Dysfunctional Leadership In The Workplace

Good Essays
The work field is an institution where citizens commit their time to make an outside living. In the work field, there are leaders that can make decisions for the company, and there are leaders that can’t. Leadership, by definition, would be people who are in charge of organizations and their subordinates (Hogan & Kaiser, 2005). Yet, there is more to leadership than just being in charge. Leadership is an essential trait that not everyone has and can execute effectively. In the workplace, this trait is vital for production and collective agreement. Managers and higher level employees of a company, such as Human Resources, need this trait; however there are two versions of leadership. Managers with effective leadership can have a productive work …show more content…
Similarly, the way to test for dysfunctional leadership is to also use the Big Five Personality test (Leary, et al., 2013). If an individual takes the Big Five, and all the traits are on the negative spectrum, it can have a high correlation with leadership effectiveness. It can cause counterproductive behavior which can degrade performance with themselves and their peers surrounding them (Leary, et al., 2013). This type of behavior can lead to stressful events that can cause turnover in the workforce. Some of these events could be harassment in the workplace, narcissistic replies towards other employees, absenteeism. These examples that dysfunctional managers show can cause burnout in the subordinates. It causes absenteeism and the lack of motivation for some people with this type of manager. Narcissism plays a major role in poor leadership skills. Narcissist usually are self-motivated however, they seek admiration from others about their superiority (Judge, LePine, & Rich, 2006). The tactic of seeking admiration is self-defeating in the long run, because it undermines personal relationship (Judge, LePine, & Rich, 2006). Meaning that it can damage relationships and could cause a subordinate to veer away from a narcissistic manager. They won’t listen to their manager, thus productivity will decrease. This can cause turnover in corporations and could lead Human …show more content…
The company saw a major decline in satisfaction in one year, which lead to their overall earnings decreasing. The overall earnings for the company decreased 72 percent (The LensCrafters Vision , 2011). The company discovered that the managers weren’t being trained properly and their leadership styles were severely lacking. They were lacking directing, coaching, supporting, and delegating towards their subordinates (The LensCrafters Vision , 2011). Lacking those traits caused a turnover with the managers and their employees. It had a snowball effect because the turnover of employees also meant sales went down for the company. This leads to a concern that some managers only perform well when a person of higher power appears. Some managers will be more productive, and have more effective performance when a district manager or human resources appears. This problem of poor character can lead corporations into bankruptcy (Conger & Hollenbeck, 2010). Some subordinates will even take matters into their own hand and show effective ways management, even when they don’t have the power to make some of the calls (Conger & Hollenbeck, 2010). Even though it might be positive for the subordinate, it might make the company itself look bad. They might believe that they hired or promoted the wrong individual, clearly with the wrong mindset and traits to lead a

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Low Morale

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This means that the company could lose valuable employees to a competitor which would be a sad site in our eyes. The previous argument also leads to another point for low morale within the organization, which is how the company is being run. A main question which you should ask yourself is, “Does the company have a great leader, or are you working under a person with poor leadership skill?”. Poor leadership skill can also have a negative influence on the morale of the company, which is why it’s key to have a manager that has the qualities required for a the…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Lastly, item three “omitting key facts when speaking to the media after crises” will be viewed by many as unethical. When companies are purposely deceitful in communication and consumers find out, they instantly have negative and unethical thoughts of that business. Proceeding on to part two of the assignment; examining item eight, if the communicator is not concerned with the ethical factors of negatively motivating employees they risk alienating the work force. Even worse if performed in a biased way towards some employees, some may claim discrimination. Repercussions of the communicator for item four, if not done ethically may include, people leaving the organization prior to the actually layoffs if they find out.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Unethical Legal Issues

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The authors had report that harassment can affect job satisfaction and organizational commitment, while bullying increases problems. This sort of behavior, the study report, affects perpetrators, victims and witnesses as well as associated people. For example, if bullying creates problem an organization may be less productive, leading stockholders to suffer financial losses. This ethical problem could also affect the staff at the company by making them not care about their job and which would affect their performance. An employee working for an employer or company with unethical, deceptive, and dishonest conduct will be directly affected physically and mentally, and may even come down with emotional and health related problems because of it.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Employees are become less productive due to the monotonous nature of their work. Poor morale among workers has been blamed for the problem which is increasingly affecting the performance of many firms. Absenteeism and lack of motivation among workers is to blame for the overall poor performance of these organizations. This report focuses on providing probable solution for the problem by comparing two different alternatives that firms can adopt. This report identifies hoteling and job sharing as the best option in boosting the morale of employees to increase the performance of companies.…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    c. Negative feedback with sites such as Glassdoor.com a business can be put on shame for not being kind to their employees and treating them as cattle. Either not being consistent with what management is telling an employee of or simply giving them negative feedback by not addressing 3. Result of Bad management: (Rocio) Overall, if an employee’s needs are not heard and the employee is not put first then you can pretty much expect your business to fail if you do not plan on someone addressing…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The lack of employees has produced an initial increase in monetary savings but the prolonged effects of not having adequate employees will yield a large decrease in the revenues over an extended period Fd gqert q4tq gqert notice a lack of employees manning the store. If you have a question about a product good luck trying to hunt someone down to assist you with your inqucdtrt;qwerkqwe’r233343240234l’iry. Often times you will feel as if you are the only one in the store. This is due to the fact that TheStore has trimmed the company employees down below an acceptable level for conducting normal business operations. The lack of employees has produced an initial increase in monetary savings but the prolonged effects of not having adequate employees will yield a large decrease in the revenues over an extended period Fd gqert q4tq gqert notice a lack of employees manning the store.…

    • 52230 Words
    • 209 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Case Study Perfect Pottery

    • 1041 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This was the largest problem because if the morale increased then it would eliminate so many other problems. The people that are affected include both the employer and employee. It effects the employees because if one person hates their job and complains then it’s going to put the rest of the employees in a bad mood. This results in a chain reaction and by the end of the day just about everyone else will be in a poor mood. This is also bad for the employer/boss because it means that the employee is more likely to do a poor job at the tasks they need to complete.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kerrie Peterson Case Study

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There is bitterness among the members as exposed through the exchanges during the meeting. The change will also not be supported by the account managers as they think that the changes are to benefit the senior management at their own expense. Kerrie’s inexperience in leadership is also brought up as the redesign team findings highlight poor communication. All in all, means of achieving the 15% cost reduction goal are proposed to be reducing travel expenses and other discretionary expenses and redesigning how employees carry out their operations (to limit the low value adding activities). It is expected, that there is likely resistance from the workforce as the rumors have already started going around.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Roberts & Pregitzer (2007) note that rating bias, hypocrisy, poor informal feedback, poor communication during formal feedback sessions, and rater errors are factors that create animosity towards feedback systems. However, this can be solved through a balanced system that uses maximum effort from the managers. There are multiple aspects to an employee's performance that should not only focus on quantitative results but job knowledge and skills, quality of work, work habits, and attitude (Capko, 2007, sec. 3-7). Along with an ineffective appraisal system, downsizing can leave to detrimental effects on the company.…

    • 1861 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When inept bosses misdirect you in your job, it creates extra work and it also potentially points the blame to you, which might even cause you to get fired. Having an incompetent boss not only causes increased difficulty at work, but it also means you are deprived of a mentor. When you…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics