Plutarch's Punishments Of Coriolanus Analysis

Superior Essays
The primary goal of the republican politician is to be elected and then reelected. This is necessary for the politician to even exist and must therefore be considered before any other issue. A common result of this is that elected officials will dishonestly try to appeal to the common man to garner votes. History is rife with examples of this. Many contemporary dictators, such as Hugo Chavez and Robert Mugabe, started by being publicly elected. They were able to manipulate the public into putting them into power, and then backtracked on many of the promises that put them in power. Similar things happen all over the world, even in the United States where presidential candidates might promise reforms they have no way of guaranteeing just so they can get in office. In Plutarch 's and Shakespeare’s renditions of Coriolanus, here referenced in tandem to illustrate both the skills and defects of Caius Martius, he is the exact opposite of these types of politicians. The concept of seeming to serve the public to put himself in power is anathema to him. Instead, he shirks a servile representation of himself and displays his character honestly. Martius’ mother instilled in him the belief that to be a good soldier is the same as being a good Roman and this belief left him unable to be a successful politician, ultimately leading to his downfall. …show more content…
Throughout the play there is an open hostility between the tribunes and him. Early on, Martius says of the people, “Five tribunes to defend their vulgar wisdoms, / Of their own choice … / The rabble should have first unroofed the city / Ere so prevailed with me,” (Shakespeare 10). The implication here is clear, that if put into power Martius intends to reduce the powers of the people. To him, the plebeians of Rome are a resource, but they should remain content to be governed rather than aspire to lead

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Livy Vs Plutarch Analysis

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Livy vs Plutarch; a Glimpse at Their Methods The Romans were some of the first detailed historians who were able to really paint a picture of the times when they lived and they took pride in trying to verify their facts as well against other documents. Two such historians, Livy and Plutarch, are amongst the most well know historians of the Roman era. Livy constructed a complete history of Rome from its creation until the death of Augustus, whom Livy served under. Plutarch wrote many historical biographies on the various politicians and important figures of Rome, many of which were exaggerated for his own purposes and many others were lost over the years.…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Oedipus Rex by Sophocles is a work heavily focused on justice. Oedipus, as the king of Thebes, discovers that the only way he can save his beloved city and its people from a rampant plague is to seek and accordingly punish his predecessor’s killer. Oedipus is determined to find justice for the city by harshly punishing the murderer, which he is successful in, but he in turn is penalized with harsh and irreversible consequences. The most pronounce theme in the play is that human beings are relatively powerless before fate and the gods. Although Oedipus tries his entire life to do what is right, by running away from home to save his adopted parents, killing the sphinx, and chasing a murderer, he ultimately faces a horrible end caused by his…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Clever, Clever Brutus Politicians twist the truth. Most of the time, what they say is accurate but the techniques they use have a way of manipulating listeners. All politicians do this, in fictional stories, throughout history, and even to this present day. In William Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, Brutus uses manipulative devices in order to appeal to, pathos in which he evokes the feeling of being loved from the plebeians, logos in order to convince Cassius of his superior military plan, and ethos to establish trust with the commoners. Brutus’s appeal to pathos was intended to extract, from the audience, the most powerful feeling in the world, which is: love.…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The fundamental idea behind Republicanism is that people are no longer individuals, but rather serve a higher purpose than themselves. Similarly, one “Can only be free in absence of domination, absence of a king” and “You can’t…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alexander the Great is known as the King of Macedonia and conqueror of the Persian Empire. One of the writers of Alexander, Plutarch was ethnically Greek, but a citizen of Rome. The author takes famous Greek characters and compares them to Roman characters in his biographies; he has created the romantic picture of Alexander and used the story of Alexander to exemplify what is good leadership, and he does emphasize certain values that would be consider good qualities found in a leader, and the outcome of the use of such qualities. Being biased towards the Greeks, Plutarch successfully made his readers to believe that Alexander is a perfect model of leader by emphasizing maturity (insight) and ambition (courage) of Alexander, and by distorting…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Rise Of Rome

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Livy lamented the republic’s early days, when morality seemed to play a more important role in the patricians’ careers, and wondered, “such decency of feeling, such fairness and magnanimity [that] characterized...the whole body of the Roman commons,” wondering “where would you find it today in a single man” (4.6)? The system was incredibly political; alliances formed, bargains made, blackmail mounted, and careers won and lost by seemingly subtle shifts in favor. This fickle and nebulous power structure threatened to collapse, as it later did with Julius Caesar, if the massive system of checks and balances within the flat government failed to prevent an overwhelming concentration of power in one position or person. To this effect, “some of the governing elite were concerned to prevent prominent and popular senators from overshadowing their peers by too wide a margin. Senators after all, especially the most prominent among them, were participants in a constant competition for fame and glory, and certain very ambitious individuals within this circle may occasionally have desired to achieve an unduly preeminent place in the city.…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The trait of being trustworthy is important to one’s social life. Trust can help you make new friendships or destroy ones you already have. The tragedy of Julius Caesar has a lot to do with that trait. The play has the cast in which two of the main character’s lives end tragically because of one major decision made by one of them, Marcus Brutus, which ended the life of Julius Caesar. Brutus was thought to be trustworthy in the eyes of his close friend Caesar, but Brutus broke that trust by agreeing to the idea of joining Caius Cassius and forming the group of Conspirators against Caesar.…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pliny the Younger, nephew of Pliny the Elder, was a civil servant that governed Bithynia. He was the first to encounter Christians, and was confused on how to adapt to it. So, he wrote a letter to Trajan asking for assistance. This is the soonest inner record demonstrating the Roman Empire's demeanor and arrangement towards the congregation. In addition, Pliny does students of history the immense support of portraying what he has found about the way Christians venerated.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Moreover, Republicans desire to maintain a means to overthrow governmental authorities should a revolution become necessary to secure the rights of freedom and liberty within the country. Republicans also support a minimal level of taxation. They believe in an even taxing grid across all classes of people and businesses. Avid religious upbringings solidify Republican faith in pro-life and traditional marriages between one man and one…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Plutarch vs. Shakespeare: Was Caesar a Good Man? According to the great philosopher Plato, “the measure of a man is what he does with power”. While we know a lot about Julius Caesar’s legendary military and political career; his character is more or less unknown. Was he a ruthless, ambitious dictator; or was he a wise leader whose ultimate concern was for his loyal subjects?…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Those speakers who utilize pathos, logos, and ethos in order to engage their audiences win their favor more often than not. Point being, in Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, the character Antony wins the bona-fide of the Roman people by using the icon of Julius Caesar’s body (post mortem) in order to solicit a hatred in the plebeians against Brutus who used his elements of rhetoric ineffectually. Hence, Antony is more auspicious in his arguments as he has the greater mastery in the rhetorical triangle, hence why he is able to turn the plebeians to mutiny against Brutus despite Brutus delivering an equally impassioned speech. Though Antony and Brutus are both equally utilizing the element of pathos in their respective speeches,…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Crime and Punishment: An Interpretation of Ancient Roman Law enforcement in Pompeii Introduction Today, our police force is affiliated with the slogan, To Serve and Protect. The policemen and women are now trained to perform their duties as protectors of the peace by enforcing law and order and ensuring the safety of the citizens they are put in charge of. However, it has only been since the eighteenth and nineteenth century that “a police force in the sense of a specialized and impartial law-enforcement agency” has been around (Wilfred ix). Before law enforcement became the government institution that we are used to seeing today, it was a system dependent upon the everyday person to ensure that justice was dispatched. This paper explores the world of Pompeii’s law enforcement during it duration as a Roman colony before its destruction by the eruption of Mount Vesuvius in 79 BC.…

    • 2511 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Often times, individuals will find themselves in a position where a difficult decision must be made. This common occurrence is used by authors to develop plots as well as characters. In The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, Julius Caesar is gaining power among the Romans after defeating the previous leader, Pompey. Some Senators are taking note of this, and believe that they need to end this accelerated growth in power by assassinating Caesar. Marcus Brutus, one of Caesar’s dearest friends, must make a decision whether to remain in his friendship, or accept his invitation to the conspiracy in the name of his country.…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Augustus and Caesar: A Comparison Julius Caesar remains one of history’s best generals and propagandists. However, Caesar’s reign came to a quick and brutal end with his assassination. In contrast, Caesar’s inexperienced nephew Augustus would go on to succeed where Caesar failed. Augustus’s rule was long, and inarguably successful. While Augustus’s comparative success might appear to result from historical contingencies, a closer examination reveals that was Augustus was a much shrewder politician than Caesar.…

    • 1606 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Peloponnesian War featured social and political deterioration. Through power struggles, revolutions, land and sea battles, diplomacy, and rapid cultural change, Thucydides demonstrated his belief that human nature is inherently ambitious and ruthless. In his writing on the revolution in Corcyra, he illustrated the conflict between human law and man’s insatiable desires. He saw the revolution of Corcyra as an example of the general decline of Greece during the Peloponnesian War, characterizing the period as full of political strife and chaos that had dire consequences. Many people died in combat and massacres, buildings and property were destroyed, and Greek society experienced moral decay.…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays