Disobedience In Military

Improved Essays
Being married to a member of the armed forces I have been able to experience some of the stress related issues that our service members go through. Much of this stress comes from superior officers. Orders are given to lower ranking members that they sometimes do not agree with. However, our military members are taught to take orders from superior officers no matter if they agree with the orders or not. One of our military foundations is to obey. Soldiers are taught from boot camp to obey with no questions asked. If they don’t listen to orders given to them by superiors they are punished. When a solider commits a crime due to an order coming from a superior officer I believe that the superior officer should be at fault. When an individual …show more content…
From the very beginning military personal are taught to obey orders. Orders ranging from tie my shoe to orders that can sometimes be unlawful. Once an individual steps into boot camp all they receive is orders. For some individuals this can cause fear. Fear of the consequences for not following orders and fear of not being accepted. In fact if orders are given by superior officers and those orders are not followed it is a crime. In Article 90 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, “makes it a crime for a military member to WILLFULLY disobey a superior commissioned officer” (Powers). Also found under Article 90, it states that during times of war if a military member does not obey orders from a superior officer they can be sentenced to death. These rules alone can make any individual fear the consequences of not following orders. Not following orders can make some feel like they might not be accepted. Some individuals will go to great lengths to feel appreciated and acknowledged that they might not even think twice of what is being told of …show more content…
In the 1960’s an obedience study done by Stanley Milgram found that, when a normal person is asked to do something by a superior they will complete the job even if it means killing another human being. Milgrams also stated that, “finding regarding obedience the chaos, fear, and stress of combat (along with the military’s emphasis on obedience) and it is easy to see how civilians and other innocents are often deliberately killed in warfare” (Fichtelberg 129). The book goes on to explain how the stress of combat can make an individual completely different, most of the time acting on fear. Having all these different forces working together can only create

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Disadvantages Of Obedience

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This is an example of how extreme obedience failed. Individuals who are underneath authority and follow commands without question also fall into this category of dangerous obedience. This concept helps understand military processes and its relation to Abu Ghraib. In military courses and drill training soldiers are taught to let go of their ego, and pride to follow direct orders from sergeants and higher military officials without question; blind obedience. Which helps explain why these horrific blood bath type events occurred at Abu Ghraib.…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The setting of a routine which removed the option of making a choice and the dehumanization of the prisoners by maybe attaching crimes they had committed against humanity. Creation of habit by doing the horrific acts repeatedly creates a routine where the soldiers obey and act out of their technical responsibility. The separation of who morally is supposed to be treated right may have encouraged the soldiers to torture and molest the prisoners. This way the guilt of killing the individual is reduced when the soldiers feel they have no moral responsibility towards them since they are “less than”. At the same time the need to obey the authoritative figure giving out the orders on what should be done to the…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abu Ghraib Experiment

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the military, disobedience has consequences. In battle, it is crucial that orders are followed and ranks are respected. Disobedience are also seen asas abuses of position and, if sufficiently grave,…

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I definitely need to warm up to the idea that at times I will need the Authoritarian approach (especially being a Military Training Instructor). My subordinates will need to see me be more assertive and stern instead of the nice guy. This goes for my peers and supervisors as well so they can see me as a truly adaptable leader who ‘adjusts fire’ to fit the needs of the situation or circumstances, and better influence my unit towards the objective. It would take a shift in power influence as mentioned in Module 7 to better accomplish…

    • 1055 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    All of a sudden, one of them said, “I am the enemy you killed, my friend”. Implying that they both didn’t have any personal hatred against the other, both have come all the way by killing the other. Personally, having some knowledge about the military, the most important rules are to first respect all orders from a higher ranked person; secondly the respect of the military rules, leaving no one superior to the rules. The military laws are subjected to clarity, truthfulness, and be against corruption. Most often is seen when a soldier respects the laws to the line it sometimes cause hatred from the bad bosses.…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Walzer asserts that soldiers will inevitably blame someone for all the pain and suffering. The soldier exploits his resentment on the enemy, but not the person who sent them to war. This is ironic because “we know that they are not responsible.” 3). It is practical for soldiers to try to kill each other, but “it is wrong to cut the throats of their wounded or shoot them down when they are trying to surrender.” This proves that war is a ruled-governed activity with morals but in the midst of hell. 4).…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why are orders important to the military lifestyle? Let me start answering this question by giving the definition of an order from the Merriam Webster Dictionary. Military Order: A command proceeding from a military superior. After hearing this definition many people immediately jump to the complaining and judging stage of following instruction. Comments such as, “Why would I follow one man’s opinion,” or “only certain orders apply to me,” are common place among lower ranks in the military.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    NCO’s have a strict code in which they should abide by. This code is taught to those who get promoted into the NCO ranks and, we as NCO’s try and teach it to the solders before they get promoted hoping that that they have a good grasp of it before they themselves get promoted. One of the earliest ways we can start to do this is by putting a soldier into a leadership position early. With hope that they learn this code and set up rules and principles to follow them at all…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If he is not questioned in this world, he will be definitely questioned in the other world that, "you were selected the head of that many number of people, but your selection was not for name or display, rather you were handed over the responsivity of training and watching of those people. Therefore, officials should strongly keep in mind that junior mujahedin should be monitored. Teach them the ethics of jihad and of dealing with people. They should be praised for doing good and reprimanded for doing something improper. The mujahedin Taliban should seriously keep in mind these few words and important guidance mentioned in Mansur sahib speech.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Do people obey them just because they do not have enough courage to walk away? In A Few Good Men, two Marines were ordered to murder their fellow officer by their superior that led them to the consequence where they had to pay for their actions. On top of it, three experiments by prominent psychologists can shed light on obedience and social pressure. In the article of “The Perils…

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays