Case Study: Should College Athletes Be Paid

Great Essays
When it comes to Sports Law there are several issues at all levels of competition; College, Professional, and even International sports have begun to see an influx of legal issues as the popularity of sports continues to grow. Issues like player health and safety, player labor and union issues, and gambling limitations in sport are generating a lot of conversation. However, the fight between college athletes and the National Collegiate Athletic Association over developing free market and unions for players. The question that is typically heard on a daily basis is, “Should college athletes be paid?”, and the typical answer is ether “yes” or “no, they are getting a free education.” But, as the topics popularity continues to grow and the athletes …show more content…
NCAA case is a win for former, current, and future college athletes. Not only has this case helped to provide student-athletes playing on Division I football and basketball teams the opportunity to earn financial aid for the full cost of going to the school, but it has sparked conversation from the topic. Following this case, we will see Jenkins v. NCAA arguing for free market for college athletes’ labor services, and while the O’Bannon case was taking place the litigation before the National Labor Relations Board gave the Northwestern University scholarship football players’ right to …show more content…
These college athletes are used as employees by the universities to produce a product on the field which can cause them serious injury and brings in profits that they do not see in return. I understand that many people feel like a college scholarship to play college sports is enough and that the universities have stated that they cannot afford to pay all of the student athletes and that it would be unfair to only pay men’s basketball and football teams. That is why I believe that the “Olympic Model” is the solution to this issue because now it gives all college athletes from all sports to get paid, it takes pressure of the universities to pay the athletes, and is completely separate from the financial aid aspect. The “Olympic Model” is based off of how Olympic athletes make money for a living because they get paid very low sums of money by their countries and it gives them an opportunity to gain financial security based on their individual performance. By introducing this into college sports you would allow for college athletes to get money from endorsements, autographs, jobs, and control their own image. I understand that with this type of model will also have to come with rules to prevent the college athletes from infringing upon the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    They should not be paid in salaries because they’re still student athletes and not professional athletes. Also he goes on to say, “They are students receiving access to a college education through their participation in sports, for which they earn scholarships to pay tuition, fees, room and board, and other allowable expenses” (Horace Mitchell. Vol 5. Issue 52, p 17-17. p.1). He is right because they do get a lot of benefits from the universities.…

    • 2027 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This quote is stating a prime reason why college athletes should not be paid; the athletes are already receiving money for playing a sport. Why do the athletes need a paycheck on top of thousands of dollars in scholarship money? Numerous college athletes are capable of receiving both athletic and academic scholarships. Many college students have a hard time just paying for a college level education, therefore it is simply unfair for the student’s who choose to go to college for education to not receive a high amount of money in scholarships as well if the athletes get paid on top of his or her scholarship (Block). The athletes should not receive any more treatment than going to college for free, if other students aren’t receiving any more money on top of scholarships as well.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should Athletes Be Paid There are many different arguments going on right now in colleges about student athletes. The main one is if athletes should or should not be paid. In the article titled 7 Common Sense Reasons Why College Athletes Should Be Paid (According to Jay Bilas), Peebles interviews Bilas on the controversial topic: payment of college athletes. Many people believe that scholarships, grants, and loans are enough for the athletes. However, Peebles and Bilas are strong believers of college athletes being paid.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paying College Athletes

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In order to live the dream of playing a collegiate sport, one must work the extra mile to break away from the pack. Getting paid for athletics may seem like it’s logical with the amount of money college games earn, but getting paid to play a sport is what sets the pros and the up and comers apart. How would the University disperse the money between all of the athletes anyways, would it be based on skill or position? There is no answer, there would never be a fair way to pay. Paying the athletes is no the solution.…

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    College athletes get scholarships from colleges to play sports. The athletes put in a lot of time and energy to play on a college level team. Weather they should be paid or not is the question. Pro athletes get money to play sports, so why shouldn’t the college athletes. A lot of college athletes get hurt playing sports which end up hurting their chances of going pro.…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If the NCAA started paying these athletes, the students would be too closely compared to true professionals, while actually they are students at a university. Most college sports team are not profitable enough to pay their athletes, let alone operate the cost of their institution. Some colleges do not have enough benefits to make every single athlete happy, and if they start paying athletes as well, the powerhouse colleges will become so much more powerful and destroy the lower colleges because they can not receive the best available players. Professional players mainly choose which team they will play on based on whichever franchise will sign them the biggest contract. “Students are not professional athletes who are paid salaries and incentives for a career in sports.…

    • 2398 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many complain for various reasons, as mentioned above, how allowing collegiate athletes to be paid will ruin the point of college. In reality, these athletes are just receiving what they deserve. The NCAA is a billion dollar industry that has more than enough money to pay athletes. The athletes sacrifice countless hours, work themselves to exhaustion, plus carry the burdens of a regular student all in the name of a game-without them there would be nothing. College athletes deserve a portion of the money that they help generate.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pay for Play One of the biggest debates in college sports right now is if college athletes should be getting paid to play. College sports is big money maker for many people. The sports make so much money for the schools and television programs are just racking in money on game day. The only people part of college sports not making money is the athletes. Many of the athletes think they should be paid to play the sport they are playing.…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First off, if one team wants to start paying their players, based on the amount of revenue that teams produces, it would flag the question as to whether or not all athletes for each sport in the college should be paid. Some people who are involved will be against all teams getting paid and others will be for it. If schools decided to only pay certain players, other teams or athletes may quit from this unfair, discriminating act. If they only pay the biggest revenue making teams, commonly football and basketball, are all players going to get paid, even those who sit on the bench? “Commonly, players and their families often overestimate a player’s market worth.…

    • 1366 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Paying a college athlete defeats the overall purpose of attending a university. Being a student athlete is meant to achieve success on the field, but being a student is to continue academic success. Paying a college athletes would not live up to the purpose of furthering one’s knowledge and obtaining a degree to begin life in their career aspirations. Although it may seem reasonable to pay these athletes for sacrificing their body, just as professionals do, however, college is not the place for the students to be paid to play, that is why there is a professional…

    • 1072 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays