Authentic Text Analysis

Superior Essays
With the design and implementation of Common Core in recent years (Selection of Authentic Texts, 2013), many researchers and educators struggle to find common ground on the proper use of authentic, simplified and elaborate texts in the classroom for second language acquisition (SLA) (e.g., Crossley, Mouwerse, McCarthy & McNamara, 2007; Allen, 2009; Young, 1999). For teachers of English language learners (ELLs), this problem is compounded by the dual task of teaching content and language skills, often times simultaneously (Herrera & Murry, 2015). Maloch & Bomer (2013) describe the “fourth-year slump” (p. 205) for native English speakers when students begin “reading to learn” instead of simply “learning to read.” Furthermore, ELLs typically cannot …show more content…
Crossley et al., (2007) define authentic texts as a “text originally created to fulfill a social purpose in the language community for which it was intended.” (p. 17). Examples of these raw texts include newspapers, manuals, transportation tickets, advertisements, magazine articles, and, perhaps most relevant to the classroom, novels. (Crossely et al., 2007). Supporters of authentic text usage state that these types of texts are necessary for ELLs if they wish to advance their reading comprehension skills (Herrera & Murry, 2015). ELLs also take advantage of the added redundancy found in many authentic texts (Johnson, 1982). For instance, if a reader does not know the meaning of one word, he or she can rely on other words or phrases in the passage to determine the definition. Detractors of authentic texts claim that these passages are often seen as “too much, too soon” by the readers and lead to a weakening of confidence and morale. If a student is exposed to a great deal of difficult and authentic texts over time, he or she may feel too overwhelmed to continue (O’Donnell, 2009). Furthermore, authentic texts typically take more time to teach than a simplified or elaborated text. When students are learning content and comprehension together, authentic texts can be viewed as a misuse of classroom instruction (Crossely et al, …show more content…
Material developers and publishers, policy makers, teachers of ELLs and content teachers would all benefit from such a result (Crossley & McNamara, 2008). Firstly, commercial publishers are hesitant to stray from their current designs, possibly from a lack of a definitive agreement on this subject (Yano et al., 1994). More recently, Shirzadi (2014) argues that despite some growing momentum of the benefits of lexical simplification, any movement to accommodate these new findings is latent due to inconsistent research. One possible reason for these inconsistencies is the differences in research designs (Crossely et al, 2014). It can be hard to reach one conclusion when methods and procedures can vary widely. Teachers, both of ELLs and content subjects, would most certainly feel the effect of more solid analysis on this subject. As already discussed above, modifications, of any kind, take time (Allen, 2009, Petersen & Ostendorf, 2007). This poses a huge hurdle for teachers who are already working countless hours in and out of the classroom. Taking up precious prep time by modifying authentic texts for their students can be seen as tedious and perhaps futile. If material developers produced proper texts for ELLs, teachers would not need to modify existing texts themselves (perhaps even doing so incorrectly or intuitively) (Crossley et al, 2012). ENL/ESL teachers who follow the SIOP model would better understand

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Philosophy of Reading I am someone who loves children, and knowing that I am one step closer to having my own classroom gives me a huge sense of hope and joy. If I can help just one child, I feel an irresistible sense of accomplishment; and as a teacher I will have the opportunity to help many children. To succeed as a teacher, I need each one of my students to succeed. I believe reading is the backbone of the classroom; and ultimately being a proficient reader increases the chance for success in life in general.…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Diving In: An Introduction to Basic Writing” by Mina Shaughnessy In this article, Shaughnessy argues that educators need to start examining their own teaching and learning processes and the complex and contextual needs of their students, instead of focusing on what students can be doing differently. She points out that basic writing students are not behind and need to “catch up” to any particular level, but there must been a more effective means of communication needs to be established between the students and teachers (291). Shaughnessy presents four stages of development as a basic writer instructor and explains how educators move through these stages before becoming competent to teach basic writing. The first stage called “Guarding the…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Each and every person conceptualizes reading in a different way. In their article “Rhetorical Reading Strategies and the Construction of Meaning” Christina Haas and Linda Flower examine the different ways readers, mainly students, read a text and break it down for post read analysis. They believe that every student finds different meaning in every text they read as they show when they state, “There is a growing consensus in our field that reading should be thought of as a constructive rather than as a receptive process: that “meaning” does not exist in a text but in readers and the representations they build” (167). This shows that they do not share the same ideas about reading that many K-12 institutions throughout the united states do considering…

    • 1821 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    By analyzing the issue from all sides, Shanahan shows readers the issue does exist through remarkable uses of ethos, pathos and logos. Furthermore, Shanahan’s article was rhetorically successful, in my opinion, communicating his research without an abundant use of pathos, yet the influential use of logos and ethos in regards to informational text and literature readings being equally communicated in the English classroom in order to benefit students, as well as, teachers of all fields of study, proved to be…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Rhetorical Reading Strategies and the Construction of Meaning” from Haas & Flowers wants us to understand the true meaning of reading and writing, how we need to see reading as a “constructive rather than a receptive process” (Haas & Flower 167). Targeting students and teachers as well, Haas and Flower managed to develop an article that explains and shows us some misconception of our daily writing life that should be known by everybody. They make questions towards students asking if they really gather all the information that is available in the articles, and if they are available to print them on their writings. Some of the students use a strategy called “rhetorical reading” to get the most out of the texts but only experienced readers managed to use this skill as supposed to. Freshman readers and experienced readers are mentioned and evaluated with the same article, comparing their results, Haas & Flower observed that experienced readers could get more juice out of the readings due to the experience and the previous knowledge in the area.…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The National Curriculum (2014) and the impact it can have on teaching pupils Literacy In Primary Education, teachers are responsible for ensuring pupils reach age – related expectations which are noted in the National Curriculum (NC) (2014). The NC provides statutory and non – statutory guidance for every subject including English which assists teachers. The purpose of the programmes of study in the NC is for teachers to understand what pupils need to learn and helps teachers to plan effective lessons. The NC covers aims which include the teacher’s responsibilities to: “Promote high standards of language and literacy by equipping pupils with a strong command of the spoken word and written word, and to develop their love of literature through widespread reading for enjoyment” (DfE, 2014: 13). The aims also comprise conventional literacy skills which the National Early Literacy Panel…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis: Positivity of Bilingual Education Bilingual education has positively affected foreign children with their overall lives. Kenneth Jost’s, Harvard College and Georgetown University Law Center alumni, article, “Bilingual Education vs. English Immersion” is about the positive significance of bilingual education in public schools. Jeff Bale’s, a language education professor at Michigan State University, article, “Bilingual Education is the Best Approach for English Language Learners” also explains why this type of education is effective for foreign students. Together, both of these authors provide an effective argument with the use of reasoning, credibility, and emotion, but also include logical fallacies. Jost’s and Bale’s…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Priscilla Witte is a first grade teacher in an area that is striving to meet the required Common Core State Standards. Specifically, being able to understand different texts with stable difficulty as they continue to advance through their education. To start she had to find a way to distinctly determine what is considered a complex text. One commonly used system for regulating the difficulty is the Lexile framework, which uses “semantic difficulty of words in a lexical database and sentence length to match books to readers.” (p.30)…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Literacy Instruction Framework The ability to read and write does not develop naturally. Teaching reading and writing to emergent readers and writers needs careful planning and systematic instruction. In a joint position and statement of the National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC) and International Reading Association (IRA), it stated that “learning to read and write is a complex, multifaceted process that requires a wide variety of instructional approaches” (1998, p. 206). Children need regular meaningful and active experiences with print so they can understand from an early reading and writing are valuable life- tools.…

    • 1719 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Tovani’s Chapter 4, Real Rigor: Connecting Students with Accessible Text, the use of accessible texts to compensate for the challenging content presented in social studies textbooks is thoroughly analyzed. Tovani explains how social studies textbooks cannot be the only source of instruction because they lack the format to develop authentic instruction. Aside from being too stiff, textbooks are usually at a more advanced reading grade level than where students are currently at. In order for instruction to be comprehensive and meaningful, teachers have to be aware of alternative approaches for teaching social studies content.…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If he writes the fake document and his friend get the job, because his friend doesn’t have an experience in the job, there is a chance that he could make a mistake and then enter trouble for it, which will lead back to the soldier because he wrote the document. Then, the soldier enters trouble and might have serious issues with the military and can damage his reputation in the…

    • 71 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Behizadeh's Essay

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Let’s face it. Though writing serves as a means of communication (Behizadeh 289), it can be relatively difficult to compose an essay, depending what one writes for. In the broadest of student contexts, there is a difference between writing that occurs at school and writing that occurs at home. However, according to Nadia Behizadeh, authenticity lies in between.…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I chose to examine the LNS Monograph Content Literacy. The monograph explains that content literacy is the, “ability to read, write, create, interpret and present a range of media, in subjects such as science, social studies and mathematics.” (Content Literacy p. 1) Through conversation with my board ESL colleagues, I have discovered that frequently ESL teachers collaborate with classroom teachers to plan, teach and assess ELLs in the content area, therefore, reviewing this monograph was a natural fit for me. The monograph discusses the importance of teaching content literacy skills to increase proficiency in reading and writing across content subjects.…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This week’s reading was the first three chapters of, “Do I Really Have to Teach Reading?” this was an interesting reading. The book expanded on perspectives about teaching reading that I had never thought were important for an adolescent reader to know. “Do I Really Have to Teach Reading,” is an instructional comprehension book that’s primary focus is to teach effective reading strategies. The first three chapters introduce basic ways for teachers to use in order to help their students understand readings, even if the subject is not English/ Language Arts.…

    • 238 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mr Sinnett Analysis

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Mr. Sinnett modeled how to be a great teacher, and writing coach. I thought it was interesting that Mr. Sinnett took his writing strategies straight from the state exams his students would have to take years from kindergarten. That is what teachers ideally want to do, but I think most wouldn’t concern themselves with matching the state exam guidelines unless their grade was taking the test. Mr. Sinnett ensures he is teaching students what they need to know about writing, because these students are being taught originally how to successfully complete this test.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays