Pupil Directed Talk Analysis

Improved Essays
Writing in the sixties Andrew Wilkinson commented on the fact that spoken language, or oracy (his term), was neglected in English education. He suggested three reasons why pupil-directed talk was neglected in school:
One is certainly practical - that it is much more difficult to teach oracy than literacy. These difficulties are connected with such matters as the size of classes, the problem of control, the thinness of walls and the absence of teaching patterns. The second is connected with the structure of society - its attitudes, assumptions and rewards. The third is psychological - lack of knowledge until comparatively recently of the relationship between language and thought. (Wilkinson, 1968, p 124)
Observations of classroom interactions
…show more content…
Such relationships provide quiet pupils with feelings of security which allow them to take a more active role in their education. In a chapter entitled "The Social and Emotional Context for Learning" Sally Beveridge (1993) acknowledges that the informal or 'hidden' curriculum of relationships and interactions at school can, "pose considerable demands on pupils with respect to their social competence and their personal resources, such as self-confidence" (Beveridge, 1993, p 91). However, as the following section demonstrates, teachers also need to be aware of what the psychological aspects of habitually quiet behaviour in …show more content…
The interaction is one of answering and talking and group interactions and so on and so forth, and silence does get in the way of teaching particularly by those who are committed to a particular style of teaching. So it does get in the way of working with students and bringing them out to talk about their involvement in the sort of classroom activities which have come to be typical in schools. So it is a problem. It is a problem having students talk about their concerns when teachers and others want to counsel and consult with them. It is a problem in assessing the youngsters when we want to ascertain where they are at in terms of literacy and numeracy for instance. So the phenomenon of silence does pose problems to teaching and learning in our classrooms. But it does not... it does not pose a behavioural problem. It is not something which gets on teachers' nerves. It is not a behavioural problem which causes teachers distress and which impacts on the rights of other

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Deficit thinking is the central topic under study in module four. Jupp (2013) writes, “life and teacher story interviews provided pages upon pages that discussed structural understandings of student differences, yet in a contradictory turn, teachers retained deficit understandings of students as well” (p. 106). Firstly, these structural understandings that Jupp (2013) describes, can be understood as “differences [that] exist in relation of historical and social center and margins” (p. 57). If we look at the social and historical centers in America we can see them as a hegemonic center that has evolved out of western European culture and institutions (Jupp, 2013, p. 57). This in and of itself, is an understanding that many white classroom teachers…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A student’s class is undeniably the central component in his or her social landscape. Students first learn how to connect and effectively communicate with human beings in the classroom when they are grouped together with other children their age. Almost every person’s best friends, social bonds, and romantic interests have been defined by socialization within the school he or she attended. Even homeschooled children regularly meet for outings and “play dates” in order to stimulate social development. The ability to interact, interview, and communicate with other people is important in countless aspects throughout life, especially employment, reproduction, and the sake of personal happiness.…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, getting the majority to understand developing a level of comfort is one of the key elements in reaching out to students. Time and awkwardness should not hold up students from communicating more openly in class with one other because it can lead to good academic standing and develop both stronger social and critical thinking skills. Lifeless…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Writing is a Technology that Reconstructs Thoughts Summary In the article, The Written Word Literacy in Transition: Wolfson College Lectures 1985 by Gerd Baumann, the writer Walter j. Ong has provided the advantages and disadvantages of literacy in society. In the article there is a compelling reason to believe that both literate and oral cultures are important and must be exercised on a regular basis in society. Although literate and non-literate cultures are extremely different, each method has contributed to the advancement of the society. In this summary, you will discover the differences between literate and non-literate cultures as well as the opinion about each method from Walter J. Ong.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Norm Violation Examples

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Dr. Nalkur Sociology 101 Norm Violation Assignment Going against the Norm: Runner Imitator in the Classroom Social context is arbitrary. What society deems as normal and ordinary varies amongst all societies. Going against the norm or expectations for behavior in society, can result in either positive or in my case negative sanctions. Sanctions are either positive or punishing reactions received from others in response to certain behaviors(Nalkur, Lecture Notes). All in all, norms are the expectations and behaviors that the majority of us assign to spaces and statuses.…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Teacher plays important role in creating an environment in which students enhance their cognitive abilities and tell us the importance of social interaction in our real life. The writer told that learning is a continuous process that cannot be stopped and the social interaction is the main tool in progress of our learning. We grow in a social environment where we emphasis on values created by our ancestors.…

    • 1341 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Modelling effective communication is an important part of forming positive relationships for children, who then can form positive relationships with other children and adults. It helps children to feel comfortable if they have something to convey, therefore it helps with their own self-esteem and confidence, although it also benefits everyone. It also helps children to understand what is going on, this can help the children to feel settled, otherwise it could cause an atmosphere which will only make any situation worse. If children have a positive relationship they are more likely to share information about how they feel. Children may not be exposed to positive relationships outside of school, so when they attend school it’s important that they understand what is expected of them and this is done though communication.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wherever we go we must communicate to other people in order to make relationships. There are several concepts and theories that go into interpersonal relationships. In the movie, “The Breakfast Club” there is multiple situations where we see the development of relationships. There are five students that are stuck in detention for eight hours. The five students are named Bender, Claire, Andrew, Alison, and Brian; they are most commonly known by their labels in the school: the criminal, the princess, the athlete, the brain, and the basket case.…

    • 1109 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Technology and education has surged a tremendous amount from what it was decades ago. Advanced computers to super smart phones and new and improved school textbooks are among many of the new breakthroughs. Throughout the story school vs education Russell baker the author argues the deficiencies both school and education depicted throughout his time. Jonathan Kozol the author of “The human cost of and illiterate society” argues that illiterate people are a burden to non-illiterate humans and that they’re sometimes taken advantage of. Both of these stories were written in the mid to late 1900s and everything wasn’t as advanced as it is today.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    For the majority of her students, education and learning are not a top priority and instead, the conflicts outside of the classroom, is of uttermost…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Early years of childhood have widely been recognised as the most important years of learning and development. “Research have shown the importance of these years to learn and acquire new skills” (DEECD, 2010), which have assigned a great responsibility to the educators working with the young children. As an early childhood educator, I feel that it is my responsibility to provide the high quality learning environment for the young children to learn, acquire and develop social, emotional, academic and technological skills. The following paper contains my philosophy statement, which includes my values and professional knowledge in relation to children, teaching and learning in early childhood education. Connor defines philosophy as “it can be used…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout the observations I noticed there was a relatively even amount of information regarding the four developmental domains: physical, cognitive, social, and emotional. The first instance of physical development was in observation two when children were playing outside. Children were climbing the playground and running around in the play area. Children should be encouraged to run around while outside, if they aren’t then children are antsy in times when they need to be quiet and still.…

    • 1597 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Keynote speaker, Clint Smith speaks on the “Dangers of Silence” through the reflection of his own failures to tell the basic, everyday truth. When we hear the word danger, we typically think straight of the actions committed by others that are grave and deadly. Mr. Smith, a writer, and teacher brought an entirely new meaning to the meaning of silence. Clint states that the pure act of silence being recognized as serene causes more danger than any good. He teaches the audience that when we are dealing with controversial issues that demand action from the public, we divert ourselves to keep hushed and automatically become muted in order to avoid the issue at hand.…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Basically, There four three main problem with Maria summarized by Mr. Bennett. Did not be school on time, might cause by flexible school time before; not able to complete reading assignment (poor reading skills), might cause by different language use; trouble with all subject (poor academic skills), might cause by different course schedule; and unable to contact with parents (never responds), might cause by language or not familiar with different types of electrical products. How does linguistic diversity influence classroom performance? Linguistic might cause unskilled language in different ways like reading writing and speaking.…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Classroom procedures are important for every grade level but especially in a kindergarten classroom. Teachers talk about them, teach them, model them and practice them. It is essential to establish routines and procedures involving classroom basics, working procedures, hallway procedures as well as lunch and cafeteria routines. There are a myriad of additional routines involving bathroom, recess, dismissal and bus behavior. I consider the following fifteen procedures/routines to be important in any classroom.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays