Death Penalty Good Or Bad

Good Essays
The death penalty is a controversial topic throughout the United States. When convicted of a capital crime, a criminal has a chance to be sentenced to death if the crime was committed in one of the 31 states that offer this lethal sentence (States With and Without the Death Penalty, 2015). While most people argue that the death penalty is the right thing to do if someone commits such a heinous crime, or that without it it would cost much more to house these criminals for life, I disagree. Though intended to punish people, the death penalty may be doing more harm than good. With the first execution performed in 1608, the death penalty was brought to America by the Europeans. Most of the colonies had their own laws for what was punishable by …show more content…
Soon after, some states began to get rid of this punishment while others actually extended the number of crimes that could be sentenced to death, mainly states with slavery. As time progressed to the twentieth century, many states who had abolished the death penalty reinstated it when new execution methods developed and eager criminologists stressed it was needed in America. With the United States moving forward in terms of capital punishment, most of America’s allies had removed the death penalty by the 1950’s and only 42% of the population favored it (Part 1: History of the Death Penalty, n.d.). This led to many doubts on the humanity of the punishment, and it was said to be cruel and unusual. The Supreme Court began to change the ways death was given, and throughout the next thirty or so years the court had given the power to the states to write their own death penalty statutes to rid the problems associated with the question of constitutionality and problems of crimes (Part 1: History of the Death Penalty, …show more content…
In Texas, it’s $47.50 to keep a prisoner behind bars for twenty-four hours. If the inmate was sheltered for a span of forty-years, it would cost $693,500. Again, this is just the cost to bunk this prisoner. From the time a death row inmate receives the sentence to their execution date with court costs by themselves, it is an nearly $1.2 million dollars. Some argue that if the length of the appeals could be shortened, then the death penalty would not cost as much, but research says the cost of the first trial is always more expensive in death cases. When you factor in the multiple lawyers appointed to the case, the cost continues to stack up, as well as the fact that cases are almost always retried several times (Carver, 2009). It makes sense to think that killing someone convicted of a capital offense would be cheaper, but these inmates must go through a much more length process to be certain they are guilty and provided fair

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    By some estimates, seeking death adds at least $1 million to the cost of a murder trial, and some death penalty cases cost 20 times as much as the average life-without-parole prosecution.” Many people would agree that it isn’t worth the money to seek the death penalty and instead just pay for the person to stay in prison for the rest of their life. However, others like Don Hambidge say that, “ Safety is better than convenience.” If the person going to prison is going there for life, and not having any chance of seeing the outside world again, and convicted of killing someone else, what would stop them from not killing or hurting someone else in…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    On the contrary, however, capital punishment is in violation of the constitution due to an individual’s life being exterminated through force. Inmates who are facing death row are reaching a fate where their life is seized from existence. In contrast to the death penalty allowing the inmate to die with dignity, lethal injection is not guaranteed effective. For instance, California’s technique of lethal injection had the risk of an inmate suffering extreme pain (Economist 2014, 2). If the death sentencing contains immense pain, the punishment should be considered cruel and…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Capital punishment, the United States law that is enforced on society’s most dangerous criminals such as rapist and murderers to “ensure” the safety of citizen and deter crimes as promised. As of right now, there are thirty eight states in the United States that have a death penalty and the cost of the death penalty for each state is different but one thing in similar is it’s not worth spending so much money on killing somebody that could face a better way of punishment. Many believe that the death penalty benefits outweigh its costs because it has been there for centuries. "The death penalty should not be a utilitarian issue in terms of weighing the costs against the benefits, but rather an issue simply of justice, of who deserves it.”(Jon)…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The cost of capital punishment is too excessive. Many Americans will argue that the state should find more affordable ways to execute the inmate when infact most of the money spent on a capital punishment case is put into the trials preceding the execution. On average a death penalty trial will cost $116,700.00 more than a regular murder trial. This is largely due to jury selection, pretrial motions, and expenses for expert witnesses, all of which are more complicated than a regular case. If california alone were to abolish capital punishment it would save the state 90 million each year(Source).…

    • 1332 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Although most states differ between most of these consequences they mainly all agree on the ‘Murder Felony Rule.’ This rule states that even if the murder was an accident if someone is killed someone will be put in jail or receive the Death Penalty for this person’s life. Some say that this is how it should be and then others completely disagree with it saying that it is unfair. “If a death occurs accidentally during the commission of a felony, then the felon should not be charged.” (Felony-Murder…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For example, they don't take into account the increase in the cost of life without parole cases if there were no death penalty. Criminal defendants who are facing the death penalty — which today must be pleaded by prosecutors up front — often want to make a deal by pleading guilty to first degree murder in exchange for a sentencing recommendation of life without parole. The existence of the death penalty as a possible sentence leads to guilty pleas that save the money spent on trials and limit the opportunity for appeals." The real question is, why would you keep a criminal alive in prison for as long as they should live? Why spend the money to keep someone like this alive.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Capital Punishment Cons

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The prosecutors should have the choice to use certain punishments to lower crime. Justice possibility served to fit the right crime .if the prisoner is on parole or escapes it can give them another chance to kill. The biggest reason why to keep the penalty to prevent more crimes from happing in the world. Nowadays the parole system is a big joke. It just doesn’t make sense to have someone in prison for a “life” sentence plus twenty more years.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Another recent study concluded that a death-eligible case in Maryland in which the death penalty is not sought would cost, over the prisoner 's lifetime, about $ 1.1 million; a case in which the death penalty is successfully sought would cost about $ 3 million”. (OUR BROKEN DEATH PENALTY) Although many religions scriptures have supported the death penalty, but almost every religion within America goes against the death penalty and considers it to be immoral. The opposing side also feels that the death penalty could put innocent people at risk. There has been numerous people that have received the death penalty that have been released from death row, some of these were minutes right before the execution start time. This could have been because the individual was poorly defended, and received the maximum punishment for something that he may not have done.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The extra money spent on the death penalty could be spent on other means of achieving justice and making the community safer. “To any state, a million dollars spent today is a lot more costly than an equivalent amount paid gradually over 40 years” (www.nmrepeal.org/issues/cost). Some may argue that paying this large fee is worth it for deterring crime, but that is flaw. “The death penalty is not a deterrent to crime. In 2006, the South again had the…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Life without parole costs more than execution by the capital crimes punishment. Greengarbageblogadmin states in their article, “death penalty costs government… the lives of incarcerated individuals serving life.” When a prisoners ruling is life in prison without parole means they require everything to be paid for them by taxpayers’ money. The death penalty provides a cheaper way to punish criminals rather than locking them away; when a prisoner is locked away, other people must pay for their health care, food, and other necessities they may need. The average cost for a prisoner in prison for one year is $31,286. The economical view of the conflict shows that despite a short term high price, it is cheaper in the long…

    • 1918 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays