the Constitution. However, had there been a chance, slaves could have been freed instead of being counted a three-fifths of a person. The plantation owners, which claimed to rely heavily on slavery, could have retained the labor without the enslavement of human being but could this have led to an earlier Civil War or could it have been prevented due to the fact that the states had to agree to…

    • 107 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The second chapter of March reveals the multiple distinctions between the Northern and the Southern perspectives on slavery, specifically those regarding education and punishment. As stated by Mr. Clements, “your Yankee pamphleteers have much to answer for. I’ll not have anyone on this place reading those foul, intemperate, slanderous rags!” (Brooks 32). When discussing the matter of education for slaves, Mr. Clements disregarded the Northern and rather optimistic ideals of Mr. March, who secretly hoped to educate Prudence.…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He made reference in his text to the cruelty of slavery as an institution, but also to how slavery pertained to politics, law, religion, and social life (). Having lived with several masters, mostly bad, he described the deplorable condition under which he and other slaves lived. His explanation of slaves singing to appear happy to appease their white masters was simply a false impression to whites; he believed this happy appearance was the only way a slave could truly protect himself. “Slaves sing most when they are unhappy. The sons of the slave represent the sorrows of his heart; he is relieved by them, only as an aching heart is relieved by its tears" ( ).…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indentured servants were individuals who sold themselves, as a form of labor for a or a certain amount of time. The indentures were often shoemakers, plumbers, clerks, weavers, painters, and all sorts of workers. This started in England, because they wanted more people to go into the new world and start colonies over there so they offered to pay for the trip, and if the indentured servants didn 't like staying over there, England would pay for their trip to come back as well. Most workers in England thought they could gain more money and live a better life in the new world than it England. They hoped to succeed in the new world and be better off than when they were I England, so many became indentured servants.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the early America when people started to come from the far east to settle for a better life, there were times that weren’t so great. One of the major negatives was slavery, also not many women had the right to their own person they were practically slaves to the men in my opinion. In the book, “An American History Give Me Liberty” by Eric Foner sites in chapter 3 called Creating Anglo-America 1660-1750 some of the important marks of that specific time period. Like in 1676 the Bacon’s Rebellion, which became known as the most intense conflicts of that time (83). There are many other events like Glorious Revolution in England in 1688 and the most abundant witch trials in 1692 (71).…

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although it was generally acknowledged that the practice of slavery was a peculiar institution, many southerns in favor of slavery felt justified in their beliefs due to the potentially positive ramifications of slavery. Many of the dominant nations throughout history, such as ancient Greece and Rome, had engaged in the practice of slavery. Southerners also tended to point out the hypocrisy of antislavery northerners by highlighting the inhumane conditions which factory workers were accustomed to. Those in favor of slavery often attempted to manipulate the text of the Bible in order to support their cause, and proclaimed slavery as their religious responsibility to evangelize the heathens. As the message of the pro slavery argument…

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The issue of slavery in the United States became paramount in the late nineteenth century. There were two clear sides in this debate, those pro-slavery and those anti-slavery. This division was quite geographical, pitting the South against the North. Regional differences between the North and the South led to fierce conflict, particularly over the issue of slavery. The Northern states were free states, against the idea of slavery.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the nineteenth century, white’s either supported the institution of slavery, or were strongly against it. Abolitionists were the people who who went against slavery and the way of life in the nineteenth century. However, apologist’s were in total support of the institution of slavery and used legal, religious and economic arguments to further their desire for slavery. African slavery began in North America in 1619, from there on slavery became a way of life, and apologist’s did not want their normal and believed necessary way of life to change. Supporters of slavery used legal arguments to keep the slaves, that they say, are their property.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. George Fitzhugh thought of slaves as children and that they need to be governed like children. He also looked at the masters like they were the parents. He explained his reasoning for his pro-slavery stance by making an analogy between the relationship of a parent and a child to that of a master and a slave. 2.…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1. The Colony of Massachusetts believes that citizens qualified to vote in elections for the state legislatures should elect members of the lower house. We believe that this proposition is the correct decision because it upholds what we fought for in the Revolutionary War. In The Declaration of Independence, created by our founding father, it states that all men are created equal.…

    • 1818 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The South was as secure in their conviction that slavery was a proper institution as the Minutemen who turned the British back at the Old North Bridge were in theirs. The insulation of the South allowed these convictions to thrive without serious opposition in local communities. With everyone thinking and therefore voting the same way it was easy to keep slavery alive for decades. Insomuch as they believed the proslavery position was unfounded in reality putting forward idealized and sometimes fantastical ideas of Southern society and slave holding. The slave’s perspective was very much real where even in the best position slaves still felt the fear of sale and control by whites.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    First and for most I think that Lincoln's conclusion of slavery being illegal is a wise one because if it was not for this move I believe it would have taken a longer period of time for the people to stand up for their rights to live in a free world. Though during that period of time of the Civil War it had escalated the amount of hostilities and whether he did it sooner or later there were always gonna be those who would appose this decision and creating that chaos of war. In his decision of making slavery illegal we all can say that it was a risky one at the time where the United states were already separated from the north and the south. By taking that risk of consequences to come upon it was something to do to change the future and make…

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Blessings of Slavery, and what is to come… “The negro slaves of the South are the happiest, and in some sense, the freest people in the world” (Fitzhugh). George Fitzhugh argued that slavery was humane, true to biblical tradition, and a blessing, as seen in his excerpt from Cannibals All, or Slaves without Masters, titled “The Blessings of Slavery”. Fitzhugh’s family suffered some rough times, but through his struggles he was able to achieve great strides such being a small planter and practicing the law. Fitzhugh also wrote two books, in which become so famed, that his words reached President Lincoln, who was shocked by Fitzhugh’s message. Fitzhugh had awaken the south, startling this whole revolution of secession with slavery, and its prominence in the southern living economy.…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critic of policy options It appears that most of the actions taken by the government (laws, agencies) have currently not proven their efficiency due to either, the absence of strict implementation, lack of funding for agencies, or the inexistence of forms of protection and reinsertion for victims. It is important that in its fight for the eradication of slavery the current policy should include legislation relative to racism and all forms of discrimination. Also the government should seek to regulate the messages preached in mosques in the intention of raising awareness among victims but also slave owners.…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays