Analysis Of Yoshino's Covering: The Hidden Assault On Our Civil Rights

Improved Essays
If you only ever see yourself in tragic stories, do you learn to expect sadness? If you only ever see people concealing pieces of themselves, do you learn to hide elements of yourself? Despite the changes that are occurring in American society concerning the acceptance of LGBTQ+ people our representation in the media is deeply problematic. One of the fundamental problems is that TV, like society, asks its LGBTQ people to cover. According to Kenji Yoshino the author of Covering: The Hidden Assault on Our Civil Rights, covering is "to tone down a disfavored identity to fit into the mainstream" (Yoshino 2006: ix). In Covering Yoshino examines the consequences of covering in the queer community, specifically how it affects our rights as citizens …show more content…
He believes that covering is the dark side of assimilation and "the most widespread form of assimilation required of us today" (Yoshino xi). Covering is the act of disguising unfavorable characteristics but not removing them completely. According to Yoshino to cover is to make oneself more able to assimilate into heterosexual culture, but is not the same as passing which is to pretend to be heterosexual. Covering is the key to being accepted as a LGBTQ+ member of society and is the way most LGBTQ+ characters are scripted on TV. On its most basic level covering is the way to separate the Gays from the Queers. Yoshino explains this distinction in terms of vulnerability. When he decided between going to Law School or to pursue writing he said," I decided on law school in part because I had accepted my gay identity. A gay poet is vulnerable in profession as well as person. I refused that level of exposure" (Yoshino 12). Behind the title of a lawyer, a profession that is seen as both highly masculinized and vital to society, the fact of Yoshino 's homosexuality becomes less important and less visible as it could be if he were a writer. The difference laying in the amount society believes one 's identity influences their profession. Moreover, to be a lawyer who is gay is still to be a productive and valuable member of society, a 'respectable deviant ' someone who does not let their …show more content…
When applying a larger gradient to both sides of sexuality you get a spectrum of heterosexual privilege and homosexual privilege; and while a privileged homosexual will never reach the status of a privileged heterosexual, they do have power over less privileged homosexuals, who are the Queers. Privileged homosexuals, sometimes colloquially referred to as the Hetero-Gays, are those who conform to a heterosexual lifestyle who fulfill the societal expectations of what it means to be a couple. Complete with the white-picket fence, steady careers, two children and the min-van, the Hetero-Gays are the ultimate coverers. They are the people who are accepted into mainstream society because they actually do belong, they are assimilated to a point where their homosexuality is but a fun element to spice up the neighborhood. This sect of homosexual people are the standard that society holds all other LGBTQ+ people to and sees those who do not conform as flaunting their homosexuality, something they could easily hide like their more respectable

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    There is hope for a better reality of Americans when the few come together as a group, exposing themselves and others, and the documentaries Tough Guise 2 and Miss Representation speak to men and women and how they can change their bad gender image sold to them by the media. Tough Guise 2 observes men bred by the media to be leaders in America’s violent crimes. Miss Representation observes the role the entertainment industry plays in defining gender roles, but takes a closer look at what women can do to fight gender inequality in political spectrums where their positive example is lacking in areas where males predominate, and therefore attempts to do something about gender representation. Without diverse input from men outside the realm of the most famous, both documentaries miss an opportunity to reach an audience of men that could use their power to stand up against the plight of gender misrepresentation in the media.…

    • 1168 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Misrepresentation affects us all to some degree. Maybe one night you didn’t get enough sleep and you were grumpy all day. That’s an unfortunate misrepresentation, but what about if the media displayed you as a grumpy person every day? “It Ain’t Easy Being Bisexual on TV” by Amy Zimmerman seeks to describe the current state of bisexuality’s representation in the today’s media by analyzing a popular TV shows. Daily Beast, a liberal leaning website, published this article in August of 14. The piece is Intended for those who understand the concerns and identity of bisexual individuals and take interest in popular culture. This article only fails to accomplishes the aims of the writer. Zimmerman’s limited substance diversity, excessive assumptions,…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This evolution, for the most part, has which has lessened the taboo, and subsequent protest, of representing the LGBTQ+ community on television, and representing them with greater diversity and in increasingly romantic and sexual situations that would have been prohibited in the 1990s, thus lifting restrictions of their representations from either middle to upper-class non-sexual successful white men or stereotypical overly sexually men who are never actually depicted in sexual situations, like the characters in “Men on Film”, to more realistic, nuanced, and diverse LGBTQ+ characters. For example, How to Get Away with Murder, though similar to slumpie targeted program, portrays a variety of LGBTQ+ characters, not just gay white men, and their relationships are consistently present throughout the series, not just a few skits like “Men of Film” in In Living Color. Furthermore, they are presented in more complex, nuanced, and respectful ways, rarely as the punch line, as opposed to the flat stereotypical characters of “Men on Film”. However, it is important to recognize that this programming environment was established in order to promote profitability through the attraction of quality audiences and was only aided by sociopolitical conditions due to the fact that the new liberal conditions decreased homophobic backlash that could negatively affect the program’s…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Amy Zimmerman's article, “It Ain’t Easy Being Bisexual On T.V”, Zimmerman showed her fear and concern for the children who would be influenced by it. She argued that the main reason for these extreme stereotypes were the T.V. She not only speaks to those who think they are homosexual and bisexual, but also raise consciousness to the immediate individual. The purpose of this article is to inform people that the media portrayed homosexual and bisexual personal community errors.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Privilege in relation to society view is an influential social grouping where some individuals have massive advantages over other groups. This term is frequently associated with social inequality most especially in relation to various types of groupings such as social class, gender, race, and disability among others. Importantly, individuals’ gender, race, as well as social class are undeniably the imperative determinative of the people’s general level of privilege. In terms of the societal perception, privileged individuals are considered as the norm, since they gain immense invisibility and ease in the entire society whilst others are seen as inferior variants (Karsten, 2006). The noteworthy and specific examples of privilege in my life consist of, white…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hollywood is American society’s guilty pleasure and the most frequent used source of entertainment. People rush to the movies in flocks for an opening premier of Hollywood’s latest blockbuster hit. Therefore the movie and television industry has become so much a part of American culture that society fails to question what is actually being broadcasted. People become sublimely oblivious and subconsciously record everything they watch on these theatrical screens, that any unrepresented ethics or morals are simply disregarded. Minorities are so highly misrepresented in a way that society falsely labels their identity, origin and culture. It is the entertainment industry’s social obligation to neglect teaching society…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evidence shows there is an incline of violence directed towards those who do not display heteronormativity. Racism and homophobia work together hand in hand through institutional prejudice. On the bright side, LGBTQ and Two-Spirit officials are making headway up the political ladder (p.3). Hunt & Homes articulated how LGBTQ & two-spirit people are not even fully safe at home. It may be possible be “site of oppression, violence, and surveillance” (p.159). The bisexual umbrella as previously mentions includes all people who do not have attraction for only one gender or monosexuality, including two-spirit people. A common misconception of the umbrella is to promote homogeneity, when really it is providing a common place for all non-heterosexual individuals to fall under (Flanders,…

    • 1145 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A study was conducted by GLAAD, an organization that monitors the media portrayal of LGBT characters, in which they found the 2013-2014 TV season had “46 LGBT characters in total, out of which there were only 10 bisexual characters.” If that wasn’t a small enough number, “out of that minuscule number of bisexual roles, only two were male characters” goes on to describe just how little bisexuality is actually portrayed in the media. The world in the media is nothing like the world that actually exists, as Zimmerman points out that the bisexuality portrayed is “either a fun voluntary act of experimentation or a mere myth through two tried and true tactics: misrepresenting and oversimplifying bisexual characters until they are either punchlines or wet dream fodder, or simply refusing to portray bisexual characters in the first place.” By reducing bisexuality to experimentation, myth, punchlines and wet dreams, the media makes bisexuals feel invalid or confused, as Zimmerman uses pathos to make the audience feel sympathy for those who are reduced to such demeaning…

    • 1780 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It has always been known that basic human nature embeds the will to reach satisfaction and conformity in society through all means. Due to this, acceptance is customarily regulated to fit the requirements created by those who are considered superior. As individuals we are pressured to assimilate in order to fulfill the emotional void in the social aspect of their life. In Kenji Yoshino’s “Covering: The Hidden Assault on Our Civil Rights”, the concept of “covering” is introduced as a means to assimilate into the melting pot of society but is also viewed as a threat to both moral dignity and the civil equilibrium deserved by humanity. Covering can be defined as hiding one’s natural identity to meet the standards that are required of the individuals. The power of covering leads to demands that damage one’s integrity but remains relevant to American society due to its immense…

    • 873 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Abigail Graber's article “Television Encourages Viewers to Reject Homosexuals”, Graber faults media depictions of LGBT people as part of the reason gay people are discriminated against in places such as the workforce (Graber). Negative stereotypes in media depicting homosexuality as taboo and perverse have helped spread homophobia. Stereotyping LGBT people only furthers perceptions that being LGBT is abnormal, and thus treating them differently than heterosexuals is socially acceptable. Newsweek reporter Ramin Setoodeh notes that most gay men depicted in media are that of the effeminate flamboyant type that is widely regarded as a stereotype (Setoodeh). The idea that almost every gay male is effeminate and do stereotypical acts like “snapping a Facebook picture of Lady Gaga” (Setoodeh) is outdated and inaccurate. This widespread notion leads straight people to think that all gay men are freaks because they do not adhere to gender roles, making them different and thus bad. It also makes gay men who don't fall into such stereotypes feel less accepted within the gay community, or at least, the gay community as depicted in the media. This can lead to questioning over whether or not said person is gay enough, and constant sexuality questioning creates a sense of confusion and anger. Of course, whether or not these stereotypes should be considered offensive at all is a topic that divides the LGBT community, generally across an age gap (Setoodeh). Younger members of the gay community, who have faced less persecution for being gay and generally feel as if they are more accepted (Setoodeh) than older members of the LGBT community who were out before civil rights victories for LGBT people, feel as if the effeminate gay stereotype isn't harmful to the community, especially if they embody some characteristics of the stereotype. The failure of…

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In choosing to watch a film for the diversity activity, I chose to watch “The Laramie Project”. reporters chose to create a movie on the murder case of the homosexual college student Mathew Shepard, whom attended the university of Wyoming. The reporter who traveled to Laramie Wyoming were homosexual as well, a few of them where not sure about going because they were afraid that since Mathew Shepard was murdered for being himself that that could potentially be harmed. The homosexuals who were already present their shared the same fears with the reporters, who were at times silent about their sexuality. The population in Wyoming was very small so they attitudes…

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The usage of the words “gay” or “homo” in a negative way can further normalize heterosexism. Within chapter four, “Sentimental Education” of The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, Yunior describes the dorm Oscar lives in as “Homo Hall” because it was full of “weirdos and losers and freaks and fembots”(Diaz, 170) (Fembots is a term often used to describe a feminist who is very adamant that women are oppressed in every situation they encounter.) Yunior’s use of the word Homo doesn’t refer to the sexual identities of the occupants but that they are stupid and do not fit properly into society. The use of the word homo as a way to refer to something as stupid or abnormal can lead people to think that queer people are stupid and abnormal. The word gay used as a substitute for stupid comes about again when Yunior and Melvin are talking to Oscar about the sign on his door. Melvin says the sign written in Sindarin is “gay-hay-hay,”(Diaz, 172) meaning that the sign is silly and lame. The usage of the words homo and gay in this way can also further intensify homosexual panic. If a person who associates the words gay and homo with words like stupid, lame or abnormal, they will have a bigger reaction to being called gay or thinking that they might be gay(Parker, 210). By associating “homo” with “abnormal” then we are also associating “hetero” with “normal” and further…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Heterosexuality is an implied privilege by the Black community, however, scholars argue that they are “psychologically enslaved” (Pentony, 1971, p. 61), and believed to be constraining themselves from their privileges instead. The mythical norm, “defined as white, thin, male, young, heterosexual, Christian, and finally secure” (Lorde, 2001, p. 178), has been eluding individuals who desire to fit the norm. However, when this mythical norm is unobtainable, then the privileges are unrecognized. In fact, the homophobic behavior is immensely prevalent in Black communities than White communities. Black men are inclined to reinforce their heterosexuality with “strength, athletic prowess, and high rates of sexual activity and potency” (Harris, 2009,…

    • 171 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My understanding of this is that many leaders, religions, and people have decided to use being LGBTQ as a reason to treat people like they are less than human. This is comparative to the way some leaders have decided that others from another race or ethnicity are less because of their skin color, beliefs, or any excuse to commit genocide and other atrocities against human beings. It is a skewed way of viewing things, albeit, one that continues to cause inequality to all…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Diversity In Media

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The main stream media’s lack of racial and sexual diversity is a growing problem in America. Sonia Saraiya, author of the article The Burden of Representation, talks about how the representation of minorities in the media is full of stereotypes, marginalizations, exploitations and misrepresentations from an industry that is almost solely based on appearances. The author is correct because there is lack of diversity in the main stream media, which leads to the formation of stereotypes, loss of self-esteem and lack of opportunities.…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics