High School Integrity Case Study

Improved Essays
Integrity I recently read an interesting article about a group of students cheating. The question that was lingering throughout the article was, has integrity declined leading to issues such as cheating? Cheating has become a problem, and in this case a highschool teacher did something about it. Christine Pelton failed 28 sophomores from her biology class after finding evidence that they had plagiarized their semester projects. The principal and superintendent gave her their support and agreed with giving the students zeros until parents complained to the school. The parents fought for their children’s wrongdoing, and as a result, the school board backed down. Mrs. Pelton resigned from her teaching position based on the lack of integrity. …show more content…
The beginning and appropriate approach was failing the twenty eight students on their assignment. That was not the long term result in this case. Instead, the school board acted by going easier on the guilty. Christine showed integrity by noticing the cheating, and quitting when she was overruled by the school board. Teachers ignoring cheating now could get students kicked out of college later on. Schools can not blame cheating on students anymore. A surprising 74% of high school students had cheated or plagiarized based on McCabe’s experiment in the years 2000 and 2001. This problem affects everyone. I have already listed off how it involves the cheaters, parents, administration, and school board, but the other students are also affected. Some students are hard workers that do their own work, and they have to compete with cheaters. I know for a fact that I have put a lot of work into my academics. It does not seem fair that cheaters are still rewarded and receive the same privileges after they don’t do their own work or understand it. The Kansas school must have realized that cheating is wrong which is why they acted on it initially, but now that they gave up it defeats the purpose. Cheating will never end, but this almost promotes it. Cheating happens in our school, but I do not notice it all the time. It is naive to think it does not happen at all. Although it happens, it does not make it okay. …show more content…
Not only do I have strong feelings towards the subject, but I can relate to it on an extremely personal level. I was left with the question, has integrity declined leading to issues such as cheating? Cheating has become a problem, but it does not matter what it is. If it is wrong, our schools should be capable of fixing the issue instead of just promising to. I completely support Mrs. Christine Pelton in her overall decisions and actions, and I honestly look up to her. The results from these incidents affect the students, teachers, administration, and parents. The most important things you can learn in school are habits and life lessons, and if cheating is portrayed as okay then our system is failing. I hope the future brings hope and change, but until then I am not afraid to speak my mind and address these problems. Growing up, observing, and having hand in hand experiences with the idea of integrity and all it stands for has been the fundamental reasoning behind my

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Honor Code Dbq Essay

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As it is seen in the students’ responses at Lawrence Academy in Alyssa Vangelli, they said that they did “...not see it as their responsibility” when asked to report cheating (Source B). Another example are the Harvard students in the article about honor codes by Jennifer Dirmeyer and Alexander Cartwright who “...are skeptical that signing a piece of paper will suddenly cause a cheater to change their ways” (Source C). It can be later seen in Dirmeyer and Cartwright’s article that honor codes that are strictly enforced managed by students reduces cheating due to punishments and a social disapproval. Additionally, referring back to McCabe and Pavela’s article, “...the highest levels of cheating are usually found at colleges that have not engaged their students in active dialogue on the issue of academic dishonesty” (Source F). Evidently, maintaining an honor code within the school is proven to reduce…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When appealing to higher loyalties, students believe their responsibility to some other entity, usually their peers, is more important than doing what they know to be morally right. Ultimately, a student will lie their way through their grades because they are given the opportunity to. When an instructor does not uphold strict discipline, opportunities arise for students to take advantage of this situation. The instructor must set an stern environment against academic dishonesty, otherwise a pupil will abuse the opportunity, feeling the instructor does not take cheating seriously. The issue of student engaging in academic dishonesty is one that is continually increasing, as students face a great deal of pressure to succeed academically while many succumb to the trap of cheating.…

    • 1328 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this discussionn board I chose the article on CNN called Cheating in Atlanta Public Schools: it is not what you think. In this article the issues regarding pressure placed on teachers to perform is discussed along with the disadvantages of standardized tests in school environments. The incentive provided by students scoring high on the Criterion Reference Compentency Test (CRCT) urges teachers to strive towards better test results in their classrooms without having regard to specific student educational needs. As far as economics is concerned, the issues teachers faced in their demographic location along with statistics of local social classes showed many red flags that were never researched fast enough. As this specific article explains, the area in Atlanta where the school was located in was a lower income area where 90% of children qualify for free or reduced lunches.…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the past few decades the american dream now requires whoever wants to participate to achieve academic excellence within the school system. This study focuses on a way that students are using to help maintain high grades. By ditching the moral integrity students cheat to help achieve higher grades. The toxic concept of having to do well, has coerced these kids into taking a step down the path into academic dishonesty. The problem is a small step away from dishonesty will eventually lead to bigger problems, but in the minds of the cheaters, they have rationalized that it’s fine, as long as they focus upon the things that they will be doing later in life.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Honor Code Dbq

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Unlike trust in the honor code, you can not change conscience. People will always do what they thinks is right. In other words, maybe students can be taught why cheating is wrong. Philip Altbach, a higher education scholar at Boston College from Source D, speaks on plagiarism and says says “It's just just easier to do… It's tempting to simply insert phrases”.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Point Loma High School

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    When someone cheats, they are not only cheating on paper, but on themselves and their future. By cheating in school, student’s academic grades do well for that semester, but in a month, year, or decade later, the students who took shortcuts on assignments will never have the full knowledge to answer the tricky questions life brings them later on. Academic dishonesty, also known as cheating, is a rapidly spreading issue in which students continue to take to the next level. From texting during an exam to copying the answers on the inside of their calculators, these students have thought of it all and now it is up to us to find an end to this problem. Point Loma High School, a school known for its outgoing students, winning sports teams, and it’s legacy of academic integrity, but is this school really all that it is cracked up to be?…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are numerous reasons why students cheat. In the article Instructing Students in Academic Integrity, according to the authors, “ Cheating tends to be justified when students feel that the material that they are learning is not relevant to educational and personal goals”( Craig, Federici, and Buehler 50). When students don’t feel like an assignment is necessary, then they will simply ask to copy another student's work just to get it done and get the assignment points. This is a very popular trend, especially in a course that doesn’t matter or interests the student. When asking people around campus, the cut throat environment of college and getting into graduate school is the main reason students…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Cheating Is Wrong

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The definition of cheating has remained uncleared. But as it is considered as wrong, no matter what, the teachers were wrong because cheating was something that they started with a good intention, but not in a right way. Teachers are often tempted to cheat as they think that it is an easier way to get bright results. There is not a single situation where I could describe it to be totally fair or acceptable. According to me the teachers at park middle school were at fault.…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article it mentioned East Lake Elementary School as one such school that participated in the cheating scandal (2011). According to the article superintendent Hall suggested that principals that did not meet the goals of the test would be replaced. This is an example of a negative incentive within the school district. Both teacher’s and principles were told by Hall to fear for their jobs if they could not bring up the test scores of their students.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Essay On Honor Codes

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Cheating and plagiarizing hurts the student more than it helps, but with a lack of interest and desire to do well, the student may disregard that possibility. Some students may do even better in an environment where cheating is less common because of an honor code, as represented in Alyssa Vangelli’s article. It makes sense that she has criticisms about a new honor code because not everyone will agree, but once it gets revised and makes students want to prevent cheating, students will end up doing better in school. A less excessive amount of writing a code and consequences and more focused on increasing the moral values of maintaining integrity will aid the success rate of students. Additionally, an increased moral value against cheating and a belief in themselves, students will be more encouraged to reduce the amount of cheating that occurs in school.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Honor Codes Dbq

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Source F explained how “relying on peer monitoring to control cheating” helped the success rate of honesty and integrity. In other words, a cheaters peer convicted them of their actions not some stuffy old teacher who seemed unfair and unrealistic. This method of student involvement helped “students understand the value of academic integrity” (source F). To summarize, many students not understand the importance of academic integrity. Academic integrity is valued because it can influence the student's whole life as well as their future decisions and opportunities.…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While these are valid assumptions, I see that later in Dirmeyers article that with strict enforcement of the honor code with harsh punishments like suspension or expulsion in addition to social disapproval attached to cheating tends to reduce cheating (source C). Additionally, In any school, not just mine, if the consequences for cheating were suspension or expulsion then there would be an obvious decrease in…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Integrity Research Paper

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Another time I was full of integrity along with my AP history class was when Mrs. Rappoport left during our test and although there was opportunity to share answers and cheat everyone stayed quiet and continued their work silently. This shows how Sacred Heart is a school filled with integrity in each and every one of the students. Integrity will affect your future both because if you are caught not being honest and cheating you can possibly be punished. Also if you grow up not being an honest and just person you may not be as successful in life. You will not be confident in yourself because you will rely on cheating and lying.…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Integrity: What Does It Means to You? What does integrity mean to you? The definition of integrity has more than one meaning. Also, the definition varies from person to person.…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Though I’m sure cheating is an issue in every school system to some extent, it truly became an issue when teacher’s had to throw out finals and make their students retake them, which has just happened for my Calculus BC final. I do believe that school’s should run on an honor code because schools should install morals into its students, but if there are no punishments for students who don’t follow the rules there will be kids who have no incentive to do the right thing. Or worse, with a high school system so focused on ranks and numbers, though I don’t believe this is what matters to most colleges, including Duke, students find more incentive in cheating because they get higher grades and don’t have to worry about any punishments. It’s gotten to a point where some teachers turn a blind eye to it because its more paperwork for them to report these kids. So recently, I, along with some other friends who are getting red up, have started talking to teachers about the issue in an attempt to work side by side to find a solution.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays