The Fallacy Of Ignorance Essay

Improved Essays
Why do obese patients get worse care? Plenty of doctors across the United States do not see past their obesity, and treat them poorly without considering the circumstances and the feelings of the person. Most of the obese patients respond to this kind of poor care by becoming nervous, uncomfortable, and defensive about the situation. The fallacy of appeal to ignorance is presented in all three articles. In this situation, the doctors are treating their patients not how they want to be treated ignoring their knowledge on wanting to get a diet or surgery and in this case the doctors thinking their argument is correct. Doctors are jumping to prescribe diet over medical care for specific ailments and injuries. Treating mostly women that are overweight …show more content…
12, 2016, the article has strong logos as patients are now getting less depression by weight-loss surgery. One problem is a surgery called bariatric surgery is making a lot of development doing decent on the concentration and body of the individual and weight loss measures. But patients that carry with depression due to obesity might affect them in their mental health as too much fat is taking away from them and resulting in a bad habit with symptoms of mood disorder. Another problem is how the doctors are not quite sure if the bariatric surgery might have effects after the surgery for the obese people even that has lower the rates of depression. According to Amina Khan a doctor stated “Mental health conditions might preclude patients from having bariatric surgery, because they’re either not very good surgical candidates or they won’t stand to benefit.” (“Weight-loss surgery”) Meaning doctors do not have enough evidence to prove if this surgery is working at is best. The final issue is some obese patients have diabetes, sleep apnea, or cardiovascular disease and some doctors approve for a surgery even with their conditions not being sure if it will affect them more after or if it will improve their condition. Some doctors decide just finish their work with obese patients so they do not have to deal with them anymore so they let them get surgery if their diet does not …show more content…
The articles present the fallacy of appeal to ignorance as obese women’s opinion is being ignored the most by the doctors, as doctors decide their own argument. One main issue concerning obese patients is that they require their job to be on their feet all day to work making this important because it shows how the patient wants to keep going on his/her feet to continue with their job and require a surgery or a special treatment, but doctors refuse to do it pledging the fallacy appeal of ignorance. Another main issue is how doctors are treating their patients with the X-rays scanners. Patients that do not fit on scanners are sent to different places like a hospital or a zoo, making the patient humiliated heartbroken his/her feeling not wanting to come back and this is appealing solid pathos as is affecting them emotionally. The final main issue is how doctors after completing the bariatric surgery are not quite sure if they might have effects when the patient has sleep apnea or diabetes. Putting them at a very hard position and high risk of whether they would be healthy and on their feet after surgery or if they would get worse. Overall in all three articles doctors do not see past the weight of their patients by taking decisions at their own risk not knowing how far they are hurting, humiliating, or helping their

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The consequences of obesity impact on the individual from all angles: physical, psychological social and economical. On the other hand the costs of obesity affect the entire society as may limit the employment status, becoming dependent on benefits and experiencing poverty. Simultaneously, obese people face discrimination, stigmatisation and stereotyping. This will impact most of the time negatively on an individual 's emotional state. Heath Promotion is recognised to be a key to tackling overweight patients.…

    • 1957 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    This procedure can be extremely risky and is not a surgery designed for everyone looking to lose a lot of weight. Some people have died from the procedure, which is always something that the patient knows before opting to have the operation. For some people, that risk still gives them better odds than if they continue their current lifestyle. There are plenty of people who have had this surgery who have been able to lose a large amount of weight and begin the transition to a healthier life. I think that education about healthy diet and exercise should be implemented even more for people who have bariatric surgery because they must understand that this isn’t another “miracle” solution.…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The article goes on to talk about doctors disrespecting and making overweight patients the base of jokes, even goes as far as saying training hospitals push to make jokes about them. Myself, being overweight, needs to take a step back and really ponder the health decisions I have made and what I could…

    • 129 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She goes on to discuss the reluctance of the government and insurance companies to classify obesity as a disease; she also includes statistics relating to the high cost of treating obesity and obesity-related diseases. While Spake communicates her…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Rethinking Weight,” author Amanda Spake clarifies the issue of obesity and how individuals struggle to lose weight in a society consumed with false prophets. America's stomachs continue to grow as our communities immerse themselves in one of the greatest and most abominable markets: the weight supplement cartel. Spake questions who should cover the overall cost of weight loss programs, and she challenges the policy insurance companies institute regarding the expenses obese people encounter. The writer explains obesity is a biological "disease" (283); therefore, the general population as well as medical professionals should handle and subsidize treatment options for overweight individuals like any other critical illness. Although…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Twenty-two percent of the patients begin to have complications before they even leave the hospital. Bariatric surgery is inviting and seems safe; the advertisements and success stories seem to sell it to the people that are ashamed of their obesity. People are unable to pass up the opportunity of having the body they are promised, but the eye can be deceiving and the body that people see on magazines and in success stories does not show the complications going on inside the body. Eileen Wells was one of these hopeful Gastric Bypass patients ignorant of the dangers and blinded by the success stories of those that had lost hundreds of pounds. Eileen shares her story in Sabrina Erdley’s article, “Gastric Bypass Surgery Can Be Dangerous and Ineffective”.…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    2. Thesis: Obesity is a huge issue in the worldwide and in the United Sates, understanding the significance and consequences of this problem is the key to eradicating it. My paper will address obesity, what it is and what causes the problem. Then it will address the causes of obesity and the health issues that accompany the epidemic. Lastly it will move into who or what is…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Weight Loss Surgery Options Losing weight is a top priority for a growing number of people in the United States and around the world. However, with increasing fast food chains, constant junk food advertising and busy schedules, it is often more difficult to avoid unhealthy eating than it may seem. That is why many people choose one of the many weight loss surgery options. Although patients must change their eating habits before, during and after surgery, the procedure can help get many people on a healthy path toward achieving a healthy body weight.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Worley listens to one doctor because it is what she wants to listen to. Dr. Budd had seemingly caught Worley at an emotional point. Both Critser and Worley bring their points on unhealthy lifestyles and doctors to extremes. Critser assumes that all overweight or obese people are living unhealthy lifestyles, but not uncontrolled health problems that could lead to being overweight or obese. Worley, however, makes the assumption that it is not the fat person’s fault and that health professionals are biased and opinionated in their work.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Rethinking Weight Summary

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Spake spends time to paint the picture of obesity that is caused by not being able to receive the correct treatments. She works to show the desire for opening up better treatments and quotes psychologist Kelly Brownell, “The ramifications could be enormous-for opening up better treatments, and to some extent for social attitudes toward people with this problem.” (Spake 155). Establishing how the change in social ideals will affect obesity, Spake makes it evident that obesity is viewed as negative and with a change in the social ideals about it the discrimination against obesity will become miniscule. Like Spake, Seid also expresses concern for the societal ideals around obesity.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They say obesity is social labyrinth and can be spread from person to person. A common question citizens bring up is how can government help obesity? They can help by providing service to those who can’t afford it. Those who oppose are incorrect when the say government should not play a role in obesity, because they have the resources to make a lasting impact in the obese…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Obesity In England Essay

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Obesity is a medical condition which caused by accumulated excess body fat that stored in certain parts of the body in a harmful manner. (9 ) Majority of the medical practitioners consider obesity as a life-long disease, just like high blood pressure or diabetes; therefore, it should be covered under insurance plans for treatment. Others argue obesity should not consider as disease but as a risk factor for different health issues. They also argue, if Obesity considered as disease, then many countries should be categorized as “disease / sick states”. (13) As per the World Heart Federation 2010 report, globally, almost 3 million deaths a year are contributed by obesity and overweight (7).…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The obesity epidemic in the United States is now three decades old, continuing to worsen over the years. Many Americans are fearful of being categorized as obese because of the risk of other developing health conditions that come along with it, including: heart disease, cancer, diabetes or sleep apnea, just to name a few. Obesity is looked at as a simplistic issue because being larger than others automatically means that one is lazy right? This is the attitude taken towards this subject. Many people do not understand the complexity of obesity, but medical professionals and other researchers are starting to take a look into why the number of people being diagnosed as obese is increasing.…

    • 2108 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Despite the researches that have been done by scientist in numerous cases, we have seen their findings being ignored on the effect of public health on people. However, the effects of obesity on people have been left on those that are obese and they are perceived to be the cause of their failure . In addition, they are said to have adopted a lifestyle which is unhealthier. I examine evidence to address these assumptions and discuss their public health implications.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Individuals suffering from obesity in most cases are always discriminated by the rest of the people that they associate with in their daily lives, this is because many people do not take time or do not completely understand the reason some people may suffer from obesity. While it is true in some cases that obesity is caused by just overeating and a lack of exercise there are also several metabolic disease and conditions that lead to obesity due to their bodies inability to regulate hormones in the body correctly. Since there is no way to distinguish between those obese individuals who have made personal life decisions and those who are effected by disease they all inevitably get lumped into the same category. In many instances, some people take advantage of these situations to mock them while referring to their huge sizes or deformed body figures (Wang, et al, 2014).…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays

Related Topics