Arguments Against Gay Adoption

Improved Essays
The subject of gay rights has been a hot topic in today’s society causing a heated debate. The homosexual community has faced many obstacles. Recently, an enormous victory in the fight for civil rights was won by the Supreme Court’s ruling that same sex couples have the right to marry. In some states, gays have the right to adopt children, unfortunately, it is not legal in all states for homosexual married couples to adopt children together. The US should lift the laws restricting married homosexual couples from adopting children.
In one child’s experience, an adoption by a gay couple was a blessing. Michael Arden is now 22 years old, but he recalls how he arrived in foster care with his two brothers. When Michael was young, he slowly came
…show more content…
The naysayers point out that having two same sex parents will confuse children. A study from the University of Cambridge states that same sex parents “do not suffer any disadvantage, and the vast majority are not bullied at school” (Owen). This leads to the following question, should judges shape decisions on where to place children for adoption based on the possibility for bullying? Especially since, most children are teased or bullied at some point in their lives. An expert in the study explains "What I don 't like is when people make assumptions that a certain type of family, such as gay fathers, will be bad for children. The anxieties about the potential negative effect for children of being placed with gay fathers seem to be, from our study, unfounded” (Owen). Brodzinsky argues, a family’s ability to have a positive relationship is more important to a child’s psychological well-being than the genetic relatedness of the children. (Brodzinsky 40). Mallon reports many homosexual fathers described a “deep and abiding desire” to be a father as well as feelings of sadness; these feelings stemmed from the social stigma that surrounds gay men and men in general wanting to become parents. Each man recalls feeling as though there were an unspoken set of standards. These standards implied that if a man, especially a gay man wanted to be a father …show more content…
Despite meeting resistance and controversy along the way, the overall trajectory for lesbian and gay adoption has been toward acceptance and accommodation rather than exclusion”. (Brodzinsky 53)
The gay community has faced many forms of discrimination, including the prevailing thought they are not fit to be parents. Many judges bring personal ideals into the courtroom and put personal beliefs before the well-being of the child. A gay person is just as capable of raising a child as any other person is. Sexual orientation should have no place in the decision of to whom a child should be entrusted to. The US should enact laws to make it more accommodating for homosexuals to adopt

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    As a conclusion, there are many misunderstandings about gay / lesbian relationships, their marriage and adoption. People do not even sure about the definition of the word “marriage”. Marriage does not have to be between a man and a woman. People should not exclude gays and lesbian because of the life they are living. It is not their choice, a man does not wake up one day in the morning and decides to be gay.…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “The traditional family consisting of a father, a mother and children is ‘a fashion that does not happen’. ” Are words from the founders fashion designer Domenico Dolce of Dolce & Gabbana brand, according to New York Daily News. Gender equality at this time brings us changes in the family, not only heterosexual couples want adopter children also gays couple want to do it. Should same-sex couples adopt children and raise a family? Everyone has the right to have a father and a mother, but not everyone has the right to be fathers or mothers, the gay designer is aware like many people that gay adoption should not be recommended for many reasons like psychological disorders, identity and socialization problems. These problems could lead to various…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “It’s a shame that qualified families are being rejected from the process because of irrelevant considerations, such as sexuality” - Shannon Corregan. Gay couples are being rejected from adoption just for their sexuality. Although some say children need a mother and a father, Gay couples should be allowed to adopt. Laws have been enforced to ban gay couples from legally adopting a child. Evidence from the article states “The Supreme Court's refusal to hear an appeal was a setback for the American Civil Liberties Union and gay rights group.”…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout this notion, a child needs the reassurance of both a mother and father figure. Once again, individuals who are ‘for’ gay marriage and parenting will possibly disagree and point out that a homosexual couples does not necessarily need to have children or the case that children will not be affected with same sex parents. As for the argument ‘against' this topic, that is not necessarily the case. In order to build upon this idea of children having both a mother and a father figure as apart of their lives, Jane Edwards’s article builds on Rod Benson’s claims in relation to arguments against same sex marriage laws. Rod Benson (2011, para 5) argues that “marriage has a place in the law because a relationship between a man and a woman is the kind of relationship that may produce children.…

    • 2734 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gay Appropriation

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The principle things to search for while assessing a man's worth as a parent ought to be regardless of whether the individual is minding, dedicated, and stable. In an article by Jon Campbell, it is expressed that a man, Danny Stewart, found an as of late conceived child on a tram. The child was arrested and when Jon Campbell was gotten some information about this infant the judge inquired as to whether he was occupied with embracing. Before long, he and his accomplice, Peter Mercurio, embraced the infant, imagining that it may be their lone possibility in receiving a tyke. Another case of how much gay couples esteem having kids is appeared by Birtcher, a 44 year old hair salon proprietor, when he said, "Our jails are brimming with individuals who were in child care, and those individuals were in, quote unquote, straight family homes, in the event that I can give an adoring, stable home for my son, that is the objective.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Children should grow up with parents of separate genders. Many may think that having separate gender does not have an impact on how your children are raised. However, it is only the beginning of showing them from right and wrong. According to the article “Children Without Mothers Are at Special Risk,” “If a son or daughter who loses a mother never receives adequate substitute mothering, the loss can do long-term damage to his or her self-esteem, ability to relate to other people, overall feelings of security and ability to trust others.”…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stereotyping And Adoption

    • 1348 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Stereotype threat can contribute to the stress of the adoption process by forcing a parent to change the way they are adopting or even to go above and beyond the law to make adoption a possibility. Often times, the laws can cause discrepancies that force the couple to change the agency they want to adopt through, or even force them to move to another state if there are laws against LGBT couples adopting together. A lot of times it is okay for a single person, who is LGBT, to adopt, but it is very difficult for an LGBT couple to adopt together and they may have to go to court in order for that to be a possibility. “Sexual minority mothers reported using four primary methods to learn about the law: doing independent research, relying on friends, relying on LGBT organizations, and hiring an attorney.” (Kazyak 2015).…

    • 1348 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As people have said, homosexual parents cannot provide a traditional family setting, because of the parents, having a very easy time of getting a kid, the parents are more likely to affect the child “negatively”, and homosexual families can’t raise children because it’s unnatural. These questions bring up the important question of, “Should Gay Citizens be able to Adopt Children?” People…

    • 1165 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Federal Information & News Dispatch comments, “Only seven states prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation in adoption, and only five explicitly ban discrimination in foster care. Louisiana, Mississippi and Michigan prohibit same-sex couples from jointly adopting, and Nebraska, Ohio, Kentucky and Kansas restrict same-sex couples from accessing second-parent adoption. ”(Congressional Documents and Publications). The times tides have been turning for LBGT couples due to the fact that only 7 states still having laws preventing the fostering or adoption of children. If America as a whole proceeds to looking forward, the barrier these states have create can be disbanded so that all LGBT couples in any region of the U.S. have equal rights to adopt and to foster children.…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Adoption is not about finding a child for a family; it’s about finding a family for a child. Adoption has been around for many years, but only recently has the question of gay adoption been raised. Throughout this world there are many orphans but not enough parents or families to take them in. There are not that many families who can and will adopt children, whether its because they cant support them, they have children of their own, or they just don’t want children. The end result is still an over abundance of orphaned children in need of a loving family.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An estimated 100,000 kids linger in foster care centers around the United States. Same-sex couples are dominating a large portion of the population that hope to adopt, but still continue to face many obstacles on their quest to do so. Because the Supreme Court voted to make gay marriage legal nationwide in 2015, this aids in same-sex couples being allowed to adopt from foster care agencies instead of through private, gay-friendly adoption agencies. However, homosexual couples continue to face difficulties in adopting in states that have laws to limit joint adoption to a husband and wife (Beitsch). Research shows evidence that gay and lesbian couples are more likely to adopt foster care children that typically belong to groups that are least likely to get adopted.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Lastly the divorce and all the drama that goes on between parents shouldn’t have anything to do with the child afterwards, only the part about who gets custody of the child, but even then those matters should be discussed behind closed doors. As long as the parents are doing everything in their power to make sure the child comes out a homophobic free life, that 's all that matters at the end of the day. Everyone has their own opinion and belief on how gay adoption should be handled, but mine is that they everyone even gays and lesbians should have the same right as everyone…

    • 1838 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A child being born is said to be one of the happiest moment in parent’s life. They make a silent pact then to protect and love their little angel, regardless of any mistakes that he or she shall make. Unfortunately, sometimes when the parent is looking out for the child’s best interest, their actions can be detrimental to their well-being. This is often the case when a parent is faced with the reality that their son or daughter identifies as LGBT. Some parents may see gay children as having a disorder that they will grow out of, in spite of the medical community believing just the opposite.…

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “According to the Adoption and Foster Care Analysis and Reporting System Report there were about 423,773 children in foster care” (NOLO). This number can be reduced with simple solutions. By denying the access for gay couples to adopt, these children are being left behind. There are too many children who can be adopted but adoption agencies won’t let these couples take them home. Many states deny these couples to adopt.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Destiny Quinonez English 102 October 28, 2016 Essay #4 There are millions of kids all over the world waiting to become part of a family and thousands of couples or families looking to adopt each year. The lack of acceptable straight couples, gay adoption can provide numerous kids with the loving home they need. Same sex couples or straight couples are a better alternative than the foster care system. So why not decrease the number of kids waiting to be apart of a family by allowing them to be raised by people who are making a big decision to cherish and love them through years that lie ahead of them? Adoption is the process of providing families with a child that can no longer be raised by their biological parents.…

    • 2082 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics