The Importance Of Nonconsensual Silence

Decent Essays
Nonconsensual Silence Humans often try to exert their control over companion animals through changes like physical refinement to their liking. One of the main physical traits that people try to alter on a dog is vocalization because they do not want their dog to irritate them with their constant barking. Many owners would request procedures to devocalize their dogs such as laryngeal paralysis that remove vocal fold masses. Often, this would hurt the dogs physically and emotionally. Humans should not be devocalizing their dogs through surgery, or with any alternative methods, because it restricts their way of communicating with other dogs and humans, and causes countless health issues. Vocalization is an important factor of how dogs communicate …show more content…
Barking is a normal dog behavior, without it they tend to lose interaction and relationships among other dogs. (Sarangom 2013) Even after the procedure there are no guarantee if the owners would keep the devocalized dog, and often those dogs become strays. Without their ability to vocalize, these newly stray dogs are not able to communicate with other dogs when they are in need of help. They often start to lose the ability to interact with other dogs and would not be able to form bonds with others. Throughout the course of history humans favor dogs that help make their lives easier such as warning and signaling them when someone is intruding their property. (Grossman 2013) Dogs are evolved from wolves that are much quieter, but since domestication started humans picked the more vocalized dogs due to their ability to bark and alarm them when emergencies happen. Humans were the reason why dogs were manipulated for their vocalization, but now since quieter dogs are more valued they would choose to devocalize their dogs and not think about the consequences that follow it. People devocalize their pets due to noise pollution and the annoyance …show more content…
One of form of punishment to inhibit barking behavior is using electric shock collars (Sarangom 2013) These collars are controlled by humans and, when the dogs would bark, they would control the collar and cause it to shock the dogs, and this is to punish them and to stop them from more barking. People do not understand that electric shock is very harmful and cause pain to dogs. According to Sarangmom relinquishment and euthanasia are two convenient alternatives when devocalizing and training has failed. Relinquishment is when the owner gives away their dog, which often leads to them becoming strays. So stray dogs are not able to communicate with other animals due to their previous owner devocalizing them and they are not able to form bonds with others. Euthanasia is when the owner lets their dog die painlessly through drugs and gases that slows down their breathing and systems. It is unfair though that these dogs have to be put down due to natural behavior, and they do not have the choice or voice to tell their owner. They think relinquishment and euthanasia is the final decision because other methods such as training and devocalizing operations do not work and their barking dogs still pester

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This is a medical method to end up their life without pain. Although it may be a good way for pet dogs, it still violate the ethical thinking. No one should have the authority or right to take away another one’s lives. Some owner want their dogs to be passed away because of his or her situation or ability. In such case, it is not ethical to do so as the pet dogs may still healthy without any sick and illness.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Animals don’t deserve to be tested or harm in anyway because they didn’t do anything. Animals should have at least some rights so we can improve how animals are abused, tested, and disrespected by humans. Would you want your pet to be taken away for testing? Would you want to watch the brutality of it? If not, then why let another animal go through this.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    It also states that some women were at a risk of having blood clots with the use of an oral contraceptive and some animal tests failed to actually solve the problem. With using dogs and having them take the same oral contraceptive it had a much different effect, it made the dog have a more difficult time for their blood to clot. “The study of an infection that bears no resemblance to that found in a human would be fruitless in terms of developing treatment strategies for the human condition” (“Animal Models of Infection”). Some scientists say when testing on an animal for a human 's sake, it needs to mirror the human as much as possible. This is utterly wrong in the case of dogs because dogs do not react the same way as humans would react to these drugs.…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dogs are not born to fight it is how they are raised. There are many reasons why a fighting dog should be put down or euthanized. Some people might disagree, however it what is best for the animal. This will prevent this animal from getting out and killing other animals. When dogs are trained to fight and have puppies then they will have the instinct to kill as well.…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being A Service Dog Essay

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For example, traits such as fear, aggression and timidity would not be appropriate Service Dog work. Additionally, any health or behavioral concerns would not be right for a Service Dog candidate. Here are some tips for choosing a Service dog prospect from a shelter. Age: Evaluating a Puppy is entirely different then evaluating an adolescent or adult dog. You do want to be able to tell the temperment of the prospect, however you do not want a dog that is older as it significantly decreases the dog’s working life.…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although the article is presented as strictly scientific, Brassey uses phrases such as “greedy mutation” and “food obsession” to make the audience feel as if Labradors can’t help that they’re obese. Analyzing the topic, the word “obesity” tends to have a negative connotation, so its use serves as an unwanted consequence in relation to any topic. On the other hand, Labradors are referred as “our most popular canine companion” in the article. Dog lovers will experience negative feelings of sadness to see obesity occurring in a beloved animal and will want to learn about the efforts to prevent obesity addressed in this article. The use of this device creates an audience that is willing to read this article in order to take action in a struggle between a negative consequence and a lovable animal.…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    this can affect the way a dog reacts to others around them as if they feel threatened they made become more aggressive or very timid however they are more likely to run or hide from the threat whereas the wolf would usually become aggressive and stand its ground. If they are having trouble with hormones they may over react or try to mate with other animals or objects. Hormones may also cause a male dog to scent on objects even if they have been taught not to or in female dogs cause fake pregnancies. However this behaviour has been dramatically decreased in domesticated dogs as owners will have their dogs fixed so that they are calmer and not as unpredictable. Stress is another internal factor tat can change a dog 's behaviour and make them unpredictable however the reaction to certain types of stress has been reduced compared to the wolf and other have been escalated, for example a wolf is used to wide open spaces and is allowed freedom and if it is confined it may become very strassed causing health issues whereas the domestic dog is used to confined spaces like a house, garden or even cage and would not experience that amount of stress.…

    • 1522 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Additionally, animals do not exhibit human diseases such as HIV, Alzheimer's disease and many more. Therefore, it sounds useless to think that testing drugs to these diseases using animals will give accurate results (Slattery & Cryan, 2012). Apart from this, using these animals as test subjects also greatly violates the animal rights, because animals just like humans have feelings and deserve to be treated right. However, if not for the use of these animals, the medicine world would be stagnant. However, the use of animals as testing subjects should be banned, because it greatly invades animals’ rights and puts the animals through a lot of pain and suffering.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With this happening, it causes potential dangerous pathogen spreads between people and animals. This isn’t fair to the animals because this wasn’t the animal's choice, even though they can’t let someone know what they want and what they don’t want, it still is common sense that no animal would want that done to them. Eventually all the animals will pick up on the treatment of antibiotics given to them before being slaughtered, that will result in depression from many of the other animals. No animals want to have to go through that process. The…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis The article “All Dog, No Bark: The Pitfalls of Devocalization Surgery,” establishes that devocalization is a negative and unnecessary surgery. It gives many alternatives to devocalization and ways that an owner can prevent a dog from barking. The article uses the process of devocalization, examples, and solutions to prove that there are no positive effects on a dog. Therefore the article accomplishes it’s goal in persuading readers to believe that devocalization is inhumane and unnecessary. In the first paragraph the author, Anna Grossman, explains the process of debarking, it “involves removing a dog’s vocal cords with an incision made either through the mouth or the neck.” The author uses this explanation in hopes of deterring dog owners from debarking their animals.…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics