The Stone Carvers By Jane Urquhart Analysis

Superior Essays
The Human Beings Inclination to Attain Freedom Nelson Mandela once stated, “There is no easy walk to freedom anywhere, and many of us will have to pass through the valley of the shadow of death again and again before we reach the mountaintop of our desires” (BrainyQuote). Moreover, freedom is a basic desire which everyone seeks to attain. Essentially, it is a part of our human nature to strive for, go after, and achieve, a life of freedom. In the novel The Stone Carvers by Jane Urquhart, a handful of characters experience an unfortunate life without the freedom which they endlessly seek for. They experience a life with no freedom, which leads to the burning craving to sense what being free is like. Consequently, in the poem “Sympathy” …show more content…
In The Stone Carvers, repetition is used to display the characters’ obsession with freedom. Allward’s obsession with demonstrating the freedom obtained by all the soldiers who fought in WWII is seen through the repetitive search for the perfect stone: “He visited quarries in France, Spain, Italy, England; he sent investigated the possibilities of Canadian quarries, American quarries; he sent his emissaries off to the distant corners of the world, rejecting their suggestions….” (Urquhart 270). The endless search for the perfect stone reveals how significant freedom is for Allward. He longs for the freedom, which has been won by the deaths of several soldiers, to be epitomized through an impeccable monument. Allward recognizes how focal freedom is, and that is the reason he is so obsessed with creating a perfect representation of this freedom through the monument. Furthermore, Tilman is the opposite of Allward, as he feels the effect of this obsession through his personal experiences. The repetition of leaving and running away, Tilman creates an obsession with freedom within himself, “ermore, Tilman is the opposite We’ve got to keep moving said Phoebe… You stay still someone’ll put a cage on you sure as anything… Guess you know that don’t you Chain Child?’ …. “Yes,” said Tilman. “Yes, I guess I do.” (Urquhart 185). Tilman understands the significance of not having freedom. Thus, …show more content…
Throughout “Sympathy”, a river is symbolic of freedom. “And the river flows like a stream of glass” (“Sympathy” 4). Rivers are free flowing, as they flow in one direction and it cannot be restricted. This symbol shows that the character desperately wants to be free. Slaves are restricted, having no will of their own because their oppressor forces them into what to do. Moreover. the bird represents a slave, as it is shut in its cage. Hence, in this case, a free flowing river is precisely what the slaves wish they could have. Analyzing this symbol more in depth, the bars represent entrapment: “When he beats his bars and he would be free” (“Sympathy” 17). As the cage takes away the birds freedom, but also, the slaves. This is because the slaves long to be free, but these bars are terminating their desires; they can see their freedom just outside the bars yet they cannot reach it. Thus, they are left with the simple inclination to be free and to attain this freedom. Furthermore, in both The Stone Carvers and “Sympathy”, symbols convey the feelings characters experience when they are restricted of their freedom. It allows the reader to sympathize and attempt to step in the character 's’ shoes, which is an astounding experience for the reader. A river symbolizes the ability to leave whenever a character desires. However, the two materials use

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Compare or contrast how Bronte and Dunbar use form, language and symbolism to present a theme in their respective poems. Emily Brontë was born in Yorkshire, England on July 30th, 1818 (Benvenuto). Brontë grew up in a very strong Catholic home (Benvenuto). She was known to be very reclusive and mostly kept to herself. Brontë lived in the Romantic period, often in these times nature would resemble perfection (Benvenuto).…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Freedom In A White Heron

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In many genres and centuries, one common theme that can be represented is freedom. In Sarah Orne Jewett’s A White Heron, the author discusses many different themes such as liberty, hope and faith. In the beginning of the story, Jewett slowly begins to introduce these main themes with the cow and young Sylvia. It is seen in the second paragraph in page 169, that Sylvia is the character through which Jewett transmits and displays the theme of freedom.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Langston Hughes has been revered as the "’O. Henry of Harlem,’ the ‘Dean of Negro Writers in America,’ and the ‘Negro Poet Laureate,’" as well as “’the Poet Laureate’ of Black America’” (Scott 1; Waldron 140). He was a pivotal figure in the Harlem Renaissance and, in fact, defined the movement from a literary point of view. He also contributed an unsurpassed personal account of the movement in his autobiography The Big Sea (Gates and McKay 1251).…

    • 1638 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1) During his time at the Emergency Child Service, Marc Parent had to witness the horror of child abuse that would haunt him for years. The things he saw and experienced over the years took their toll on him and in return, causing him to doubt his own motives and abilities. It was also due to these experiences that had shaped how he named the title of his book. The phase ‘’Turning Stones’’ can have different interpretation according to the author. This phrase first mentioned in chapter eight, where Marc Parent was recalling the fieldtrip that he had with his classmates.…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In past times African American people were discriminated against and segregated, making a lot of people stand up for their rights in different ways. The speech written by Martin Luther King, “I have a dream” and the poem written by Langston Hughes, “Harlem”, both of them talk about the times of the brutality over African American people. The two works are similar because they both talk about African Americans not having the right of freely expressing their dissatisfaction with oppression. However, the two works are different in that one has a message with hope and the other one is without any optimism.…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Langston Hughes wrote “Harlem” as a prediction of the upcoming clash African Americans would embrace in order to gain civil liberties. The poem also serves as a rallying cry to those pondering what to do with their frustration of the way blacks were treated in America before the civil rights movement. Hughes delivers an emotional appeal to readers, urging them to wake up and see the future of a people bursting with ambition but held back by discrimination. In the poem "Harlem" Hughes uses figurative language to powerfully convey the consequences of oppression which deny black Americans the dream of equality. Hughes uses similes, anaphora, alliteration, and metaphor to help the reader visualize and empathize with the plight of African Americans…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1917-1938, The Harlem Renaissance was in full swing. In a small New York brough called Harlem, black people were beginning to gain social, cultural and artistic freedom. Black poets, writers, musicians and scholars flocked to Harlem in search of these freedoms. Many poets wrote about the hardships faced with racism to help express their feelings against oppression. In “We Wear the Mask” and “Sympathy”, Paul Laurence Dunbar depicts the harmful effects of racism through the use of symbolism, violent imagery, and a gloomy mood to develop the theme that oppression by society causes a desire for freedom among minorities.…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sometimes life is best explained in metaphors. Sometimes the hurt, pain, and anger found in life are more easily grasped when one looks at them in terms of other objects. This is how the poem,“The Minefield,” written by Diane Thiel, looks at pain and anger. Written in short and choppy lines with no clear rhythm or rhyming pattern, this poem tells the story of a man who witnessed his friend blown to pieces in a minefield. Because of this, the man who witnessed this terrifying tragedy has grown into an angry and broken soul.…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The boat is pushed along genteelly and guided by the wind, verses being instructed and forced by a whip which draws nothing but pain and suffering. This next part also ties in, “You are freedom’s swift-winged angels, that fly around the world; I am confined in bands of Iron! O that I were Free!” I think there is a double meaning hear as we can see that the boat is free, but is referred to as an angel. Angels help and protect followers of Christ as instructed by God and therefore I think he is also referring to the fact that they can be used to escape slavery upon the boats.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout her stories in “Teaching a Stone to Talk,” Dillard uses juxtapositions, analogies and imagery to demonstrate the raw beauty of the natural world and humans’ lack of awareness of it. Nature, as explained by the author, refers to the natural, physical world, and life that is lived by necessity rather than choice. The word nature itself is derived from the Latin form, natura, which means "essential qualities and innate disposition." A general concept is that all things, biotic or abiotic, are a part of nature, yet Dillard defines the natural world as all, that which is unaltered by human interference. Dillard acknowledges humans as members of the natural world, but makes a clear effort to differentiate actual nature from the artificialness…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Road to Freedom In his excerpt “Learning to Read and Write”, Public speaker, editor, author and former slave, Frederick Douglass, recounts his path to learning how to read and write in order to escape to the north to be a freed man. In order to convey his strong emotions of helplessness and loathing, Douglass effectively uses metaphor and references to animals to convince abolitionists to sympathize with his situation. Douglass begins his narrative by recounting the instruction from his mistress to teach him how to read and write. The words used to describe the transition of his mistress after her “training in the exercise of irresponsible power” (Douglass 100) inject a fear like prey has to predator to appeal to the intense emotions of…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Freedom is an important idea. It is a common goal for everyone at some point. “For to be free is not merely to cost of one’s chains, but to live in a way that respects and enchanges the freedom at others” (Nelson Mandela). Freedom is hard to achieve at times but if you really want it, you will fight for it. If not you will just have to wait until it comes to you, that is if it can.…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humans are continuously evolving with their surroundings, leaving the past behind. However, certain aspects of the past can cause mental pain to the extent that humans need to eliminate the thought of being defeated or taken advantage of using inhumane measures. The Cask of Amontillado written by Edgar Allen doe and Stone Mattress written by Margaret Atwood are two short stories based around the violent acts due to the distress caused previously in life. This distress affects one’s emotion, disturbing their moral and ethical thinking when resolving the issue. ‘Revenge’ is the natural human extinct when it comes to mending an unhinged past, and in order to take revenge, the idea of false ‘trust’ is applied to make the revenge as insufferable…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Strength is often misinterpreted as showing no emotion. In Margaret Laurence’s novel The Stone Angel, The protagonist, Hagar Currie/Shipley is strongly influenced by her father, Jason Currie. Jason taught Hagar to be tough and tenacious. Hagar shields her weakness with her inability to help her peers. Hagar unsuccessfully plays the roles of a maiden, wife, and mother in her life.…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Before starting to discuss Taylor’s argument, it is necessary to look at Berlin’s distinction of liberty in “Two Concepts of Liberty”. Berlin argues that there are two types of liberty, positive and negative. The freedom from external interference is what he calls negative liberty, and the freedom to act upon one’s…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays