When Hamlet finally completes his destruction of evil, he really has just committed murder. When Hamlet brutally forces Claudius to “drink off this potion” (5.2.357), Hamlet, in essence, does the very same evil act that Claudius did to the former king. They both are guilty of murdering someone with poison, and if Claudius is considered evil for murdering the former king, then Hamlet must in turn be evil for murdering the current king. Of course, perhaps one can say that Claudius deserved death as death seems to be a fitting punishment. Nevertheless, though, murdering a murderer doesn’t make murder not evil. This argument could go on in more directions, but it must come to a point that murder, even if it’s the murder of a murderer, is always evil. As a result, no matter how one attempts to destroy evil, one eventually becomes
When Hamlet finally completes his destruction of evil, he really has just committed murder. When Hamlet brutally forces Claudius to “drink off this potion” (5.2.357), Hamlet, in essence, does the very same evil act that Claudius did to the former king. They both are guilty of murdering someone with poison, and if Claudius is considered evil for murdering the former king, then Hamlet must in turn be evil for murdering the current king. Of course, perhaps one can say that Claudius deserved death as death seems to be a fitting punishment. Nevertheless, though, murdering a murderer doesn’t make murder not evil. This argument could go on in more directions, but it must come to a point that murder, even if it’s the murder of a murderer, is always evil. As a result, no matter how one attempts to destroy evil, one eventually becomes