Bernard Berenson: The Study And Criticism Of Italian Art

Improved Essays
Bernard Berenson was born in Lithuania in 1865, and moved to America when he was 9 years old. Berenson studied art history at Harvard on scholarship, and set off traveling Europe in 1887 with monetary help from patrons, specifically Isabella Stewart Gardner. When money started to run out Berenson still desired to stay in Europe, so he became active in the art market. In 1890 England, Berenson met his future wife, Mary Smith, and with her collaboration, began writing books on Italian art. His most popular writings being, The Drawings of the Florentine Painters (1903), The Study and Criticism of Italian Art (1901), and Three Essays in Method (1927). After a rise to fame from a review on Venetian paintings exposing 33 fakes attributed to Titian, …show more content…
He was introduced to Morelli’s writings through Jean Paul Richter’s critical discussion of Italian pictures in the National Gallery. Richter was one of Morelli’s eager followers. Berenson used Morelli’s techniques as building blocks for his method of connoisseurship by elaborating on his set of traits for establishing an artist. He categorized aspects of a painting into three groups, in order of usefulness in determining who painted the piece, which he calls the Morellian tests. First group holds the ears, hands, folds, and landscapes. Second group has eyes, nose, and mouth, and the third group has chin, overall figure, architecture, color, and contrasts. Unlike Morelli, Berenson believed that all the aspects of a painting point to a specific artist, which was their metaphysics of individuality, rather than a region or school of thinking. Like Morelli, Berenson focused mainly on Italian paintings, perhaps from the bias of his teacher or the time period, or the appreciation of ‘great …show more content…
It has Leonardo traits, but it doesn 't carry his metaphysical individuality. La Bella is the only painting of Leonardo 's to have an object sitting in front of the subject and the viewer. La Belle also most closely resembles the Mona Lisa, who wasn 't painted until 15 years after Belle. The paintings that Leonardo was making at the time period of La Belle were still rather stylized, and all beared some sort of resemblance, La Belle being the odd one out. This method could be useful in determining authorship, if used in conjunction with another method. This method doesn 't account for style change, the ability to grow as an artist, or contemporary preference. Berenson’s tests are helpful in picking up subtle clues about the artist and the artist’s hand, but again, does not account for any semblance of

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Like what most portrait paintings looks, there is only one figure in the picture. Unlike past art works, this painting does not have a outline to the figure. Leonardo da Vinci uses a technic called sfumato and instead of outlining, he used the contrast of light and shadow. This makes the painting seem more life like and realistic. The location of the back ground is said to be unknown even today and the identity of Mona Lisa is also said to be a mystery according to Ficher and on numerous articles and websites (2016).…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Why was there seemingly such a remarkable barrier of skill between Titian and those below him? Three works of art on display at The MET’s Gallery 607 allow for a great analysis of what really went on in 16th century Venice. Paris Bordone and Lorenzo Lotto both have a history with Titian, yet both could only accomplish just a modicum of the success that he did. Titian’s, Venus and the Lute Player, Lotto’s, Brother Gregorio, and Bordone’s, Portrait of a Man in Armor…

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Florence the poem would be read to the public like a lecture. The Divine Comedy and all of the italians influenced to write like Dante helped create the Italian language. His work is considered what brought the European world out of the Medieval Ages and into the Renaissance. The reason this was thought is that it showed civilization reemerging and the ending of catholic rule. The story gave an image that the middles ages were a time of the past.…

    • 1476 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Period Eye Analysis

    • 1118 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This example sets up the the idea that art is influenced by the world constructed around it. Another example Baxandall use is the different types of the Vigin Mary. You can tell what part of the “Annucationation” you are looking at use by the gesture of the Virgin Mary. Respiting the Virgin in different parts of the story was a very poplar thing back in fiftieth-centery painting. People of that time and from Italian culture would understand that little detail in the painting but maybe some from outside of the culture would not understand that detail in the same way.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Italian Baroque

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Mannerism is a style marked by a spatial complexity, artificiality, and affection. These paintings brought self-conscious spirituality and profound insecurities of an age of religious wars and political rivalry. The Italian baroque started in the seventeenth century and dominated the style of production between 1650 through 1750. The baroque artists in Italy made art to express the religious subject matter that they wanted to share to others. Through their art, they were able to give the sense of participation in major events in the Christian story and in the ritual of worships.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Giotto took what he learned from the world and used it in this art piece. He was able to show the mother like figure by showing her shape underneath her robe. Also, could notice how he incorporated shadows and used his new naturalistic approach. Duccio is another large artist during the Renaissance in Italy. He was known for showing religious figures with emotion.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michelangelo was obsessed with the human form and understanding the shape of the human figure above all else and known for his pieces physical realism (Michelangelo And The Mastery Of Drawing). “This drawing is the result of intense observation and masterful economy of notation, from which the artist would pull information for painting the fresco” (linesandcolors.com). Michelangelo was an individual artist who worked on projects in various disciplines. “One of the commonalities that relate each of his works in the different fields together is that they all start with a drawing” (michelangelo-gallery.com). One way we can observe the critical thinking process Michelangelo used is in the toe being drawn three times.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Artists Leonardo da Vinci and Johannes Vermeer have left a mark on the importance and compelling factors of a portrait. Leonardo da Vinci’s “Mona Lisa” is one of the most famous paintings in the world. His use of color and details “Mona Lisa” developed many controversies on the analysis of the painting. As for Vermeer’s “Girl with a Pearl…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Italian culture is one of the most historical and elegant cultures arguably in the world. It is for this reason I take pride in learning about the values of my ancestors and even of my parents. Similar to what we explored in Beppe Severgnini’s La Bella Figura, there is a defining line that proves your Italian simply by the way situations are handled. This comical yet very true narrative explains how certain environments in Italy are very different from what we expect. Having been fortunate to experience Italy’s beauty, reading more into the Italian culture has allowed me to view the country entirely different from what I experienced.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gustave Courbet was a man interested in beauty no matter where he found it while Eugène Delacroix focused more on beauty in war and suffering. Both painters used color to enhance the authenticity of the the people in the images. As well as color, the painters used shadowing and it enhanced the mystery and seriousness of the paintings. Gustave and Eugène both painted pictures of characters that were surrounded by backgrounds that either enhanced them or the scene or the image in the back was blurred to emphasize the unimportance of everything except the characters. Emotion is also evident in both of their paintings.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays