Orwell intentions for the torture scenes were most probably to reveal the truth behind Oceania’s government and Winston’s character, but it may have revealed just as much about O’Brien himself. He is a member of the Inner Party, the rich upper class, and he therefore holds much of the power (Orwell 168). O’Brien gives most of his lesson through a simple math problem, one which Winston introduced earlier in the novel: What is two plus two? O’Brien seems to know that two plus two, by the laws of nature, is four, but chooses to believe that two plus two, by the laws of the Party, is five (Orwell 249-254). This reveals Orwell’s view that fascist governments are, by their nature, contradictory to themselves. The only way that they may function is by blind support and love by the general population; any form of intelligent thought would be detrimental to the regime, possibly resulting in change. And, as many fascist governments normally function under the guise of socialism, the presence of a more powerful higher class does not fit with the government’s theoretical modus operandi. Orwell believed that these governments could only form because the aforementioned higher class wished to keep control over the people of their country
Orwell intentions for the torture scenes were most probably to reveal the truth behind Oceania’s government and Winston’s character, but it may have revealed just as much about O’Brien himself. He is a member of the Inner Party, the rich upper class, and he therefore holds much of the power (Orwell 168). O’Brien gives most of his lesson through a simple math problem, one which Winston introduced earlier in the novel: What is two plus two? O’Brien seems to know that two plus two, by the laws of nature, is four, but chooses to believe that two plus two, by the laws of the Party, is five (Orwell 249-254). This reveals Orwell’s view that fascist governments are, by their nature, contradictory to themselves. The only way that they may function is by blind support and love by the general population; any form of intelligent thought would be detrimental to the regime, possibly resulting in change. And, as many fascist governments normally function under the guise of socialism, the presence of a more powerful higher class does not fit with the government’s theoretical modus operandi. Orwell believed that these governments could only form because the aforementioned higher class wished to keep control over the people of their country