Genetic Discrimination Argumentative Analysis

Amazing Essays
The next objection is based on human autonomy and how enhancement strips the right of that. Our autonomy is based on a personal rule of self that is free from outside opinions or controlling interferences. This idea allows every person to have their own mind set without someone controlling every decision they make. When a child starts to grow up they start to become interested in certain things, whether it is sports or dance or even art. Once the child really becomes their own self they will arbitrate the things they like and dislike. When a child is genetically enhanced, their parents have already chosen which type of things the child will be interested in and will completely strip them of becoming the person they desire to be.
Open future
…show more content…
Technically all of the previous points discussed can be considered under the category of genetic discrimination. In this case any type of modification is going against the role of nature. Every path a person goes down is because they were destined to do so, even if it was not the right path, it still helped guide them to where they needed to be. Genetically enhancing genotypes in an unborn child is completely going against nature. Most people will agree in the matter of God brings children into this world as a gift and how everything happens for a reason. As hard as it is to grasp such concepts during times when people have cancer or have a shorter life than expected, it is all a part of nature. If it’s meant to be that every person had some kind of genetic enhancement to improve multiple characteristics, then it would have started in the beginning of time. Discovering this procedure and finding ways to make it safe are just actions of attempting to ‘play God’. People are trying to decide everything about their child and that is not something for them to determine. The idea of genetic discrimination is about parents trying to contribute to every aspect of their child’s life before they are even born, which is something we have no control …show more content…
Steven Pinker, a cognitive scientists and psychologists, wrote an article called The Designer Baby Myth and explains how genetic enhancement is unrealistic. “ Geneticists have failed to find single genes that consistently cause schizophrenia, autism, or manic-depressive disorder, even though there is overwhelming evidence that these conditions are substantially heritable. And if we can’t find a gene for that it’s unlikely to find one for musical talent” (Pinker 816). Researchers have not found accurate ways to determine the genes for autism so it is very unlikely they will be able to distinguish the genes for athleticism. In like manner, all genes are dependent on one another. A positive effect on one gene may cause a negative effect on another creating a result that is not desired. Not only is this procedure nonviable it has absolutely no certainty as to whether it will be effective or

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Human Genetic Engineering and Its Glitches Everybody deserves the right to have control of their own body. When the choice is made by a parent(s) to use genetic engineering to create their wanted child, the fetus has no choice but to be the way it was designed to be. Although human genetic engineering (HGE) is helpful to prevent harmful diseases and disorders, some people selfishly use this method to make a “designer baby,” for which they can create a child with the physical traits they desire. No matter the reasons one has for making the complicated choice for using genetic engineering to create their offspring, the same problems and concerns go along with it. Human genetic engineering has many ethical issues and unnecessary risks; therefore,…

    • 2242 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Lastly, many people search for love their whole life, hoping to find someone to have a family with and continue the human legacy. Whether it is for love or for lust, all humans want to take advantage of their right to choose and find someone who not only makes them happy but satisfies their humanly needs. A Eugenics Program would never be able to exist today because it will put a limit on individuality by allowing the government to control arguably one of the most important decisions of a person’s life. Also, in the Eugenics Program of Equality’s society, a child is forbidden to know their parents (Rand 15). Although in the modern world children often may never meet their parents, the idea is not forbidden because everyone is entitled to know where they came from and who gave them the gift of life.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When combined with in vitro fertilization (IVF) parents can make sure that only selected embryos are transferred to the uterus. PGD was originally designed to prevent serious medical diseases; but most recently, this technology has been developed to screen for other nonmedical reasons which include gender selection, physical attributes or personality traits. Some of them are already possible and, some others are likely to be possible in the near future. It is truly frightening to imagine a world where babies are customized by their parents, and children have no choice about their given characteristics and…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Parents should step back as their children grow and not be a helicopter parent. Though every child is raised differently, the important factors are that your child is successful, happy, and supported. “But happiness as a goal is a recipe for disaster.”, said Lori. Every parent wants to see their child happy, but if you keep wanting them to be happy, what is going to happen once they grow up? The children…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It will cause the child to question themselves and their identity, thus creating a strained relationship with their parents. In addition, there is no guarantee that the child will show the trait that has been genetically modified. For example, if the parents select an embryo to be athletic, and he/she grows up to dislike sports, then the parents would be disappointed because their investment did not get properly utilized. As a result, this leads to unrealistic expectations on children. Furthermore, babies cannot give consent, so is it right for parents to genetically modify their child?…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Like I stated earlier, for many, IUI’s, IVF’s and surrogate motherhood arrangements are not an option for them, however, the other options that are on the table are adoptions and embryo adoptions. I will only talk about adoptions for a short period because all of you should be aware of what adoptions are and also our main point of our discussion does not deal with ordinary adoptions but for embryo adoptions. Adoptions are a great thing for couples who suffer from infertility and for the children who desperately desire to have a loving family. Children who are already living in this world should have a loving family to support and raise them. After all, family is a gift from God and we all should be granted with a family that loves and supports…

    • 1681 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Parenting styles such as giving their child (ren) everything and anything they want. The word “no” is not in their vocabulary because these type of parents believe that their child is God. Yes a child can have some of the wants they want in life, but that should not affect what they truly need. Parents should set boundaries for their child as they grow up, not just let that innocent life believe “whatever you want, you can have” type of life. Loving your child is healthy and good, but thinking your child is better than other children can lead to narcissism, and there is nothing healthy about narcissism (2015).…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    That is mean we do not have the right to select the baby, as we want. According to Muslim and Christian religions they both believe God can alter the genetic makeup of a person due to the sanctity of life.”Only God has the right to interfere with our genes” (Designer Babies). According to this fact Allah (God) is the only one that has the right to create the perfect human. Also, God know what is better for each person. In addition, (Allah) could cause any problems whenever someone tries to replace wrong things to hurt himself or herself because our body is not for us to harm them, they are belong to (Allah) God.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Once the baby is created, parents remove the cells required and give the baby for adoption. Moreover, some parents go ahead and abort the baby. Many couples want this procedure just for enhancing the features of babies, which is more likely playing with the natural Will and Creation of God. (Org, 2015). Abuse of Baby’s Rights When going for designer baby, you actually alter the life and mind of a human being without their permission.…

    • 1474 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In today’s modern society, children often grow up being taught to exercise the religion that their parents claim themselves to be. While growing up, children are not exposed to different types of religion, therefore they are unable to identify themselves with a religion that they choose or fits them the most. Instead, these individuals are being forced to adopt the religion of their parents, and they blindly accept it. Most, not all, of children do not go out and explore all the different religion options there are out there in the world. It would make perfect sense to identify oneself with a religion that meets all of one’s standards, but this is not always the case.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays